Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 


Belgrave Finance auditor loses bid to quash negligence claim

Belgrave Finance auditor loses bid to throw out accusations of negligence

By Paul McBeth

Nov. 13 (BusinessDesk) - Accounting firm Hayes Knight has lost a bid to throw out accusations it breached its duty of care in signing off on Belgrave Finance accounts, and is one of several parties being sued by the receivers of the failed lender.

Associate Judge John Matthews dismissed an application to strike out Belgrave's case against Hayes Knight, provided the claim was amended to more clearly demonstrate the auditor's alleged culpability, he said in a Nov. 7 judgment. Belgrave has filed six causes of action against former directors Shane Buckley and Steven Smith, their associate Raymond Schofield, solicitors Davidson, Armstrong & Campbell and Hayes Knight.

The judge agreed with Belgrave's lawyer, Bruce Stewart QC, who argued the losses were caused "by the very fact of continued trading" and that it was an issue for a trial to determine, rather than a strike out application.

Belgrave claims that had Hayes Knight done a "careful, diligent and professionally appropriate" audit, the lender wouldn't have issued the 2007 prospectus and would probably have been placed into receivership earlier than it ultimately was in 2008.

From the time of the offer document, the lender advanced some $3.8 million, including to Schofield and related entities, and received $4.9 million from debenture stockholders which it was unable to repay.

Stewart "acknowledges that the plaintiff will have to prove these contentions at trial, but says that if proved the losses claimed are the recoverable consequence of Hayes Knight's negligence," the judgment said.

Judge Matthews ordered Belgrave to "clearly plead relevant facts to show that the losses claimed were the result of the decision to continue to trade."

Costs were reserved, though the judge said his immediate view was to let them lie where they fell.

In August, former Belgrave director Buckley was sentenced to three years in jail after pleading guilty to 19 charges of theft by a person in a special relationship, and four charges of false statement by promoter under the Crimes Act. He also pleaded guilty to one Securities Act charge of making an untrue statement and one Companies Act charge of making a false statement to a trustee.

The Serious Fraud Office has levelled similar charges against Smith and Schofield, who are due to stand trial in April next year.

(BusinessDesk)

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Tourism: China Southern Airlines To Fly To Christchurch

China Southern Airlines, in partnership with Christchurch Airport and the South Island tourism industry, has announced today it will begin flying directly between Guangzhou, Mainland China and the South Island. More>>

ALSO:

Dodgy: Truck Shops Come Under Scrutiny

Mobile traders, or truck shops, target poorer communities, particularly in Auckland, with non-compliant contracts, steep prices and often lower-quality goods than can be bought at ordinary shops, a Commerce Commission investigation has found. More>>

ALSO:

Auckland Transport: Government, Council Agree On Funding Approach

The government and Auckland Council have reached a detente over transport funding, establishing a one-year, collaborative timetable for decisions on funding for the city's transport infrastructure growth in the next 30 years after the government refused to fund the $2 billion of short and medium-term plans outlined in Auckland's draft Unitary Plan. More>>

ALSO:

Bullish On China Shock: Slumping Equities, Commodities May Continue, But Not A GFC

The biggest selloff in stock markets in at least four years, slumping commodity prices and a surge in Wall Street's fear gauge don't mean the world economy is heading for another global financial crisis, fund managers say. More>>

ALSO:

Real Estate: Investors Driving Up Auckland Housing Risk - RBNZ

The growing presence of investors in Auckland's property market is increasing the risks, and is likely to both amplify the housing cycle and worsen the potential damage from a downturn both to the financial system and the broader economy, said Reserve Bank deputy governor Grant Spencer. More>>

ALSO:

Annual Record: Overseas Visitors Hit 3 Million Milestone

Visitor arrivals to New Zealand surpassed 3 million for the first time in the July 2015 year, Statistics New Zealand said today. The record-breaking 3,002,982 visitors this year was 7 percent higher than the July 2014 year. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Business
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news