Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Mainzeal liquidators seek compensation in cross-appeal

Mainzeal liquidators seek twice as much compensation in cross-appeal


By Rebecca Howard

April 9 (BusinessDesk) - Mainzeal Property and Construction's liquidators want to double the amount of compensation the failed firm's directors, in particular chair Jenny Shipley, were ordered to pay, in cross-appealing a High Court ruling.

In late February, Justice Francis Cooke ruled that four directors of the failed construction company should pay $36 million to unsecured creditors. The Mainzeal directors had traded recklessly, Justice Cooke said, particularly by allowing the mostly loss-making company to trade for several years while technically insolvent.

The judge ordered Shipley, Tilby and Gomm were liable for up to $6 million each of the $36 million total. In the case of a fourth director, Richard Yan, who was also the founder and main shareholder of Mainzeal’s parent company, Shanghai-based Richina Pacific, Justice Cooke said he should be liable for the full $36 million. The four directors have already filed appeals.

In their cross-appeal, Mainzeal liquidators Andrew James Bethell and Brian Mayo-Smith said the court erred in applying a discount of two-thirds to the starting point for compensation of $110 million and limiting the directors' liability to $6 million each, or 5.45 percent of the total claims filed in liquidation.

They also said the court was wrong to order compensation from ex-Prime Minister Shipley at the same rate as Tilby and Gomm, "given her role as chairperson of Mainzeal, a director of other companies within the group... and her position as a director of, and her interest in, Richina Pacific Limited, Mainzeal’s holding company until 2009."

According to the cross-appeal, "her culpability was significantly greater than the culpability of Messrs Gomm and Tilby."

They want an order for the directors to be liable to the respondents for a percentage of the sum of $73.3 million, being two-thirds, as opposed to one-third of the total creditors' claims of $110 million.

Within that, they call for Shipley, Gomm and Tilby to be jointly and severally liable with Yan for no less than 20 percent of $73.3 million together with interest. It also seeks Shipley to be jointly and severally liable with Yan for an additional 30 percent of the sum of $73.3 million together with interest.

If other elements of their appeal are accepted they have suggested different calculations, all of which involved a higher amount in total and for Shipley in particular.

(BusinessDesk)

ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Super Fund/Canada Bid v NZTA: Tow Preferred Bidders For Auckland Light Rail

The two preferred delivery partners for Auckland light rail have been chosen and a final decision on who will build this transformational infrastructure will be made early next year, Minister of Transport Phil Twyford announced. More>>

ALSO:

9.3 Percent: Gender Pay Gap Unchanged Since 2017

“While it has remained flat since 2017, the gender pay gap has been trending down since the series began in 1998, when it was 16.2 percent,” labour market statistics manager Scott Ussher said. More>>

ALSO:

Ex-KPEX: Stuff Pulls Pin On Media Companies' Joint Ad-Buying Business

A four-way automated advertising collaboration between the country's largest media companies is being wound up after one of the four - Australian-owned Stuff - pulled the pin on its involvement as part of a strategic review of its operations ... More>>

Bus-iness: Transdev To Acquire More Auckland And Wellington Operations

Transdev Australasia today announced that it has agreed terms to acquire two bus operations in Auckland and Wellington, reaching agreement with Souter Investments to purchase Howick and Eastern Buses and Mana Coach Services. More>>

ALSO: