Local Govt | National News Video | Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Search

 


Puhoi to Warkworth motorway time savings unrealistic

Media release: Travel time savings claimed for Puhoi to Warkworth motorway are unrealistic

Warkworth based transport planning consultant Bevan Woodward has been studying the travel time savings claimed by NZTA for the Puhoi to Warkworth motorway.

Mr Woodward advises: "A slow trip from the tunnel to Warkworth currently takes 13 minutes. That’s an average speed of 78 km/h to travel the 17 km, but in my experience most trips are quicker than this - even during week day peak hour. The only time it's slower is during summer holiday congestion."

"For a 5 minutes travel time saving, the new 18 km motorway would have to be driven in a time of 8 minutes, this equates to a highly unrealistic speed of 135 km/h."

In addition Mr Woodward says: "If the new 18km motorway was driven at the legal speed limit of 100km/h, this would take 11 minutes. However as this is to the north of Warkworth, another one to three minutes must be added to drive through the Hill Street intersection into the town of Warkworth, meaning that there are no time savings on the existing travel time of 13 minutes."

"In NZTA's business case, claimed time savings of 5 to 8 minutes are used to calculate over half of the economic benefits of the proposed motorway. Without these unrealistic time savings the project is a very negative return on investment."

Here are the calculations...

Distance (km) Average speed (km/hr) Time (minutes)

Existing SH1 from tunnel into Warkworth (slow trip = 13 minutes) 17 78 13.1

Proposed Motorway (travel time saving of 5 minutes requires an average speed of 135 km/h) 18 135 8.0

Proposed Motorway @ legal speed limit of 100 km/h = 11 minutes travel time 18 100 10.8

A summary of key issues with the Puhoi to Warkworth motorway is attached.

--


Key issues with the Puhoi to Warkworth motorway


1) The claimed travel time saving of 5 to 8 minutes are unrealistic

A slow trip from the tunnel to Warkworth currently takes 13 minutes. That’s an average speed of 78 km/h to travel the 17 km, but most trips (even during peak hour) are quicker on this 100km/h stretch of road.

For a 5 minutes travel time saving, the new 18 km motorway would have to be driven at an unrealistic 135 km/h.

If the new 18km motorway was driven at 100km/h, this would take 11 minutes. However this is to the north of Warkworth, so when another one to three minutes to drive through the Hill Street intersection is added, it means that there are no time savings.


In NZTA's business case, the claimed time savings are used to generate over half of the economic benefits of the motorway. When these unrealistic time savings are removed from the BCR calculation, the project’s total economic benefit is a negative return on the Government’s investment.

2) The motorway’s single point of access to Warkworth is likely to negatively impact on the town.

Having only one access point to the motorway at Warkworth means making a compromise solution that will have potentially negative impacts on certain sectors and causes travel delays.

For example a single point of access to the North is likely to have very negative impacts for Warkworth retailers and it lengthens travel times between Warkworth and Auckland.


A single point of access to the south means the holiday traffic will continue to queue up over long weekends and public transport access through Warkworth is be impaired.

A single point of access to the west (eg: Woodcocks Rd) would put too much traffic past the College and does not solve the issue of holiday traffic congestion through Warkworth.

A bypass road with multiple access points (as outlined in point 4 below) resolves these issues.


3) We can’t afford it

The Government is borrowing $250 million a week to fund its budget deficit. Consequently, ratings agency Standard & Poor's recently downgraded the outlook on NZ’s national credit rating to negative, this has a direct cost for all New Zealanders.


4) There are more cost-effective solutions are available

Safety improvements on SH1, bypasses of Warkworth and Wellsford, provision of public transport, along with upgrading the Northern railway line is a far more cost- effective and comprehensive solution.

It will provide multiple access points to Warkworth and leave us better placed to with future issues such as:

• Deal with the effects of rising oil prices

• Reduce our carbon emissions

• Spreading the economic development across Rodney

• Providing public transport to the region

• Delivering travel time savings sooner


ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Election Day: National Win

With all votes counted National and John Key have won a third term and are close to being able to govern alone if they so choose.

Key has indicated he will still reach out to form a Government with ACT, United Future and Maori Party.

National ended the night on 48 percent, Labour 24.6 and the Greens 10. Though special votes might change the margins it is certainly a third term victory for Key defying the political gravity which usually hits parties seeking a third term. Increasing National’s party share is a remarkable political achievement...More>>

Overall Results | Live Results | Predictions |

 


Perfectly-Timed Anniversaries: Suffrage Day Is Last Chance To Enrol

“The last chance to enrol is Friday 19 September. You can’t enrol on election day.” More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On First Time Voting (Greens)

For the last two days, I’ve turned my column over to a couple of guest columnists who are first time voters… Today’s guest columnist is Ana Avia-O’Connor, who will be casting her first time vote on Saturday for the Greens. More>>

ALSO:

Meddling: Aussie Liberals Embroiled In Key Campaign

John Key needs to explain why Australia’s Liberal Party is interfering in New Zealand domestic politics and is encouraging Kiwi voters across the ditch to vote for National just days out from the election, Labour’s campaign spokesperson Annette King says. More>>

ALSO:

SURVEILLANCE:

Election Ad Soundtrack: Rapper Eminem Sues National Party Over Copyright Breach

US rapper Eminem is suing the New Zealand National Party for alleged copyright infringement over unauthorised use of the rapper’s ‘Lose Yourself’ song in an election campaign advertisement. More>>

ALSO:

Big March: Call For An End To Domestic Violence

Hundreds of protesters marched down Lambton Quay to Parliament Monday calling for an end to domestic violence. Wearing white facemasks, waving banners and calling for “safety” for the women and children of New Zealand.. More>>

ALSO:

Pre-Election Chartering: Four New Partnership Schools To Open

Education Minister Hekia Parata today announced the Government has signed contracts to open four new Partnership Schools in 2015. More>>

ALSO:

Werewolf 50 Out Now - The Election Issue: Loss Leaders

Gordon Campbell: A third term requires a mature decision, with eyes wide open. It calls for a conscious vote of confidence… Without trying hard here are about 19 reasons, in no particular order, for not ticking ‘party vote’ National. More>>

ALSO:

Not-Especially New Plans: All Prisons To Become Working Prisons Under National

All public prisons in New Zealand will become full working prisons by 2017, and ex-prisoners will receive post-release drug addiction treatment if National is returned to government, says Corrections Spokesperson Anne Tolley. More>>

ALSO:

Māngere: "False Claim Of Matai Title" - Labour

National must explain why its candidate for Māngere Misa Fia Turner appears to be using a Matai title she is not entitled to, Labour’s MP for Māngere and Pacific Islands Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio says. A Matai title is a legally-recognised ... More>>

ALSO:

CPAG Report: No New Zealand Child Should Grow Up In Poverty

Child Poverty Action Group's flagship policy publication Our Children, Our Choice: Priorities for Policy calls for cross party political agreement to underpin an action plan to eliminate child poverty in New Zealand. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 

LATEST HEADLINES

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Regional
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news