Education Policy | Post Primary | Preschool | Primary | Tertiary | Search


Morag Hutchinson, Green Bay High School v A

5 June 2015


Morag Hutchinson and the Board of Trustees of Green Bay High School v A

(CA 143/2014)


This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at Judicial Decisions of Public Interest:

The Court of Appeal has today dismissed an appeal relating to a child (A) with special needs who was a student at Green Bay High School. He was suspended and excluded from the School by the Principal and the Board of Trustees. In the High Court, A applied for judicial review against his suspension and exclusion from the School. Justice Faire quashed those decisions because he considered the School had insufficient information before making the decisions. A was then able to return to the School.

The Principal and the Board of Trustees sought to appeal that decision. The appeal was to be heard on 7 July 2015 and was to consider arguments as to whether the School went through the correct process for suspending and excluding A. An additional issue about whether the School had discriminated against A because of his disabilities was to be raised for the first time on appeal. This issue had not been considered by the High Court. The Attorney-General on behalf of the Ministry of Education, the Human Rights Commission and IHC New Zealand were given permission to intervene to make submissions and assist the Court on that question.

The Court of Appeal (Justice Randerson, Justice Stevens and Justice White) has dismissed the appeal the Principal and Board of Trustees intended to bring. A has since left the School and is being educated outside the mainstream school system. This meant there was no longer a live issue between the School and A for the Court to resolve.

The Court acknowledged the appeal raised issues of public importance concerning alleged discrimination against students with disabilities. However this did not mean the Court should hear the appeal for two main reasons. First, the question of discrimination was not addressed by the High Court and it would be unusual for the Court of Appeal to consider such matters for the first time on appeal, particularly where there had been no factual findings made in the High Court on this issue. Second, the Human Rights Review Tribunal is a specialist body which considers human rights issues such as discrimination. It is presently considering the treatment of students with disabilities in proceedings brought by IHC New Zealand against the Ministry of Education. The Court considered that the Tribunal was an appropriate body to resolve these issues.

Full judgment: CA1432014.pdf

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Mayor's Statement: Death Of Actor Ray Henwood

“Ray was an absolute stalwart of the Wellington drama scene. His contribution to what we have today cannot be understated,” the Mayor says. “His first love was stage work and we are thankful he graced the stage in Wellington. He loved the city and we also loved him." More>>

Sport: Hay Named As All Whites Head Coach

Former All Whites captain Danny Hay, who played for the national team for 11 years, playing in 31 A internationals, was announced as the 18th Head Coach of the national team today in Auckland. More>>

Howard Davis Review: Tarantino's Pitch-Perfect Once Upon a Time … in Hollywood

Welcome back to the violent and misogynistic, yet always entertaining world of Quentin Tarantino, who this time around focuses his dyspeptic lens on Tinseltown's pimply backside. More>>

Westpac Exiting Cake Tin: Stadium Announces Naming Rights Agreement With Sky

Wellington Regional Stadium Trust (WRST) and Sky Network Television Ltd (Sky) have announced a new partnership that will see Sky secure the naming rights of the Stadium from 1 January 2020. More>>




  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland