Local Govt | National News Video | Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Search

 

Concern About Need To Pursue Court Action

5 April 2001

Councillor Kay McKelvie, Chairperson of Auckland City Council’s Finance and Property Committee, said today she was extremely irritated by the need to yet again pursue court action against businessman Mr John Spencer.

Mr Spencer has been in dispute with the Council since 1983 on the matter of public ownership of roads at the eastern end of Waiheke Island.

The disputed 7.3 kilometres of public road built by the Waiheke County Council in 1969/1970 completes the loop around Waiheke and provides the only public road access to the vicinity of the historic gun emplacement known as Stony Batter.

In 1997 the High Court found that the disputed roads were public roads belonging to the Council. This was followed by two Appeal Court dismissals of appeals lodged by Mr Spencer. He has now obtained leave from the Court of Appeal to appeal to the Privy Council.

The Finance and Property Committee has recommended that the Council defend Mr Spencer's appeal to the Privy Council and that the matter of costs in the High Court be pursued.

"Auckland City Council has no realistic option other than to oppose Mr Spencer's appeal to the Privy Council and conclude this dispute," said Councillor McKelvie.

"Over a period of nearly 20 years, the Council has spent $1.2 million, mainly in legal costs, on this case and we must look to recouping some of those costs, as well as ensuring the public has the access to property that is rightfully theirs," she said.


For further information, please contact:
Councillor Kay McKelvie, tel: 864 7076 or 025 279 6448.


BACKGROUND INFORMATION ATTACHED.

The following is a brief summary of events to date in this case:

1969/70 Roads built by the Waiheke County Council with financial assistance from Government’s 8:1 Backblocks Roading Fund.

1979/80 Mr Spencer buys the relevant land. It was soon clear that he did not accept the Council’s view that the roads were public roads.

1983 Council filed its claim in the High Court to resolve the dispute.

September/ October 1996 Trial of the case in the High Court at Auckland before Justice Anderson.

August 1997 First decision of the High Court. The Court found that approx. 7.3 kilometres of the disputed roads were public road belonging to Council. Council’s claim failed only in respect of two parts of the roads – a short distance of a few hundred metres from the boundary of one of the Spencer titles to Stony Batter, and ‘the south western deviation’ (which connects the road at Man O’War Bay to the south western entrance of the Spencer properties).
As a consequence of these decisions the Court awarded damages of $15,000 to Mr Spencer for Council’s trespass over the parts of road that were not found to be public. There was also an award of $5,000 to Mr. Spencer to compensate for gates removed from the roads from time to time by the Council. On the other hand the Court dismissed a counterclaim brought by the Spencer interests against Council for approximately $2 million.

July 1998 Second decision of the High Court. This was necessary because Mr Spencer had refused to agree about the width of the roads dedicated as public road. The Court upheld Council’s argument that a minimum width of one chain applied. This decision also clarified various details of the earlier decision and allowed the parties to formally seal the judgement and initiate to appeal process.
Page Four

March 2000 First Court of Appeal hearing. At Mr Spencer’s request a full court of 5 Judges was convened.

April 2000 First decision of the Court of Appeal. Mr Spencer’s appeal was dismissed. A cross appeal by Council was allowed with the result that (a) the south western deviation was found to be public road belonging to Council and (b) the award of damages in Mr Spencer’s favour was reduced by $10,000. The decision was unanimous. The Court also ordered Mr. Spencer to pay Council costs of $15,000. and disbursements in connection with the case in the Court of Appeal.

May - July 2000 Mr Spencer initiated the process for an appeal to the Privy Council in London.

27 November 2000 Second decision of the Court of Appeal dismissing Mr Spencer’s claim. The Court also awarded Council further costs of $3,500 and disbursements in connection with the second Court of Appeal hearing.

December 2000 Mr Spencer obtained conditional leave from the Court of Appeal to appeal both the substantive decision and the subsequent bias decision to the Privy Council. The significant condition related to the preparation of the Record of Proceedings for filing in the Privy Council within three months.

February 2001 Final leave to pursue the appeal is given by the Court of Appeal.


ENDS


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Crowdsale And Crowdfunding Campaign: Help Create The Future Of Independent News

Two weeks to go! The Scoop 3.0 plan aims to create NZ’s first community-owned, distributed news and media intelligence ecosystem in 2019. We believe this ScoopPro media monetisation approach can be scaled and spread globally to support local and independent news efforts in regional New Zealand and around the world.

Scoop is an ecosystem, it would not exist without those who contribute to it, read it and rely on it for professional media purposes. Generous past support from this ecosystem has enabled us to come this far in developing our business model. Support our PledgeMe Campaign>>

 

14/11: Two Years’ Progress Since The Kaikoura Earthquake

Mayor John Leggett said it was a day for reflection, but also a time to recognise the work by many people to support progress towards recovery made across Marlborough since November 2016. More>>

ALSO:

Pike River: Mine Drift Re-Entry Plan To Proceed

“I’ve decided the Te Kāhui Whakamana Rua Tekau Mā Iwa - Pike River Recovery Agency, recommended course of action to enter the drift, using the existing access tunnel, is by far the safest option,” said Andrew Little. More>>

ALSO:

Appointments: New High Commissioner To Australia Announced

“Dame Annette King needs no introduction given her long running career as a parliamentarian where she has previously held a number senior Cabinet portfolios, including Justice, Police and Health. She also was Parliament’s longest serving female MP with 30 years’ service,” said Mr Peters. More>>

ALSO:

Two Years Since Kaikoura: Silvia Cartwright To Lead Inquiry Into EQC

“The inquiry will be the first of its kind under the Public Inquiries Act 2013 and will have all the powers of a Royal Commission, be independent of Government and make its report directly to the Governor-General. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Royal Commission Into Child Abuse

Obviously, it is good news that the coalition government has broadened the scope of its Royal Commission into the abuse of children, beyond its previous focus on children in state care. More>>

ALSO:

Cases Delayed: Court Staff Refuse To Handle Sentencing Papers

Dozens of court cases have reportedly been delayed, as court staff escalate industrial action at two Auckland courts by enforcing a ban on handling sentencing papers. More>>

ALSO:

Education: Primary Teachers Rolling Strikes

RNZ Report: More than 100,000 primary school students in Auckland will be home from school today as teachers and principals walk off the job for the second time this year. It's the start of a week of rolling one-day strikes around the country, after the collapse of contract negotiations last Thursday. More>>

ALSO:

"Process Was Sound": Inquiry Into Haumaha Appointment Released

The Inquiry’s purpose was to examine, identify, and report on the adequacy of the process that led to the appointment. It found the process was sound and no available relevant information was omitted. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels