Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Environment gives reluctant support for ECan plan

Environment Ministry gives ECan commissioner 'reluctant' approval

By Paul McBeth

April 1 (BusinessWire) – The Ministry for the Environment has backed a government plan to replace Environment Canterbury councillors with a commission, albeit reluctantly.

MfE director of natural and built systems Mark Sowden said that although the proposal was the only one put forward that will likely meet the government’s objectives, there were “significant risks” in suspending local body elections, and that such a course of action “should only be considered in exceptional circumstances,” according to the ministry’s regulatory impact statement (RIS).
The short timeframe to draft the legislation increased the risk that intervention was “incorrectly targeted” and could lead to unintended consequences that would require later legislation, he said.

“While the ministry has a general preference for using existing intervention powers where possible, there are strong arguments for legislative amendment in this case; and also for replaced the whole ECan council,” Sowden said in the RIS’s agency disclosure statement. “However, on the basis of currently available information, the ministry has not been able to fully quantify the risks/costs of the proposal.”

Parliament passed the Environment Canterbury Bill last night after the House sat under urgency for two days. The new law sacks ECan’s regional councillors and replaces them with a commission led by Margaret Bazley within the next month. The legislation follows a damning report over ECan’s failure to successfully manage freshwater demands over the past two decades in a region where much of the water is over-allocated amid growing irrigation, hydro-electric and water storage demands. The government aims to restore local body elections to the region in 2013.

In February, Prime Minister John Key flagged water as a major resource for New Zealand and a key component to the government’s agenda. In his speech to open Parliament this year, he said the government would act to remove regulatory hurdles to water storage and irrigation in Canterbury.

Still, the MfE paper said the appointment of commissioners was a “significant intrusion into local government powers” and risked alienating the Canterbury community who may perceive it as “removing the democratic rights of Canterbury without consultation.”

“This response is unprecedented under the LGA (Local Government Act) and RMA (Resource Management Act), and if unsuccessful is likely to result in the government coming under significant criticism,” the report said.

With the costs of maintaining the status quo put at a rough estimate of between $2 billion and $3 billion annually in litigation costs, opportunities costs and degradation to New Zealand’s international brand, the MfE report said “central government intervention is necessary and justified to address this issue” with the divide between ECan’s councillors having a material effect on its ability to produce robust central planning.

The exercise is expected to be revenue neutral, with the savings from not holding an election or paying councillor salaries offset by the commissioners’ fees and drafting costs of the bill.

The RIS also flagged the need for the commissioners to have a “strong understanding of the Ngai Tahu perspective, rights and interests.” Any intervention that altered the relationship between the South Island iwi and the agency overseeing decision-making on natural resources need to take the government’s Treaty of Waitangi obligations into account, the report said.

(BusinessWire)

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Marsden Pipeline Rupture: Report Calls For Supply Improvements, Backs Digger Blame

The report makes several recommendations on how the sector can better prevent, prepare for, respond to, and recover from an incident. In particular, we consider it essential that government and industry work together to put in place and regularly practise sector-wide response plans, to improve the response to any future incident… More>>

ALSO:

Oil Scare: Trump Authorises Use Of Emergency Crude Stockpile

The New Zealand dollar fell against the US dollar after President Donald Trump authorised the use of the country's emergency crude stockpile after the weekend attack on Saudi Arabia’s major oil facilities. More>>

ALSO:

Pre-Post-Brexit Deal Talks: UK Trade Minister Visits Wellington

New Zealand should get a better deal for exports of sheepmeat, beef and dairy products into the United Kingdom after Brexit, the British Minister of State for Trade, Liz Truss, said in Wellington today. More>>

ALSO:

Not-Very Well: Tamarind Halts Tui Drilling; OMV Assesses Options

Tamarind Resources has halted drilling at its Tui oil field off the Taranaki coast after the first of the three planned wells came up dry. Managing director Ian Angell says that despite the “unexpected” result from the first well, the firm believes the other two prospects are worth pursuing. More>>

ALSO:

Seeking 'Clarity': Crown To Appeal Southern Response Decision, Offers Costs

“It is our intention that the clarity that will come from the outcome of these proceedings will enable the Crown to work with Southern Response to provide a soundly based proactive solution to those people that are affected.” More>>