Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


IRD warns investors of tax avoidance schemes

Inland Revenue
Te Tari Taake


17 April 2001

Inland Revenue warns investors of tax avoidance schemes

The Commissioner of Inland Revenue is cautioning people against buying into tax avoidance schemes, which can prove ruinous.

“If these schemes look too good to be true, they probably are,” said David Butler.

“Investors risk severe monetary penalties and may be prosecuted for fraud.”

His comments came after the Privy Council ruled against a scheme promoted by an Auckland tax adviser, JG Russell.

This was perhaps the most prolific tax avoidance scheme in New Zealand history.
It was described by the Taxation Review Authority as affecting the lives of hundreds or thousands of people who invested in it. The Authority also said that these investors and their families and staff “are having their lives ruined by financial stress which seems likely to continue for years and years”.

Mr Butler said the Privy Council ruling made it clear beyond doubt that the JG Russell scheme is void for tax purposes. He said from the date of the judgment any investor who files tax returns claiming the alleged tax advantages from the scheme is likely to receive severe monetary penalties for taking an “abusive tax position”. Such investors may also be prosecuted for fraud.

“People investing in similar tax avoidance schemes run the same risks,” said Mr Butler.

He said investors should ask whether a scheme is the subject of a ruling by Inland Revenue, and confirm if it is binding and clarifies a scheme’s tax status.

Inland Revenue is pursuing at least $10m of tax owed by investors in the JG Russell scheme. The Magnum case, by comparison, involved only $2m of tax.

In the last year, litigation was completed on tax avoidance cases involving $148 million in revenue. Of that amount, $139 million (94%) was resolved in favour of the department, said Inland Revenue's Director of Litigation, Mike Lennard.


Mr Butler said he welcomed the Privy Council’s rejection of serious allegations against Inland Revenue staff of irrationality, abuse of power, and acting without delegation. All these allegations were considered, but each of them was firmly struck-off by the Privy Council. In particular the allegation of irrationality was described as “preposterous”.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Manawatu-Whanganui Projects: PGF Top-Up To Rural Broadband Roll-Out

The government has effectively raided the $3 billion Provincial Growth Fund to top up the budget for the second phase of its rural broadband initiative, filling in mobile 'black spots' and ensuring broadband is available to marae that don't have access now. More>>


Other Windy Cities: Auckland-Chicago Named A Top 10 ‘Most Exciting’ New Route

The inclusion of Auckland-Chicago on Lonely Planet’s Where to fly in 2019? The 10 most exciting new flight routes list comes just two weeks before Air New Zealand prepares to celebrate its inaugural flight to Chicago’s O’Hare International Airport on 30 November. More>>

Deadly Strain: ESR Ups Its Reporting On Meningococcal Disease

The increasing number of cases of Group W Meningococcal disease (MenW) has prompted ESR to increase its reporting on the disease to the Ministry of Health. ESR has upped its reporting to weekly. More>>


Very Small Things: "Game-Changing" 3D Printing Technology Launched

New Zealand microfabrication researchers Andrea Bubendorfer and Andrew Best, the co-inventors of a new way of fabricating very small things with Laminated Resin Printing (LRP), are part of Callaghan Innovation’s MicroMaker3D team launching the new patent pending technology in the US this week. More>>