Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


High Court finds Carter Holt breached Commerce Act

High Court finds Carter Holt breached Commerce Act by below cost pricing against New Wool Products Ltd insulation

Media Release 2000/42

The High Court at Auckland has found that the manufacturer of "Pink Batts" fibreglass insulation, Carter Holt Harvey Building Products Group Limited (Carter Holt), contravened the Commerce Act when it used its market dominance for the purpose of preventing or deterring Nelson-based company, New Wool Products Limited from competing with it.

Commerce Commission Chairman John Belgrave said that the Commission is happy with the result and is studying the judgment to consider its application to other industries where there is a dominant business.

Mr Belgrave said that the Commission will provide factual information about the case but cannot yet comment on it—"It is a long and complex judgment, which we are still studying, and the case is sub judice as it is still before the Court." The Court will hold a penalty hearing at a date yet to be set.

The Commission claimed that New Wool Products wholly woollen insulation product, "Wool Bloc", significantly reduced sales of Pink Batts in Nelson and other areas.

The Commission alleged that Carter Holt responded by launching a wool and polyester combination insulation product which it called "Wool Line". However, the price of Wool Line was about double that of Wool Bloc and sales of Wool Line, particularly in Nelson and Marlborough, were low.

The Commission claimed that as a result of New Wool Products’ continued success, Carter Holt supplied Wool Line to outlets, mainly in the Nelson/Marlborough region, at below cost by the offer of two bales for the price of one.

Justice Williams stated in his judgment that:

"… in instituting and maintaining the "2 for 1" INZCO [which was the Carter Holt division that produced Pink Batts] used its dominant position in the South Island insulation market for the purpose—ie the object or aim—of preventing or deterring New Wool Products from engaging in competitive conduct in that market or eliminating it from that market. Its actions were accordingly in breach of the Commerce Act 1986 s36(1)(b)(c)."

The lay member of the Court, economist Professor Ralph Lattimore, stated in his judgment that during the "2 for 1" period Carter Holt priced the two types of Wool Line at 30 percent and 40 percent below cost.

Professor Lattimore stated:

"INZCO had produced a wool-type product, which it was selling in the Nelson region to directly compete with NWP’s Wool Bloc at a very significant margin below INZCO’s variable costs of producing the product. This is the action of a dominant supplier that would not be carried out by a non-dominant supplier in these circumstances. As a dominant supplier in the market, INZCO could easily afford the cost of the ‘2 for 1’ arrangement. The subsidy incurred in Wool Line sales in Nelson and elsewhere added to the cost of other products produced by INZCO. The costs were only a small fraction of its overall promotions budget, for example."

Section 36 prohibits a company that is dominant in a market using its dominance to prevent or deter competition in any market, or eliminate a competitor from any market.

Media contact: Chair John Belgrave

Phone work (04) 498 0964, cellphone 021 650 045

Communications Officer Vincent Cholewa

Phone work (04) 498 0920

© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Trade: NZ Trade Deficit Widens To A Record In September

Oct. 27 (BusinessDesk) - New Zealand's monthly trade deficit widened to a record in September as meat exports dropped to their lowest level in more than three years. More>>


Animal Welfare: Cruel Practices Condemned By DairyNZ Chief

DairyNZ chief executive Tim Mackle says cruel and illegal practices are not in any way condoned or accepted by the industry as part of dairy farming.

Tim says the video released today by Farmwatch shows some footage of transport companies and their workers, as well as some unacceptable behaviour by farmers of dragging calves. More>>


Postnatal Depression: 'The Thief That Steals Motherhood' - Alison McCulloch

Post-natal depression is a sly and cruel illness, described by one expert as ‘the thief that steals motherhood’, it creeps up on its victims, hiding behind the stress and exhaustion of being a new parent, catching many women unaware and unprepared. More>>


DIY: Kiwi Ingenuity And Masking Tape Saves Chick

Kiwi ingenuity and masking tape has saved a Kiwi chick after its egg was badly damaged endangering the chick's life. The egg was delivered to Kiwi Encounter at Rainbow Springs in Rotorua 14 days ago by a DOC worker with a large hole in its shell and against all odds has just successfully hatched. More>>


International Trade: Key To Lead Mission To India; ASEAN FTA Review Announced

Prime Minister John Key will lead a trade delegation to India next week, saying the pursuit of a free trade agreement with the protectionist giant is "the primary reason we're going" but playing down the likelihood of early progress. More>>



MYOB: Digital Signatures Go Live

From today, Inland Revenue will begin accepting “digital signatures”, saving businesses and their accountants a huge amount of administration time and further reducing the need for pen and paper in the workplace. More>>

Oil Searches: Norway's Statoil Quits Reinga Basin

Statoil, the Norwegian state-owned oil company, has given up oil and gas exploration in Northland's Reinga Basin, saying the probably of a find was 'too low'. More>>


Modern Living: Auckland Development Blowouts Reminiscent Of Run Up To GFC

The collapse of property developments in Auckland is "almost groundhog day" to the run-up of the global financial crisis in 2007/2008 as banks refuse to fund projects due to blowouts in construction and labour costs, says John Kensington, the author of KPMG's Financial Institutions Performance Survey. More>>


Get More From Scoop

Search Scoop  
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news