Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Statement in response to Court of Appeal decision

3 October 2019

Statement from Dr Alan Reay in response to the Court of Appeal decision released yesterday

The Court of Appeal has confirmed that IPENZ (ENZ) can re-start its 2012 complaint inquiry. I will now take time to consider that decision.

The Court of Appeal says that it may be in the public interest for that to happen. I acknowledge that view, even though it is 33 years after the events at the firm which I headed.

I have always rejected the complaint, given my reasons for that, and IPENZ dismissed the complaint years ago. I have already accounted for my actions to the Royal Commission, the Police, IPENZ, and a CPEng complaint hearing which found in my favour.

I am grateful for the support of the many clients, staff, friends and members of the public over the years. That support has continued and indeed grown over this long and difficult period. I am confident that if IPENZ (ENZ) does look further at the complaint, the wide support I have had will be found to be justified.

I do believe that a further complaint hearing is an unjustifiable waste of focus and resource for ENZ and our engineering profession.

As I said when I resigned from IPENZ, the urgent need and the best service to the public would come from ENZ's focus and resources on achieving better building standards and codes. Urgent needs I drew attention to then have still not been dealt with.

The collapse of the CTV building could have been avoided, as the evidence to the Royal Commission showed. I did not cause that, and other engineers who reviewed it during and after it was built did not see the faults in it.

That tragedy will continue to haunt me for the rest of my life – as I know it will many others. I have done everything within my reach to identify what happened and how the engineering profession can ensure that it will not happen again, including independent research and investigation. There is much work to do around building standards and codes, as the more recent 2016 earthquakes have demonstrated. It is my hope that this can be the priority focus for our profession from now on.

I will not be providing any further comment at this point.

Dr Alan M Reay


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


$7.5 Billion Surplus: Government Accounts "Show Strong Economy"

“The surplus and low levels of debt show the economy is in good shape. This allows the Government to spend more on infrastructure and make record investments in health and education,” Grant Robertson says. More>>


New OIO Application Trumps Judicial Review: OceanaGold Cleared To Buy Land For Waihi Tailings Expansion

In a surprise turnaround, the government has given OceanaGold a greenlight to buy land to expand its Waihi mine after the application was previously turned down by Land Information Minister Eugenie Sage. More>>


Christchurch Rebuild: Fletcher Sued For $7.5m Over Justice Precinct

Fletcher Building is being sued for $7.5 million by utilities contractor Electrix, one of the subcontractors on the Christchurch Justice and Emergency Services Precinct. More>>

Three New Drugs: PHARMAC Signs Bundle Deal For More Cancer Medicines

420 New Zealanders with lung cancer, breast cancer, multiple sclerosis and respiratory disease will benefit each year from a bundle deal PHARMAC has finalised with a medicine supplier. More>>


"Levels Playing Field": Government Responds To Electricity Price Review

The changes announced today include: • Supporting new and independent retailers by requiring the big power companies to sell into the wholesale market at affordable rates. • Extending discount rates to all customers • A pilot scheme to help customers who have not switched power providers before to shop around for better deals... More>>