Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Bell Gully acts on a significant tax avoidance win

Press release – 8 November 2018

Bell Gully acts on a significant tax avoidance win

Bell Gully represented Frucor Suntory New Zealand Limited in Frucor Suntory New Zealand Limited v Commissioner of Inland Revenue, a High Court decision which marks an important victory for New Zealand tax-paying entities on tax avoidance.

The decision was released earlier this week. A copy of the judgment is available here.

The case is a rare victory for a taxpayer on tax avoidance. The taxpayer, represented by Bell Gully and barrister Lindsay McKay, successfully rebutted the allegation that its use of convertible note financing to fund its New Zealand business was a tax avoidance arrangement. In recent years taxpayers have had limited success in resisting tax avoidance allegations and this decision may be the first step in rebalancing the position.

Bell Gully partner, Mathew McKay, who acted on the matter, describes Justice Muir’s judgment as “logical and insightful” and as being “founded on a firm understanding of the relevant tax principles”. The judgment addresses a number of significant matters:

• It accepts that Parliament would have contemplated that taxpayers would ordinarily be entitled to interest deductions on debt instruments, if set at an arm’s length rate.

• It confirms that the presence of unorthodox features in an internal arrangement between group companies will not necessarily be regarded as “artificial” features in a tax avoidance analysis – it is the tax outcomes that must be considered.

• It reinforces the traditional separate legal entity approach in an international tax context.

• It provides an indication that shortfall penalties will not automatically follow a finding of tax avoidance.

Mathew McKay expects that the judgment “will serve as a reminder to the IRD that future allegations of tax avoidance will need to be built up from rational argument that pays attention to existing policy and legislative design.”


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Ground Rules: Government Moves To Protect Best Growing Land

“Continuing to grow food in the volumes and quality we have come to expect depends on the availability of land and the quality of the soil. Once productive land is built on, we can’t use it for food production, which is why we need to act now.” More>>


Royal Society: Calls For Overhaul Of Gene-Technology Regulations

An expert panel considering the implications of new technologies that allow much more controlled and precise ‘editing’ of genes, has concluded it’s time for an overhaul of the regulations and that there’s an urgent need for wide discussion and debate about gene editing... More>>


Retail: Card Spending Dips In July

Seasonally-adjusted electronic card spending dipped in July by 0.1 percent after being flat in June, according to Stats NZ. Economists had expected a 0.5 percent lift, according to the median in a Bloomberg poll. More>>


Product Stewardship: Govt Takes More Action To Reduce Waste

The Government is proposing a new way to deal with environmentally harmful products before they become waste, including plastic packing and bottles, as part of a wider plan to reduce the amount of rubbish ending up in landfills. More>>


Earnings Update: Fonterra Sees Up To $675m Loss On Writedowns

“While the Co-op’s FY19 underlying earnings range is within the current guidance of 10-15 cents per share, when you take into consideration these likely write-downs, we expect to make a reported loss of $590-675 million this year, which is a 37 to 42 cent loss per share." More>>