Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 


Advance Australia Fair and Make New Zealand Fairer

A time to Reflect on What Might Have Been
Advance Australia Fair and Make New Zealand Fairer

by Peter Neilson | Chief Executive, Financial Services Council
26 January 2014

This year we expect that the New Zealand economy will grow faster than Australia’s. That is good news for us but cannot mask the fact that for most of the last 40 years the Australian economy has out-performed ours year after year. As a result Australian incomes are now 30% higher than our own.

There is no one magic bullet to close that gap and, as the Hon Bill English likes to say, economic success comes from doing a lot of little things right for a very long time.

One of the big things the Australians have got right over the past 20 years is getting most working Australians contributing into a superannuation scheme to give them a comfortable income in retirement.

Australian employees started contributing into their Superannuation Guarantee Scheme in 1992, more than 20 years ago, and the total funds in their Scheme now equal $A1.7 trillion, that is $A1,700,000,000,000. As a result, Australians own a considerable proportion of their mining industry through their superannuation savings. They are therefore not just benefitting from the mineral royalties; they are also getting a significant share of the profits. In contrast, the majority of NZ based corporates are owned by foreigners.

We could have been in a similar position. Forty years ago, back in 1974, the New Zealand Parliament passed legislation to create our own compulsory superannuation scheme that would have seen us contributing 8% of our salaries, 4% from the employee and 4% from the employer.

A few years ago Brian Gaynor, the columnist and Executive Director of Milford Asset Management, estimated that if the 1974 scheme was still in place we would have more than $NZ240 billion in superannuation funds now. He also said the New Zealand economy would have been transformed into a world-beater.

Unfortunately, the next Government abolished the scheme, having campaigned to do so, promising future pensioners that NZ Super would be increased by 30%. In a recent poll almost 3 out of 4 New Zealanders felt that abolishing the 1974 superannuation scheme was a mistake.

A person entering into a job in Australia this year at the average wage can expect to retire on a pension of $A69,000 pa in 40 years time. The average New Zealander, without a superannuation scheme, will rely on NZ Super which is expected to provide $NZ31,000 pa in 40 years time. So the average Australian at retirement will be on a pension much more than two times what someone in New Zealand will receive from NZ Super alone.

You may think what Australia does with its Superannuation Guarantee Scheme does not matter but it is another benefit for young New Zealanders moving to Australia for work. Last year, polling we commissioned revealed that 47% of New Zealanders aged 18 to 26 felt that knowing about the Australian scheme made them more inclined to work in Australia. If younger New Zealanders move to Australia to work it will make funding NZ Super even more difficult as our population ages and lives longer, so tax rates will need to rise.

KiwiSaver has been a positive change but New Zealanders in KiwiSaver default schemes are put into conservative assets which earn less and are subject to the heaviest effective income taxation. In contrast, a typical Australian default investor is mainly invested in growth assets which are more volatile year by year but, over the long haul, tend to out-perform conservative assets.

The Australians started off with a low contribution rate and now contribute 9.25% of their salaries into their super accounts. There is cross-party support for that number to grow in the future to 12%. If we don’t expand the coverage of and contributions into KiwiSaver we may find ourselves still working after 70, picking up the bags of much more wealthy Australian retirees.

This year we will have the opportunity to consider how we might close the emerging pension gap with Australia. We will have a general election where the option of making KiwiSaver universal or compulsory for employees will be the subject of debate. New Zealanders believe that we should be able to save to have the comfortable retirements enjoyed by most people in other OECD countries.

A comfortable retirement should not just be for former long serving MPs or public servants or members of the now rare private sector defined benefit schemes.

This is the debate whose time has come. Most New Zealanders now support making KiwiSaver compulsory so finding out where each party stands on the issue this year will be interesting.

We send our best wishes to Australians on their national day and hope this year sees us on the way to catching them up.

The FSC has not taken a position on whether KiwiSaver should be compulsory or remain voluntary.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Cosmetics & Pollution: Proposal To Ban Microbeads

Cosmetic products containing microbeads will be banned under a proposal announced by the Minister for the Environment today. Marine scientists have been advocating for a ban on the microplastics, which have been found to quickly enter waterways and harm marine life. More>>

ALSO:

NIWA: 2016 New Zealand’s Warmest Year On Record

Annual temperatures were above average (0.51°C to 1.20°C above the annual average) throughout the country, with very few locations observing near average temperatures (within 0.5°C of the annual average) or lower. The year 2016 was the warmest on record for New Zealand, based on NIWA’s seven-station series which begins in 1909. More>>

ALSO:

Farewell 2016: NZ Economy Flies Through 2016's Political Curveballs

Dec. 23 (BusinessDesk) - New Zealand's economy batted away some curly political curveballs of 2016 to end the year on a high note, with its twin planks of a booming construction sector and rampant tourism soon to be joined by a resurgent dairy industry. More>>

ALSO:


NZ Economy: More Growth Than Expected In 3rd Qtr

Dec. 22 (BusinessDesk) - New Zealand's economy grew at a faster pace than expected in the September quarter as a booming construction sector continued to underpin activity, spilling over into related building services, and was bolstered by tourism and transport ... More>>

  • NZ Govt - Solid growth for NZ despite fragile world economy
  • NZ Council of Trade Unions - Government needs to ensure economy raises living standards
  • KiwiRail Goes Deisel: Cans electric trains on partially electrified North Island trunkline

    Dec. 21 (BusinessDesk) – KiwiRail, the state-owned rail and freight operator, said a small fleet of electric trains on New Zealand’s North Island would be phased out over the next two years and replaced with diesel locomotives. More>>

  • KiwiRail - KiwiRail announces fleet decision on North Island line
  • Greens - Ditching electric trains massive step backwards
  • Labour - Bill English turns ‘Think Big’ into ‘Think Backwards’
  • First Union - Train drivers condemn KiwiRail’s return to “dirty diesel”
  • NZ First - KiwiRail Going Backwards for Xmas
  • NIWA: The Year's Top Science Findings

    Since 1972 NIWA has operated a Clean Air Monitoring Station at Baring Head, near Wellington... In June, Baring Head’s carbon dioxide readings officially passed 400 parts per million (ppm), a level last reached more than three million years ago. More>>

    ALSO:

    Get More From Scoop

     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Business
    Search Scoop  
     
     
    Powered by Vodafone
    NZ independent news