Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Fonterra Hits Back At Accounting Critic

Fonterra Hits Back At Accounting Critic

Fonterra Co-operative Group has rejected critical analysis of its half-year accounts by academic accountant Alan Robb as "inaccurate and misleading."

Mr Robb was widely reported this week as claiming Fonterra's half-year accounts show "a worrying trend in net cashflow from operations," suggesting this could lead to an even lower than forecast payout of $3.60 per kg milksolids.

Fonterra Chief Financial Officer Graham Stuart said Mr Robb's comments were misleading.

"Fonterra's cashflows are healthy. Mr Robb has taken the half-year result and made assumptions about the full year. But trading conditions between the two halves are very different - as we have made abundantly clear in the commentary attached to the half-year accounts and in other announcements in recent weeks, which Mr Robb has ignored."

Mr Robb, a senior lecturer at the University of Canterbury, said falling commodity prices and the strengthening New Zealand dollar had depressed Fonterra's net cashflow over the six months to November 30 to a surplus of only $236 million, compared with $855 million in the same period the year before. He warned that if this season's second half followed a similar pattern to last season's - when Fonterra had a negative net cashflow of more than $500 million - shareholders could face a further reduction in payout.

Mr Stuart said Mr Robb's comments suggested he did not understand Fonterra's business.

"We made it clear in our Half-Year Report, and subsequent briefings, that our revenues and cashflows would be significantly higher over the second half. This is in stark contrast to last season's pattern where prices fell dramatically in the second half.

"As explained in the Report, we contract sales several months in advance so we have confidence in saying this."

Other comments by Mr Robb also showed an absence of proper analysis, said Mr Stuart.

Mr Robb claimed it was misleading for Fonterra to have treated payout to suppliers as an operating cost and that this approach did not square with Fonterra's claim to have taken costs out of the business.

Mr Stuart said Fonterra had been completely open in its treatment of costs. They had been broken down in a special table in the Half-Year Report and detailed in the Report's text. Additional analysis of operating costs, separating milk payments and inventory movements from the total provided, clearly showed reductions of around 8 per cent in controllable costs - despite record volumes of milk being processed and sold.

"Rather than criticising us on the basis of faulty analysis, Mr Robb should be commending us for our transparent additional disclosures."

Mr Stuart said Mr Robb's suggestion that Fonterra had withheld information on milksolids production for the half year did not stand up.

"Working out the figure from the information we've provided is simple arithmetic. Just divide payout to suppliers ($1.436 million) by the amount available for payout ($2.63/kg) to get 546 million kg. To imply Fonterra has withheld this information is mischievious."

© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


ScoopPro: Helping The Education Sector Get More Out Of Scoop

The ScoopPro professional license includes a suite of useful information tools for professional users of Scoop including some specifically for those in the education sector to make your Scoop experience better. More>>

Big Tax Bill Due: Destiny Church Charities Deregistered

The independent Charities Registration Board has decided to remove Destiny International Trust and Te Hahi o Nga Matamua Holdings Limited from the Charities Register on 20 December 2017 because of the charities’ persistent failure to meet their annual return obligations. More>>

57 Million Users' Data: Uber Breach "Utterly Preventatable"

Cybersecurity leader Centrify says the Uber data breach of 57 million customer and driver records - which the ride-hailing company hid for more than a year - was “utterly preventable”. More>>

Scoop 3.0: How You Can Help Scoop’s Evolution

We have big plans for 2018 as we look to expand our public interest journalism coverage, upgrade our publishing infrastructure and offer even more valuable business tools to commercial users of Scoop. More>>

Having A Cow? Dairy Product Prices Slide For Fourth Straight Auction

Dairy product prices fell at the Global Dairy Trade auction, retreating for the fourth straight auction amid signs of increased production... Whole milk powder fell 2.7 percent to US$2,778 a tonne. More>>


Statistics: Butter At Record $5.67/Block; High Vegetable Prices

Rising dairy prices have pushed food prices up 2.7 percent in the year to October 2017, Stats NZ said today. This followed a 3.0 percent increase in the year to September 2017. More>>


Science: New Research Finds Herbicides Cause Antibiotic Resistance

New University of Canterbury research confirms that the active ingredients of the commonly used herbicides, RoundUp, Kamba and 2,4-D (glyphosate, dicamba and 2,4-D, respectively), each alone cause antibiotic resistance at concentrations well below label application rates. More>>


  • Bill Bennett on Tech