Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Court ruling a win for consumer rights

Court ruling a win for consumer rights and reminder to traders
Issued 9 September 2014

Release No. 29

The Commerce Commission says a recent precedent-setting Court of Appeal decision is a win for consumers and a reminder to traders tha¬t it is not good enough to hide important information in fine print, or where consumers need to hunt for it.

The case involved a dispute between carpet manufacturers Godfrey Hirst and Cavalier Bremworth. Godfrey Hirst alleged that Cavalier Bremworth’s claims about its “superb lifetime” carpet warranties were misleading. Godfrey Hirst alleged that claims about the warranties were misleading because the benefits of the warranties were significantly limited by terms and conditions contained in fine print or on a separate webpage.

Godfrey Hirst was successful with some of its claims in the High Court, but appealed to the Court of Appeal to seek guidance on matters dismissed by the High Court.

The Commission was granted leave to be heard in the Court of Appeal. The Commission’s General Counsel, Competition, Mary-Anne Borrowdale, said, “We became involved in the appeal because the consumer issues were of significant public interest.

“We have become increasingly concerned about the prevalence of misleading headline claims in advertising, especially online, where bold headline statements are made but they are then undermined by terms in the fine print. We want businesses and consumers to have a clear sense of what the ground rules are.”

The Court of Appeal decision clarified a number of important points, including that:

• All consumers are entitled to the protection of the Fair Trading Act, not just the knowledgeable, well-off or sophisticated.

• Claims are made to all members of the target audience, except for “outliers” which includes those who are “ill-equipped” or “whose reactions are extreme or fanciful”.

• When assessing whether a claim breaches the Fair Trading Act, it is the dominant message of the headline that is important.

• Where there is a glaring disparity between the dominant message of the headline and the information qualifying it, the maker of the statement must draw the disparity to the consumer’s attention in the clearest possible way.

• The Fair Trading Act will be breached where a claim has lured a consumer into “the marketing web” by misleading means. It does not matter that the consumer may come to appreciate the true position before the transaction is completed.

“We are pleased to have the guidance that this judgment provides, which we think sets clear rules for traders and goes a long way to ensuring New Zealand consumers are protected from misleading trade practices,” Ms Borrowdale said.

The Court of Appeal ruling can be viewed on the Commission website:


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Mycoplasma Bovis: More Properties Positive

One of the latest infected properties is in the Hastings district, the other three are within a farming enterprise in Winton. The suspect property is near Ashburton. More>>


Manawatū Gorge Alternative: More Work Needed To Choose Route

“We are currently working closely and in partnership with local councils and other stakeholders to make the right long-term decision. It’s vital we have strong support on the new route as it will represent a very significant long-term investment and it will need to serve the region and the country for decades to come.” More>>


RBNZ: Super Fund Chief To Be New Reserve Bank Governor

Adrian Orr has been appointed as Reserve Bank Governor effective from 27 March 2018, Finance Minister Grant Robertson says. More>>


ScoopPro: Helping PR Professionals Get More Out Of Scoop has been a fixture of New Zealand’s news and Public Relations infrastructure for over 18 years. However, without the financial assistance of those using Scoop in a professional context in key sectors such as Public Relations and media, Scoop will not be able to continue this service... More>>

Insurance: 2017 Worst Year On Record For Weather-Related Losses

The Insurance Council of New Zealand (ICNZ) announced today that 2017 has been the most expensive year on record for weather-related losses, with a total insured-losses value of more than $242 million. More>>