Education Policy | Post Primary | Preschool | Primary | Tertiary | Search

 


Boys’ schools research flawed and unhelpful

Boys’ schools research flawed and unhelpful

by Martin Thrupp
20 June 2014

Families living near single sex schools might be pleased with the just-released research suggesting greater achievement for boys in single sex boys’ schools than for boys attending co-educational schools. But the research, undertaken by the New Zealand Council of Educational Research (NZCER) for the Association of Boys’ Schools of New Zealand (ABSNZ) is flawed both in the way it has been carried out and in conception.

A key problem is that the research compares boys’ achievements in single sex and co-ed schools within deciles (actually only within groupings of deciles 1-4, 5-6, 7-8 and 9-10) as if this creates a way of comparing apples with apples. It certainly doesn’t.

Deciles are a measure of the socio-economic makeup of schools but there are other differences among schools within deciles. These include other intake differences (such as ethnicity, transience, special needs) and other school characteristics (such as urban rural, size, staffing).

For instance, although there are co-ed schools through the country, single sex schools tend to be restricted to major and provincial centres. There will be a significant difference between the student intake attending a decile 1 school in Mangere, Auckland compared to a decile 1 school in Mangakino or Murupara.

Also many boys’ schools are able to be selective because of their religious ‘special character’. Higher donations and/or the nature of school admissions policies makes them less exposed to the most challenging students. Even some ‘low decile’ schools can be selective and it is always galling (and sometimes truly vomit-inducing) to hear principals or others making capital out of the advantages of a school’s intake.

Actually there are many differences between schools that are likely to create contextual advantages and disadvantages for each of them. Only some of these factors have been considered by NZCER. It makes comparing school performance a case of a little knowledge being a dangerous thing. The researchers should have resisted the temptation to use available data rather than good data.

There is also a problem with the other major theme of the report, which identifies the features of some particularly ‘high-performing’ boys schools. (ERO has been doing the same recently with low socio-economic schools, these then became glorified in the Herald as ‘star’ schools). This ‘exemplary schools’ approach runs into the same contextual problems. And where there are extraordinary things happening in a school, the chances of the same practices continuing long term or transferring to other schools are often remote.

We should also be asking why those on the executive of the ABSNZ (all ‘headmasters’ including a woman headmaster) commissioned the research? The report doesn’t say much about this. But given that it is mostly about comparing the academic performance of boys’ schools and co-ed schools, I’m willing to bet they were hoping to promote the higher achievement levels of single sex boys’ schools.

Today’s secondary schools have become businesses and most of them are competing for students or for particular kinds of students that will enhance their reputations.

The concern that this research evidence could be used by ABSNZ members to market themselves against co-ed schools has been illustrated by comments in Wednesday’s Marlborough Express from Marlborough Boys’ College in Blenheim promoting that school on the back of the report. The same article reports the principal of nearby co-ed Queen Charlotte College doing damage control by suggesting that "Marlborough Boys' does not stack up the same way as the schools in the report”.

Ironically, the Queen Charlotte principal, Tom Parsons, has been a strong advocate for ‘Investing in Educational Success‘, a new policy that is centred on the idea of collaboration and ‘Communities of Schools’. It doesn’t seem like his school will be teaming up with Marlborough Boys’ for the next few weeks anyway.

Actually it’s in those smaller centres where there are single sex and co-ed schools and they are competing for a limited pool of students where this report could be most damaging. Where a co-ed school is already on the back foot (for whatever reason –less wealthy intake, a student suicide, staffing problems), any news articles promoting single sex schools will be particularly resented. Principals know that most parents will never read the actual report. It just gets read in the paper and discussed ‘on the grapevine’.

But isn’t arguing the advantages of single sex schooling also mischievous when it is just not an option for so many families? Fortunately there’s no need to go splitting up all the co-ed schools just yet. But some will want to use the report to lobby for more single sex schools. Wednesday’s Dominion Post reported the principal of boys’ school Rongotai College as commenting "It's worth noting the Ministry has not built a new boys' school since the early 1960s." And the same article talked about co-ed Naenae College having some single-sex classes. I’m sure it’s well intended but some co-ed schools might now want to use this approach to try to capture the high ground.

So why did the generally reputable NZCER get caught up in such a research project in the first place? What comes next, reports promoting catholic schools or private schools? The researchers will no doubt argue that their findings are appropriately qualified in the detail of the report. But they should have foreseen the likely misuse of their report and declined to be involved. Being able to turn down unsuitable research agendas is the cornerstone of research independence.

Ideally any choice of single sex or co-ed schooling would come down solely to what parents think will suit their individual child. For instance I know from discussion with one of my neighbours that they have valued the ‘strictness’ of a boys’ school for their sons. Although every school has its problems – this particular ‘strict’ one was recently embarrassed by some boys shoplifting during a sports trip to Japan. And although I attended one of the ABSNZ schools myself, I wanted to send my son to a co-ed school. Where he has got on just fine and - surprise, surprise – it's a school that likes to be a bit strict about its uniform and the like. My daughter thrived socially and academically at the same co-ed school too.

All in all the promotion of boys’ schools has many dimensions but is hard to escape the social segregation often involved. The Dominion Post’s case study to accompany the release of the report was of a boy going from private Wellesley College to decile 10 Wellington College. Unfortunately the socio-economic makeup of schools tends to trump everything else when it comes to parents choosing schools. Those who are in a position to choose, tend to choose middle class schools over lower socio-economic schools, almost regardless of any other features of the schools. Now that’s the research problem worth focussing on.

*************

Martin Thrupp is Professor of Education at the University of Waikato.

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines

 

Review: “Salute” By Royal New Zealand Ballet In Wellington

The Royal New Zealand Ballet performed “Salute” for a final time in Wellington on Sunday night, and it was nothing short of spectacular. More>>

ALSO:

NZ on Air: More Funding For TV Captions To Increase Access

More funding for TV captions to increase access NZ On Air has increased funding to provide more captions and audio description on television programmes for the hearing and sight impaired. More>>

Music: So Laid Back Country China Album Release

On Friday night, So Laid Back Country China held a gig at Meow for the release of their new album With Knees of Honey in Goodbye Canyon. I briefly spoke with Harriet lead vocals, keyboard) and Michael (lead vocals, guitar) before the gig More>>

Art: Wellington Region Celebrates Matariki

Eight Wellington museums and galleries have joined forces to present a major programme of exhibitions and events to celebrate Matariki 2015, the Māori New Year. The Wellington Matariki Festival will host more than 60 free events and activities between Saturday ... More>>

Wellington: TEDxWellingtonWomen Speakers Unveiled

The lineup is announced today for the highly anticipated upcoming event TEDxWellingtonWomen. Speakers include local women and men who have lived extraordinary lives and have ideas worth spreading. More>>


Books: Witi Ihimaera To Address ‘State Of NZ Literature’at Festival

6 May 2015 MEDIA RELEASE Witi Ihimaera to Address ‘State of NZ Literature’ at Dunedin Writers and Readers Festival The New Zealand Book Council has chosen the 2015 Dunedin Writers and Readers Festival as the stage for its annual address, which ... More>>

Culture: Historic Māori Portraits Travel To The Czech Republic

Image credit: Gottfried Lindauer, Wahanui Reihana Te Huatare, oil on canvas, Auckland Art Gallery Toi o Tāmaki, gift of Mr H E Partridge, 1915 More>>

Art: Something Felt, Something Shared - Enjoy

Gabrielle Amodeo, Ruby Joy Eade, Clare McLean, Kalya Ward Curated by Emma Ng May 7 – 30, 2015 Opening: Wednesday May 6, 5.30pm Strange frequencies are channelled through personal narratives and poetic placeholders in Something felt, something ... More>>

Culture: Pukeahu Park ANZAC Day Commemoration 2015

Pukeahu Park ANZAC Day Commemoration 2015 Images from New Zealand Defence Force Click for big version A bugler plays The Last Post Click for big version A View from the top of the Carillion Click for big version Faces old and young Click for big ... More>>

Television: MediaWorks Announces Dancing With The Stars Hosts

MediaWorks and BBC Worldwide ANZ are delighted to announce host Dominic Bowden alongside co-host Sharyn Casey for the hit series Dancing with the Stars. More>>

Get More From Scoop

 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

 
 
 
 
Education
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news