Local Govt | National News Video | Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Search

 

Illegal signs case: Council returns to court

Illegal signs case: Council returns to court

Auckland City Council this morning went back to court in the case of illegal signs being displayed at 10 Warnock Street, Grey Lynn.

The council filed a memorandum of counsel to Auckland District Court Judge Roderick Joyce, QC.

The memorandum was also served on Ekenasio Finau, the respondent whom the court has earlier ordered to remove the signs, which are in breach of a bylaw in a heritage residential zone.

The council is asking the court to stay its 18 December 2002 order to commit Finau to jail if he failed to remove the signs by 17 January 2003.

The application to stay that order will be determined in open court on 20 February 2003.

In its memorandum, the council says Finau has muted the nature and number of the offending signs and it will again explore further alternative enforcement procedures. The memorandum says reasons for its present position include:

The signs being displayed at the property are muted in comparison to those previously displayed and are of a less controversial nature.

Mr Finau in public statements of his own and through those of his supporters appears to be using the prospect of his committal as an opportunity to cast him as a ‘martyr’ of free speech, rather than as an individual who has displayed ongoing contempt for court orders. This is an unintended and inappropriate outcome for the exercise of the committal process.

Council representatives at a senior level have come to question the utility of the execution of a committal warrant and, given the present nature of the signage, it will appear a disproportionate and unnecessary remedy. The council’s Director of Customer Services, Mr Paul Sonderer, said today the council wanted the signs removed to protect neighbourhood values and intended to take further action to achieve that.

While these legal steps were in train the council would not be commenting further.

* Please note attached memorandum


In The District Court Held At Auckland

NP3350/01
UNDER Local Government Act 1974, Section 79(2) District Courts Act 1947 and Rules 628(2) and 570 District Court Rules

BETWEEN AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL
Applicant

AND EKENASIO FINAU
Respondent


MEMORANDUM OF COUNSEL


MEMORANDUM OF COUNSEL

MAY IT PLEASE YOUR HONOUR:

This Memorandum is filed in support of an application pursuant to Rule 570 of the District Court Rules to stay the order of committal made against the respondent by this Court on 18 December 2002. The basis for this application is set out below. For completeness, the affidavit of Austin Laurenson detailing the continued presence of signage at the respondent’s property as at 19 January 2003 is filed together with this Memorandum. It is noted that in terms of the Court’s earlier order Mr Finau remains in breach.

There are three overlapping reasons for the Applicant’s present position:

3.1 The signs presently on display at the property whilst still constituting visual pollution are muted in comparison to those signs previously displayed. In particular the number of signs has reduced and the signs of a political nature have been in a large part obscured by banners of support for Team New Zealand. The signs are now of a less controversial nature. (Compare affidavit annexures of Frith dated 8 October 2002 and Laurenson dated 30 January 2003).

3.2 Mr Finau in public statements of his own and through those of his supporters appears to be using the prospect of his committal as an opportunity to cast himself as a ‘martyr’ of free speech, rather than as an individual who has displayed ongoing contempt for court orders. This is an unintended and inappropriate outcome for the exercise of the committal process.

3.3 Council representatives at a senior level have come to question the utility of the execution of a committal warrant, in that it will not solve the underlying problem with Mr Finau and his supporting pressure group and given the present nature of the signage will appear a disproportionate & unnecessary remedy.

Because of the above reasons, the applicant now wishes to have stayed the execution of the committal order. The applicant will again explore further alternative enforcement procedures, albeit that attempts at resolution have failed in the past. Given the muting in the nature of the signage there is some expectation that other measures may meet with success. The Applicant appreciates that this application to stay the order of committal against Mr Finau will preclude the Applicant from seeking a committal warrant from the Court in future in respect of the present matter. The decision to stay rests with the Court. Whether or not the Court stays the order of committal, the Council will make a public statement to the effect that it determined not to proceed with the committal process and that it applied for a stay of the order under Rule 570 of the District Court Rules for the reasons set out at paragraph 3 above.

Should it be required, Counsel for the applicant is available to appear in Court at a convenient time in order to address the Court in respect of any matter which arises from this Memorandum. A copy of the Application, the Affidavit and this Memorandum will be served upon Mr Finau either personally or by leaving the same at his Warnock Street address. Given that a stay is sought, Counsel respectfully submits that it is not necessary to effect service before the Court proceeds to determine the application.

DATED at Auckland this 30th day of January 2003.

...................……………................ B H Dickey Counsel for the Applicant


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Why France Could Become Our Closest Ally In Europe

As PM Jacinda Ardern returns from a triumphant tour to Britain and the capitals of Europe, her officials have probably begun to assess what the more substantive gains from the trip might have been. Most of the chatter has been about potential trade deals – so lets just assume for the moment that bilateral trade deals between big and small countries are a good thing, despite the perils they pose to the smaller party. Currently, Britain is so involved with its Brexit nightmare that there seems little prospect of any substantive early progress on an FTA with Britain. In any case, New Zealand should be wary of being the first cab off that particular rank. ... More>>

 

HiveMind: Fair Enough? How Should New Zealanders Be Taxed?

Have Your Say - Scoop and PEP invite you to share your issues, ideas and perspectives on the NZ tax system with other New Zealanders using Scoop’s HiveMind tool. This Tax HiveMind is intended to complement and feed into the review being run by the Government-appointed Tax Working Group (TWG), which is looking at the fairness, balance and structure of the tax system with a 10-year time horizon. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On Thompson + Clark & Russia’s World Cup

Daily, the coalition government keeps running into examples of the toxic legacy left behind by National – and just as regularly, even the simple fixes are proving stubbornly difficult to enact. Take the case of the security firm Thompson + Clark ... More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The GCSB’s Security Hang-Up With Russia

So our GCSB has chimed in, alongside its British, Australian and US allies, with warnings about a “fresh wave” of Russian cyber attacks, although the warning has been curiously framed. More>>

ALSO:

PM's Europe Trip: CHOGM & Bilateral Meetings

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern is in Europe for the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in London and meetings with counterparts in Paris and Berlin. More>>

ALSO:


Addressing Climate Change: No New Offshore Exploration Permits

The Coalition Government is taking an important step to address climate change and create a clean, green and sustainable future for New Zealand, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced today. More>>

ALSO:

Road Safety Summit: Actions To Improve Identified

The Local Government Road Safety Summit held last week identified actions that will lead to lasting changes to road safety in New Zealand, says Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages