Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 


Review panel misses accident root causes

Review panel misses accident root causes

The Forest Industry Contractors Association (FICA) has slammed the consultation document prepared by the Independent Forest Safety Review for a lack of health and safety credibility. There is a glaring lack of root cause analysis and factual data as a basis for discussions with forestry workers.

Spokesman John Stulen said, “The document is full of union-prompted innuendo and fiction. The panel has failed to get root cause analysis of the very accidents that brought about the call for a review. Where are the facts about hours of work across industry? What are the rates of pay? What are the underlying causes of accidents? Where and when do they happen, and to whom? Without these facts to support a conversation with our industry there is not much reliable to go on.”

So far, panel members have steered clear of accessing our long-standing industry-driven ‘Incident Reporting Information System’ operates and the facts it holds. The root cause analysis of 10,000 near misses is far stronger than arguing about the cause of 10 fatalities. Facts, not emotion, are the pathway to a real solution.

If they looked they would see it shows that for over 5 years we have been focused on the key areas of serious harm with results now starting to show through. There has been a marked reduction in these accidents since late 2013. There is some fiction in options put forward which suggest that if unions are pushed in they are somehow going to solve all of our problems. It’s time the panel realised they should start the facts and science of health and safety to see where the real solutions will be found.”

“Too many assumptions have been made, based on very loud politically-driven opinions of people, with very little understanding or connection to our industry.”

“The facts are that forestry has three kinds of operators – the good, the bad and the really ugly. Our members are very good – most are mainly tertiary-accredited to the ACC system for workplace safety management plans, many are exceptional and have won National pan- industry safety awards. The many part-time operators are other rural contractors that have quickly set up harvesting crews; they’re the bad ones; often working without employment contracts or providing proper protective equipment. The really ugly ones are those who don’t obey the most basic laws about notification required for commencing bush work. WorkSafe inspectors don't even know they’re out there operating!”

“Many of the suggested options are completely obvious, for example, asking whether all forestry workers should have employment contracts that meet minimum standards. That’s not an issue among our members’ workforces. It’s simply what that the WorkSafe inspectors should have been enforcing as part of their job for the rest. But for years the’ve been denied adequate resources to do properly by constant restructuring.”

Stulen says the real solutions are to get rid of shady operators now once and for all. He says it’s a job that WorkSafe inspectors have shied away from in the past but it is time for them to front

up and find the shady operators in farm forests. Many fly-by-night operators have never had a visit from a WorkSafe inspector.

“The panel’s discussion document is looks too tainted by unions. They want to use this process to get laws changed to give them priority access to our workers. Well, we’re confident that workers with our contractor members will tell the panel that consultation and inclusion have always been a part of the workplaces they are in.”

As it stands, Stulen says, this review is at risk of becoming just another superficial look from the outside industry without fully understanding the root causes of what’s gone wrong.

“We have tried to engage with unions on injury prevention and accident investigation but unless they get their own way 100%, they just throw a tantrum and walk out of the room. They wouldn’t ever be willing to accept the science of fact-based health and safety solutions because it does not suit their agenda to get mandatory worker representation.”

Ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Gordon Campbell: On Tiwai Point (And Saying “No” In Greece)

Its hard to see how Rio Tinto’s one month delay in announcing its intentions about the Tiwai Point aluminium smelter is a good sign for (a) the jobs of the workers affected or (b) for the New Zealand taxpayer. More>>

ALSO:

Half Empty: Dairy Product Prices Extend Slide To Six-Year Low

Dairy product prices continued their slide, paced by whole milk power, in the latest GlobalDairyTrade auction, weakening to the lowest level in six years. More>>

ALSO:

Copper Broadband: Regulator Set To Keep Chorus Pricing Largely Unchanged

The Commerce Commission looks likely to settle on a price close to its original decision on what telecommunications network operator Chorus can charge its customers, though it probably won’t backdate any update. More>>

ALSO:

Lower Levy For Safer Cars: ACC Backtracks On Safety Assessments

Dog and Lemon: “The ACC has based the entire levy system on a set of badly flawed data from Monash University. This Monash data is riddled with errors and false assumptions; that’s the real reason for the multiple mistakes in setting ACC levies.” More>>

ALSO:

Fast Track: TPP Negotiations Set To Accelerate, Groser Says

Negotiations for the Trans-Pacific Partnership will accelerate in July, with New Zealand officials working to stitch up a deal by the month's end, according to Trade Minister Tim Groser. More>>

ALSO:

Floods: Initial Assessment Of Economic Impact

Authorities around the region have compiled an initial impact assessment for the Ministry of Civil Defence, putting the estimated cost of flood recovery at around $120 million... this early estimate includes social, built, and economic costs to business, but doesn’t include costs to the rural sector. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Business
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news