Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Good and bad news in ComCom decisions


Media release
Good and bad news in ComCom decisions

Wednesday 29th December 2010

“The Commerce Commission decisions for monopoly electricity, gas and airfield services are a mixed bag for consumers” said Ralph Matthes, Executive Director of MEUG. He was commenting on the decision on 23rd December by the Commerce Commission on Input Methodologies covering asset valuation, cost of capital, allocation of costs, treatment of tax etc1.

“For asset valuations the decision is good news, as summarised in the foreword to the decision:
“In the case of asset valuation, all regulated suppliers have strongly argued for asset valuations at the start of the Part 4 regime that are likely to be significantly higher than the regulatory valuations already in place. In the case of electricity distribution businesses, adopting this approach could legitimise price increases that would, based on what we believe to be a very conservative assessment, result in transfers from consumers to suppliers of almost $2 billion for no corresponding benefit. The Commission was not convinced by this proposition.”

“It is the cost of capital decision that there is good and bad news. The good news is the Commission has been unconvinced by the inflated claims by the 28 distribution companies, Transpower and their advisors for various up lifts in how cost of capital is determined.

“The bad news is the Commission has affirmed its draft decision to use a model that the Commission itself acknowledges is flawed2. In addition the final decision exacerbates the flaw to the disadvantage of consumers. The reasoning for continuing with the flawed model is not convincing. Consumers will pay3an extra $117 million per annum for monopoly electricity, gas and airfield services because the Commission has persisted with the flawed model.

“The Commission’s use of the acknowledged flawed model is in contrast to The New Zealand Treasury “Estimation of Crown’s Opportunity Cost of Capital” 4. The Commission decision doesn’t mention The Treasury guidelines even though we noted the disparity in our submissions. We think The Treasury, responsible for managing $161 billion of assets5(not counting financial assets) has got the cost of capital model right and the Commission regulating approximately $16 billion of monopoly businesses has got it wrong. Both can’t be correct.

1 Commerce Commission, Input Methodologies (Electricity Distribution and Gas Pipeline Services) Reasons Paper, 23rd December 2010, refer http://www.comcom.govt.nz/assets/Pan-Industry/Input-Methodologies/Final-Reasons-Papers/EDB-GPB-Input-Methodologies-Reasons-Paper-Dec-2010.pdf

2 A detailed explanation of this flaw is set out in the expert opinion of Garth Ireland, Ireland, Wallace & Associates, Input Methodologies (Electricity Distribution Services) Draft Reasons Paper, June 2010, Submission on Cost of Capital, 13th August 2010, refer http://www.comcom.govt.nz/assets/Pan-Industry/Input-Methodologies/Draft-Reasons-Papers/Draft-Reasons-EDBs/Costcapital-Sub/MEUG-Attachment-Submission-on-EDB-Input-Methodologies-Draft-Determination-and-Reasons-Paper-IWA-Paper-13-August-2010.pdf.

Commerce Commission acknowledgement of the model flaw is set out in, Input Methodologies (Electricity Distribution Services) Draft Reasons Paper, June 2010, paragraphs 6.3.42 to 6.3.44, refer http://www.comcom.govt.nz/assets/Pan-Industry/Input-Methodologies/Draft-Determinations-CC-Papers/Input-Methodologies-Electricity-Distribution-Services-Draft-Reasons-Paper-June-2010.pdf.

3 The $117m estimate is set out in MEUG to Commerce Commission, Submission on Pan Industry Input Methodologies for cost of capital, 13th August 2010, paragraph 6, refer http://www.comcom.govt.nz/assets/Pan-Industry/Input-Methodologies/Draft-Reasons-Papers/Draft-Reasons-EDBs/Costcapital-Sub/MEUG-Submission-on-EDB-Input-Methodologies-Draft-Determination-and-Reasons-Paper-13-August-2010.pdf.

The Commerce Commission decision paper of 23rd December 2010 changed leverage from 40% to 44%. This increase in leverage will increase charges payable by consumers, ie greater than prior estimate of $117m per annum.

4 The Treasury, Estimation of Crown’s Opportunity Cost of Capital, July 2008, refer http://www.treasury.govt.nz/publications/guidance/planning/costbenefitanalysis/discountrates/02.htm The web page referencing this Treasury report was updated in October 2010 and retains the cost of capital model proposed by MEUG and not the flawed model in the Commerce Commission final Determination.

5 Refer COMU media presentation 7th December 2010. Total Crown balance sheet is $220 billion. Less financial assets of $59 billion equal $161 billion.

End

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Retail: International Websites To Pay GST

New rules would be aimed at imported goods valued at or below $1,000. Customs would retain responsibility for collecting GST on imported parcels valued more than $1,000. More>>

ALSO:

High-Level Advice: PM’s Business Advisory Council Membership Announced

The Prime Minister’s Business Advisory Council brings together a mix of experts, six women and seven men with small to large business experience, from across New Zealand, to provide advice. More>>

ALSO:

Improving: Report Shows New Zealand Air Quality 'Good'

Our air 2018, produced by the Ministry for the Environment and Stats NZ, shows that while some previously known issues persist, progress has been made and levels of some pollutants are declining. More>>

ALSO:

Greenpeace: Govt Extends OMV Exploration Permit

The Government has just granted oil giant OMV a two-year extension to drill in the Great South Basin, despite issuing a ban on new oil and gas exploration permits in April. More>>

ALSO:

Collective Bargaining For Contractors: Working Group's Model For Screen Sector

A recommended model to allow collective bargaining for contractors in the screen sector has today been unveiled by the Government-convened Film Industry Working Group. More>>

ALSO:

Kauri Dieback: DOC Closing Tracks To Protect Trees

The Department of Conservation will close 21 tracks across kauri land to help prevent the spread of kauri dieback. An additional 10 tracks will also be partially closed and the open sections upgraded... More>>