Gattung speech raises serious questions
Gattung speech raises serious questions -
InternetNZ Media Release - for immediate release
Wednesday 1 November 2006
“Yesterday’s address by Theresa Gattung to a TUANZ audience in Wellington raises serious questions, and she should not attack those who ask important questions about how Telecom is behaving,” said InternetNZ President Colin Jackson today.
Mr Jackson was responding to yesterday’s speech, which sought to position Telecom’s response to the Government’s May stocktake announcements as constructive and restrained. The speech also attacked those who have criticised Telecom’s less than constructive responses in some areas in recent months.
“It should be a matter of serious public concern when the speech of the Chief Executive of such an important company as Telecom is at significant variance from the observed behaviour of her own company,” Colin Jackson said.
“Two examples suffice.
“Ms Gattung said ‘We’ve implemented the Wholesale Charter’, but this doesn’t seem to be true.
“Principle 2 of the Charter says: ‘The price for such products will be negotiated on a ‘retail minus’ basis…’, but Telecom did not negotiate on the price of the services that rolled out on 26 October. It presented the new prices as a done deal, and wholesale customers had no negotiation over this price at all. It is not acceptable to expect ISPs to compete at retail – on any UBS plan – at the current unilateral pricing.
“Ms Gattung said with respect to new unconstrained DSL plans that ‘The regulated price is set by the Telecommunications Commissioner not by Telecom.’
“The clear implication is that Telecom has no discretion over pricing. That is simply not true. The Commission’s price applies only to regulated UBS services, not to Telecom’s commercial offering. It is Telecom’s choice – and Telecom’s responsibility – that has seen the current price squeeze come into existence across all the UBS plans, not just entry level.
Mr Jackson was also unhappy with Ms Gattung’s attack on reasonable critics of Telecom’s behaviour.
“In her speech, Ms Gattung says that ‘We have had to bite our tongues when some in the industry make claims and allegations that get a run in the media, even if they are patently untrue.’
“Ms Gattung needs to expand on who she thinks is making untrue claims, and what claims she considers to be untrue. That is the only way her claims can be assessed and a proper debate can occur.
“The examples given above seem to show an
unfortunate tendency by Telecom to shoot the messenger and
use spin instead of substance when responding to legitimate
“Telecom has made improvements, but it should be judged by its actions, not its fine words.
“Its actions show a price squeeze caused by its own pricing choices.
“Its actions show that it is not following its own Wholesale Charter despite asserting that it does so.
“Its words suggest the opposite.
“These are serious questions and InternetNZ makes no apology for raising them.
“Media need to ask the tough questions, and challenge Telecom to do what it says it will do, and hold the company accountable when it fails to meet such a modest expectation,” Colin Jackson concluded.