Local Govt | National News Video | Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Search


Hamilton’s Fluoride Challenge Withdrawn




Wednesday 3 September 2014

For immediate release

Hamilton’s Fluoride Challenge Withdrawn

Safe Water Alternative NZ Inc (SWANZ) has withdrawn its Judicial Review proceedings against the Hamilton City Council.

SWANZ co-ordinator, Trevor Crosbie, says the reason is two-fold, “Firstly, it’s apparent to us that without substantial financial backing from benefactors we unfortunately cannot continue. While we had a good legal case, our resources are limited compared with the deep pockets of the council. We are grateful for the goodwill and generosity of supporters and won’t stop until we achieve our quest for safe unfluoridated water. We need time to explore our options, including the possibility of future proceedings on different grounds. We will not go away.”

“Another factor is the growing number of challenges to fluoridation. We are confident fluoridation will be required to cease sooner rather than later as a result of these actions. With Israel’s decision to prohibit fluoridation effective 26 August 2014, the Republic of Ireland is now the only country with mandatory fluoridation in the world.”

SWANZ, representing over 11,000 Hamilton residents who oppose having Hydrofluorosilicic Acid added to their water, without their informed consent or due consideration of evidence of harm, had filed proceedings against the Council on 28th April 2014. They claimed Hamilton City Council had not carried out a full consultative process when deciding to re-fluoridate the Hamilton water supply. Fluoride was restarted on 3rd July 2014. By that date Hamilton had been un-fluoridated for 378 days, since the Fluoride Tribunal decision in June 2013.

The reasons the Council gave when they stopped fluoridation included -

(a) they did not consider there was compelling evidence of benefit (for caries protection) and

(b) they did consider there was credible evidence of risks of harm

Mr Crosbie is emphatic these reasons still exist. “Unlike the recent (and unbalanced) Gluckman/Skegg report, the Council considered both sides of the scientific evidence and correctly identified that the potential risks outweighed the benefits. It is disappointing they didn’t have the nerve to stick with their decision.”

SWANZ has requested that Council provides Hamiltonians with a choice, and that it supplies them with a public non-fluoridated supply of drinking water using de-ionising technology (at a cost estimated to be in the order of $10,000 to $15,000 to install and up to $3,000 annually to maintain).

“This is a reasonable proposal,” says Mr Crosbie. “While the fluoridation myth persists, a non-fluoridated source of water for those who don’t want it is a fair request. Other councils already provide such a supply. For example, there is a source in Petone for Wellington residents and both Hastings and Palmerston North Councils are currently installing them. The cost to Hamilton ratepayers (Council) would be a small fraction of the legal costs that Council would have incurred if the Judicial Review had proceeded.”

“The issue of adding a waste by-product to community water supplies will continue to be challenged until the practice ends,” Mr Crosbie concluded.


ATTACHMENT: SWANZ Open Letter to Hamilton City Council CEO, Mayor and Councillors

2 September 2014

Open Letter to Hamilton City Council CEO, Mayor and Councillors

Safe Water Alternative NZ is requesting, on behalf of over 11,000 Hamilton residents, that Council seriously revisits the provision of some type of outlet for unfluoridated water drinking water - as presented to Council as Option 3 at the 28th Nov 2013 meeting http://www.hamilton.govt.nz/AgendasAndMinutes/ORDINARY%20COUNCIL%20MEETING%2028%20NOVEMBER%202013%20PART%201%20OF%204.pdf

One possibility would be to provide a public unfluoridated supply of drinking water at a location to be determined using deionising technology and estimated to cost in the order of between $10,000 to $15,000 to install and up to $3,000 operational costs per annum.

Council may be interested that Palmerston North City Council is currently planning to install a 20mm ID offtake pipe between their chlorine injection point and their fluoride injection point. This would be extended to the street with a self-shutoff tap and a backflow preventer. They estimate their allocated budget of $15,000 should be sufficient for this.

In Hastings the Council is currently proposing to spend about $28,000 on public unfluoridated water "filling stations" at two bore sites: Eastbourne Street and Frimley Park.

As Hamilton is a much larger community than Hastings, we would expect at least two outlets here, if not four, considering the size of the city.

In light of similar happenings around NZ, we do not consider our request is unreasonable or overly expensive. We would invite Council to allow us to work with them on this.

Yours sincerely

Trevor Crosbie
Spokesperson SWANZ Inc

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines



Relevant Consents Gained: Government Unveils RMA Reform Package

The government has formally hauled down the flag on its attempts to alter the balance of environmental and economic priorities in the Resource Management Act, unveiling a 180-page Resource Legislation Amendment Bill containing reforms that have been largely endorsed by most political parties. More>>


Closing Schools And Such: Interim Redcliffs Decision Announced

“While the school’s board has argued that circumstances that could give rise to potential disruption are extremely unlikely, advice from technical experts has shown these concerns cannot be ruled out." More>>


Jane Kelsey: High Court Can’t Make Groser Provide TPPA Information Faster

‘This week we went back to court to challenge Trade Minister Groser’s stalling tactics over the release of information on the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement negotiations, following a High Court order that he reconsider the Official Information Act request I made last January’, said University of Auckland law professor Jane Kelsey, first applicant in the case. More>>

Werewolf 58: No Climate For Change

The last time the global community tried to take collective action on climate change the world’s leaders finally came to agree that every not-too-onerous effort should be made to hold global warming to 2°C above the pre-industrial average. At Paris, all 150 participant countries nations will have put forward their pledges... On the information available, New Zealand's is the second weakest contribution of any nation in the developed world. More>>


Lambton Quay Shutdown: Object Was Made To Look Like Bomb

Police cordoned off part of Lambton Quay Wednesday afternoon, saying that a suspicious package had been found. Buildings were evacuated and buses were detoured. The army’s explosive ordnance disposal unit was brought to the Quay. More>>


Public Sector Still Shrinking: Record Low Number Of 'Backroom Bureaucrats'

Ongoing restraint in the public sector and a focus on better frontline services has seen a further reduction in the number of core Government employees, State Services Minister Paula Bennett says. More>>


Disobeying The Law: Police Censorship Of Crime Research “An Outrage”

The Green Party is calling on Police Minister Michael Woodhouse to ensure Police scrap controversial contracts that place onerous restrictions on academic researchers’ access to Police data, the Green Party says. More>>


Get More From Scoop



Search Scoop  
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news