Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Court rejects bargaining power benefit to workers


Court rejects bargaining power being a benefit to workers

An Employment Court decision affecting Auckland rail workers shows the need for an urgent law change to recognise that multi-employer collective agreements (MECA) are the best deal for workers, a leading union said today.

The court has ruled against the Rail and Maritime Transport Union’s bid to have the Auckland metro rail system workers covered by a MECA under their new employer, Connex.

Transport giant Toll Holdings will relinquish the operational management of the Auckland suburban rail business, Tranz Metro, to Connex. The Auckland Regional council owns all the assets of Tranz Metro Auckland.

Under the transfer agreement, the 116 staff were to move from Toll NZ to Connex on employment conditions which were the “same or more favourable”. The union said the easiest way of facilitating this and maintaining the workers’ current bargaining power was for Connex to be added as an employer party to the MECA.

The workers have been part of the largest private sector MECA in the country, which covers around 3000 transport workers. Toll Holdings, which is part of the MECA, challenged in court that the MECA was part of the “same or more favourable” conditions and refused to let Connex become a party to the MECA, said RMTU general secretary Wayne Butson.

“Under the transfer agreement, the workers must transfer to Connex on the same or more favourable conditions,” Wayne Butson said. “The court has found that a MECA – or the form of a collective agreement – does not form part of the conditions of employment for workers.”

Unions strongly disagree with the decision, he said. “Unions know that MECA are the best way to protect and improve wages and conditions for workers.

“We are gutted that, after battling so hard to get the MECA, an employer can get away with this kind of behaviour,” Wayne Butson said. “Union members are hamstrung from using industrial muscle to protect the transferring workers because we are within contract.”

The court acknowledged that although current employment law intended to promote collective bargaining and to address the inherent inequality of bargaining power in employment relationships, it was clearly not strong enough to achieve this aim.

Employers who concede to MECA’s in bargaining can now use this decision to outsource and thereby destroy the MECA whilst the union is hamstrung from taking industrial action due to being in contract. This decision undermines the objectives of the Employment Relations Act 2000.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Mycoplasma Bovis: More Properties Positive

One of the latest infected properties is in the Hastings district, the other three are within a farming enterprise in Winton. The suspect property is near Ashburton. More>>


Manawatū Gorge Alternative: More Work Needed To Choose Route

“We are currently working closely and in partnership with local councils and other stakeholders to make the right long-term decision. It’s vital we have strong support on the new route as it will represent a very significant long-term investment and it will need to serve the region and the country for decades to come.” More>>


RBNZ: Super Fund Chief To Be New Reserve Bank Governor

Adrian Orr has been appointed as Reserve Bank Governor effective from 27 March 2018, Finance Minister Grant Robertson says. More>>


ScoopPro: Helping PR Professionals Get More Out Of Scoop has been a fixture of New Zealand’s news and Public Relations infrastructure for over 18 years. However, without the financial assistance of those using Scoop in a professional context in key sectors such as Public Relations and media, Scoop will not be able to continue this service... More>>

Insurance: 2017 Worst Year On Record For Weather-Related Losses

The Insurance Council of New Zealand (ICNZ) announced today that 2017 has been the most expensive year on record for weather-related losses, with a total insured-losses value of more than $242 million. More>>