Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Save Air NZ: The Appeal Of Flogging A Dead Horse

Air New Zealand and Qantas:
The appeal of flogging a dead horse

Update #8 Of The Save Air New Zealand Campaign

So Air New Zealand and Qantas are to appeal. Apparently the Commerce Commission must be out of its mind not to approve a proposal whereby competition between the two airlines would cease. In fact, the airlines tell us, New Zealanders would be better off with the alliance because competition between the Qantas and Air New Zealand is not sustainable. Especially not with the imminent entry of an efficient and aggressive Pacific Blue. Consumers, say the airlines, must take the pain of monopoly pricing because the alternative for Air New Zealand is oblivion.

Of course, the infamous “war of attrition” - a bizarre scenario involving both Qantas and Air New Zealand throwing good money after bad - has been rejected by the Commission. It noted that Air New Zealand is surviving very well thank you very much – the Express initiative had grown the domestic market and looks set to do the same on the Tasman, Freedom is catering to a certain niche, the engineering business is prospering. And financial performance is improving. The Commission’s optimism is borne out by Air New Zealand’s head of airlines businesses, Rob Fyfe, who was recently reported in the Dominion Post as saying: “We are continuing to look at where we can create further value and further stimulate travel.” In the same report, Mr Fyfe seems sceptical about the ability of Pacific Blue to deal the blow Ralph Norris fears: "What we found is that the budget airlines are starting to show a few cracks." Hardly the attitude of an airline on death row. On the contrary, until now Air New Zealand has had no problem fighting off new entrants without any assistance from Qantas. Look at the unfortunate demise of Kiwi Air. If the recent rough-house treatment meted out to Origin on the new Hamilton to Christchurch route is an indication of Air New Zealand’s attitude in the market now, what can we expect from it when it has the might of Qantas behind it as well? It is obviously not something the Commerce Commission was prepared to contemplate.

Successful appeals against Commerce Commission decisions are rare, especially if the grounds of appeal are the “merits” (as opposed to matters of legal process). The airlines would need to turn up a fundamental error giving rise to a wild swing in the analysis. That is highly unlikely. In this case, the Commission has taken particular care. It has spent the best part of a year grappling with the issues and its determination illustrates a sophisticated and comprehensive understanding of the issues. The errors the airlines claim are not apparent to anyone else who has read the decision. The decision is thorough, well reasoned and well expressed. It was not a “close call”. The conclusion is that the benefits claimed go nowhere near compensating for the damage caused by having our only two major providers of airline services collaborate on prices, schedules and capacity on all routes and to have those arrangements underpinned and entrenched by equity investment and cross-directorships. In short, the alliance has 4 legs and barks and has, accordingly, been pronounced a dog.

And not even the spin of the very best legal and economic advocacy that millions of dollars can buy could persuade the Commission otherwise. Mind you, the inventiveness of those experts has to be admired. For example, they argued that we would all be better off under the alliance because overseas holidays would become prohibitively expensive and the economy would benefit from the money that the stranded New Zealand public were forced to spend locally. Full marks for trying but, for the record, the Commission didn’t buy that one.

So why appeal? Jim Farmer QC apparently believes the Commission was wrong not to embrace Qantas as Air New Zealand’s new guardian angel – yes, this is the same Jim Farmer QC who as acting chair of Air New Zealand blamed Qantas for sinking Ansett and putting Air New Zealand in the financial predicament in which he found it. The appeal is disingenuous. And New Zealand consumers are left to pick up the tab. As a matter of commercial commonsense, the continuing spectre of the unauthorised alliance must reduce the intensity of competition between Air New Zealand and Qantas. And while the dead horse is being flogged in front of the High Court, the winners are the airlines. From their perspective, the longer it goes on the better. Hell, with any luck, the Court will rule a re-hearing of the matter by the Commission and we’ll be none the wiser in 2006. One wonders as to what is the real end-game here.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


I Sing The Highway Electric: Charge Net NZ To Connect New Zealand

BMW is turning Middle Earth electric after today announcing a substantial contribution to the charging network Charge Net NZ. This landmark partnership will enable Kiwis to drive their electric vehicles (EVs) right across New Zealand through the installation of a fast charging highway stretching from Kaitaia to Invercargill. More>>


Watch This Space: Mahia Rocket Lab Launch Site Officially Opened

Economic Development Minster Steven Joyce today opened New Zealand’s first orbital launch site, Rocket Lab Launch Complex 1, on the Mahia Peninsula on the North Island’s east coast. More>>


Marketing Rocks!
Ig Nobel Award Winners Assess The Personality Of Rocks

A Massey University marketing lecturer has received the 2016 Ig Nobel Prize for economics for a research project that asked university students to describe the “brand personalities” of three rocks. More>>


Nurofen Promotion: Reckitt Benckiser To Plead Guilty To Misleading Ads

Reckitt Benckiser (New Zealand) intends to plead guilty to charges of misleading consumers over the way it promoted a range of Nurofen products, the Commerce Commission says. More>>


Half A Billion Accounts, Including Xtra: Yahoo Confirms Huge Data Breach

The account information may have included names, email addresses, telephone numbers, dates of birth, hashed passwords (the vast majority with bcrypt) and, in some cases, encrypted or unencrypted security questions and answers. More>>


Rural Branches: Westpac To Close 19 Branches, ANZ Looks At 7

Westpac confirms it will close nineteen branches across the country; ANZ closes its Ngaruawahia branch and is consulting on plans to close six more branches; The bank workers union says many of its members are nervous about their futures and asking ... More>>

Interest Rates: RBNZ's Wheeler Keeps OCR At 2%

Reserve Bank governor Graeme Wheeler kept the official cash rate at 2 percent and said more easing will be needed to get inflation back within the target band. More>>


Get More From Scoop

Search Scoop  
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news