Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

$792,000 payout for false claims

Issued 13 July 2006/007

$792,000 payout for false claims about Body Enhancer "potion"

Zenith Corporation, which sold and promoted the discredited "weight loss" product Body Enhancer will pay $792,000 in fines, costs and corrective advertising. The company was sentenced in the Auckland District Court today for offences under the Fair Trading Act.

Zenith will pay $632,500 in fines and $130,000 in costs, and has also been ordered to undertake a nationwide campaign of corrective advertising that is likely to cost $30,000. The company must take advertisements in newspapers and on Radio Pacific, where the product was heavily promoted in infomercials.

Commerce Commission Chair Paula Rebstock said the Commission was very pleased with the sentence.

"Zenith Corporation is paying the price for misleading the public," Ms Rebstock said.

"The size of the fine reflects the serious, persistent wrongdoing of Zenith, and the widespread harm to New Zealand consumers," Ms Rebstock said.

Extensive corrective advertising would be vital, Ms Rebstock said.

"The false claims about Body Enhancer were advertised very widely, and much was made of the so-called scientific testing of the product.

"The Court's finding is black and white: Body Enhancer does not help people lose weight, or improve their health, and the so-called scientific testing was intended purely to mislead."

While some users did experience weight loss when using Body Enhancer, the Court found that this was due to other lifestyle changes they had made, and was not in any way caused by the product.

"Now Zenith needs to tell New Zealanders the truth - that Body Enhancer doesn't work."

The case had been an important one for the New Zealand consumer, Ms Rebstock said.

"One of the expert witnesses in this case noted that 'the consumers of weight loss products are particularly vulnerable to 'magic bullet' claims.

"This sentence sends a clear message to those making claims about weight loss: whatever you promise the consumer you must be able to support with credible, scientifically rigorous evidence."

Body Enhancer was a liquid sold by mail order. It cost $80 - $90 for a 480ml bottle. Zenith claimed it would help reduce fat, control appetite and improve health, and said it was scientifically tested.

Judge L.H. Moore found that "Body Enhancer has been proved beyond reasonable doubt not to be suitable for any of the purposes claimed and not to confer upon its users any of the benefits alleged."

Of Winston and Sylvia Gallot, the directors of Zenith Corporation, Judge Moore said: "The Court is in no doubt that belief in the efficacy of the product was never their focus; their focus was the profitable exploitation of a marketing opportunity."

The previous highest payout for misleading weight loss claims was $195,000 ordered to be repaid by Marketing Direct (Celluslim) in November 2005.

Background
Body Enhancer is a liquid that claims to assist with weight loss and improve health. The product was sold in New Zealand by Zenith Corporation. On the label and accompanying pamphlet, users are advised to drink fifteen millilitres of Body Enhancer before going to sleep. They are also told to eat no food after dinner, drink eight glasses of water a day, and exercise regularly while taking Body Enhancer.

Zenith claimed that Body Enhancer would: "help control appetite... help break down fat," and assist with "weight loss... liver detoxification... healing of cartilage and strengthening of joints, tendons and heart muscles."

Zenith also claimed that Body Enhancer had been scientifically tested. Testing was carried out by Raukura Hauora O Tainui, a Maori health care organisation, but it did not follow normal clinical practice. This was not "blind" or "double blind" testing and the judge found that the testing did not prove that Body Enhancer worked.

The misleading claims about Body Enhancer appeared on the product labels and pamphlets, on the Zenith website, in magazine advertisements, and in advertisements and "lifestyle interviews" (infomercials) on Radio Pacific.

"Far from being relative innocents they [Winston and Sylvia Gallot] were considerably shrewder, tougher and more determined than those with whom they dealt. They saw, seized on and exploited an opportunity to make very large profits. From that they were not going to be deterred. If charm seemed likely to work, they used charm; if lies seemed likely to work, they used lies; if aggression seemed likely to work, then there was no shortage of that." Para 287, Reserved Judgement of Judge L.H. Moore, 2 June 2005.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Scoop 3.0: How You Can Help Scoop’s Evolution

We have big plans for 2018 as we look to expand our public interest journalism coverage, upgrade our publishing infrastructure and offer even more valuable business tools to commercial users of Scoop. More>>


Statistics: Butter At Record $5.67/Block; High Vegetable Prices

Rising dairy prices have pushed food prices up 2.7 percent in the year to October 2017, Stats NZ said today. This followed a 3.0 percent increase in the year to September 2017. More>>

ALSO:

Science: New Research Finds Herbicides Cause Antibiotic Resistance

New University of Canterbury research confirms that the active ingredients of the commonly used herbicides, RoundUp, Kamba and 2,4-D (glyphosate, dicamba and 2,4-D, respectively), each alone cause antibiotic resistance at concentrations well below label application rates. More>>

ALSO:

CO2 And Water: Fonterra's Environment Plans

Federated Farmers support Fonterra’s bold push to get to zero emissions of CO2 on the manufacturing side of the Co-operative, both in New Zealand and across its global network. More>>

ALSO:

Fisheries: Decision To Delay Monitoring ‘Fatally Flawed’

Conservation group representatives say a decision by the new Minister of Fisheries, Stuart Nash, to delay implementation of camera monitoring of fishing efforts in New Zealand is ‘fatally flawed’. More>>

ALSO:

Kaikōura Quakes: One Year On

State Highway One and the railway were blocked by damage and slips and the Inland Road suffered significant damage. Farms, homes and businesses suffered building and land damage. Power and internet went down, drinking water systems, sewage systems and local roads were all badly affected... More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  • Bill Bennett on Tech