Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


The true cost of personal grievance?

21 December 2006

The true cost of personal grievance?

Canterbury Manufacturers’ Association is warning that not only are an increasing number of businesses coming under pressure from employment advocates to offer out of court, cash payments to former employees but these ‘unofficial’ settlements are distorting the indications in official statistics.

The Government reports that between 2003 and 2005, the number of cases heard by the Employment Relations Authority has remained consistent between 1700 and 1800 and the number of cases going to mediation has fallen. It also reports that for the same period, the average amount awarded at mediation is between $5000 and $6000 and the CMA says that while some take this as an indication of success for the legislation, unofficial settlements might not support such a conclusion.

“The CMA supports the Employers and Manufacturers Association (Northern) position that an increasing number of companies are being confronted by demands for a pay off by advocates working on behalf of employees as a quick settlement”, says Chief Executive John Walley. “With this practice taken into consideration, the CMA places the average cost of settlement closer to $8000 rather than between $5000 and $6000 and we have heard of this going much higher when legal costs are added into the equation”.

Mr. Walley says that in its current form, the Employment Relations Act is open to exploitation. “Unfortunately, the complexity of the legislation enables personal grievance cases to be manipulated by advocates supporting employees with nothing to loose in pursuing unsound claims against employers. It is now much easier for the practiced ambulance chasing advocates to characterise cases as stress or harassment, these areas are highly subjective and difficult to deal with, without practice and precise procedural accuracy. The ‘no-win, no-fee’ environment encourages gaming by employees and their advocates, overall the real winners are the third parties involved gaming or responding to gaming in the system”.

Mr. Walley says that a growing number of companies are adopting a policy of refusing unofficial settlements. This is forcing them to become more aware of how to run good process and implement better management practices. It is noticeable how quickly the stand over approach evaporates once it becomes known that a “no unofficial settlement” approach exists with a particular employer – the ambulance chasers go elsewhere for easier pickings.

“Both employers and their staff need to be well educated on their obligations and rights under employment legislation”, says Mr. Walley. “The cash cost aside, there is the opportunity cost associated with the time involved and the impact on a company’s performance; especially as it is often the owners or senior management involved in defending a personal grievance as opposed to running their businesses. Companies, especially the more vulnerable start-up or small and medium enterprises, can face comparatively significant costs in the personal grievance area; the money has to come from somewhere”.

“Rather than look exclusively at the number of cases dealt with officially by the Employment Relations Authority, the focus should be on educating employers and employees of their obligations under the legislation. In the longer term deal the self-interested gaming, and amend the legislation to eliminate the complex procedural requirements and subjective grievance issues”.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Media Mega Merger: StuffMe Hearing Argues Over Moveable Feast

New Zealand's two largest news publishers are appealing against the Commerce Commission's rejection of the proposal to merge their operations. More>>


Approval: Northern Corridor Decision Released

The approval gives the green light to construction of the last link of Auckland’s Western Ring Route, providing an alternative route from South Auckland to the North Shore. More>>


Crown Accounts: $4.1 Billion Surplus

The New Zealand Government has achieved its third fiscal surplus in a row with the Crown accounts for the year ended 30 June 2017 showing an OBEGAL surplus of $4.1 billion, $2.2 billion stronger than last year, Finance Minister Steven Joyce says. More>>


Mycoplasma Bovis: One New Property Tests Positive

The newly identified property... was already under a Restricted Place notice under the Biosecurity Act. More>>

Accounting Scandal: Suspension Of Fuji Xerox From All-Of-Government Contract

General Manager of New Zealand Government Procurement John Ivil says, “FXNZ has been formally suspended from the Print Technology and Associated Services (PTAS) contract and terminated from the Office Supplies contract.” More>>