Education Policy | Post Primary | Preschool | Primary | Tertiary | Search


Report Challenges Myths About Tertiary Reform

Report Challenges Myths About Tertiary Reform

A report released yesterday challenges several myths about the 1990s market-driven tertiary education reforms being bad for education, according to Norman LaRocque, policy advisor for the Education Forum.

The report, commissioned by the Australian Commonwealth government as an input into the review of Australian higher education, brings together comparative information from several countries, including New Zealand.

The myth that New Zealand didn't spend much on tertiary education (private and public) in the 1990s is shattered by figures that show:

Total expenditure on tertiary institutions as a proportion of GDP grew rapidly between 1993 and 2000 - from 1.5% in 1993 to 2.5% in 2000. During that time, New Zealand moved from behind to well ahead of Canada and Australia. By the year 2000, New Zealand ranked second to the US in expenditure on tertiary education institutions as a proportion of GDP - 2.5% versus 2.6% in the United States. New Zealand was well ahead of Sweden (1.8%), Canada (1.8%), Australia (1.4%), Germany (1.4%) and Ireland (1.1%). New Zealand was second only to the United States for total expenditure on tertiary institutions per capita in 2000. The report also shatters the commonly held view that New Zealand wasn't producing enough of the right type of jobs for a successful economy. In 1999, New Zealand had a higher proportion of graduates in science/agriculture, maths/computer science and engineering/manufacturing/construction than successful economies such as the United States, Australia, Canada and the Netherlands (although the number of engineers was low).

The report, entitled University Resourcing: Australia in an International Context and prepared by the Australian Productivity Commission, comes on the heels of another report, prepared by Australian Education International (AEI) and IDP Australia, showing that New Zealand's university costs for international students are generally lower than Australia, the United States and Canada.

"The information in the Productivity Commission and AEI/IDP Australia reports should give us pause to reflect on the myths that surround the reforms of the 1990s and the current prescriptions for 'fixing' the tertiary education sector that are included in the Tertiary Education Reform Bill," Mr LaRocque said.

"Other countries have recognised that New Zealand tertiary education policies were heading generally in the right direction during the 1990s and they are being emulated now around the OECD. New Zealand, meanwhile, is moving backwards."

Note: Summary statistics on the AEI/IDP Australia report and the Productivity Commission report are available on the Education Forum website

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Joseph Cederwall Review: NZSO Plays Bach And Ellington

The NZSO’s Shed Series returned for 2019 with the aptly titled REBIRTH at Shed 6 on Friday 8th. This theme dealt with the way in which music constantly evolves and changes, with styles and musical periods reborn in completely new and different ways. More>>

Howard Davis Review: Voulez-Vous Couchez Avec Moi? - C'est Chic, Ça Colette!

Starring the ravishingly vibrant Keira Knightley in the title role, Colette is a fairly pedestrian paint-by numbers biopic - which is a little disappointing, given that its cross-dressing and pansexual protagonist lead anything but a dull life. More>>

Wellington Repertory Theatre: New Season Includes Royal Hunt of The Sun

“The objective behind our ambitious 2019 season is to expand our offering to a broader range of Wellingtonians. It’s the first time in over a decade that we’ve produced four shows, and the first time we will be performing at the Hannah Payhouse,” says Oliver Mander, WRT’s President. More>>

Howard Davis Review: The Revenants - They Shall Not Grow Old

Jackson has toiled laboriously in the trenches of the digital revolution for decades, with his two turgid Tolkien trilogies constantly pushing the envelope in terms of computer-generated entertainment and providing his latest project with sufficient combat experience to warrant serious Oscar consideration for its remarkable technical achievements. More>>

Unseen Let It Be Footage: Peter Jackson Making "The Ultimate Beatles Film"

Jackson's new film will be compiled from fifty-five hours of never-released studio footage of The Beatles recording their final album Let It Be in January 1969. More>>

NZCT Grants More Than $150,000 to Community Sports

NZCT has approved grants to the Tauranga Boxing Academy, provided a new lease of life to old yachts, benefitted sports at Tiniroto School, and helped to upgrade Christchurch City BMX Club track. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland