News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


ALRANZ Reply To NZ Catholic Article

The Abortion Law Reform Association responded to an article within the New Zealand Catholic (13.2.2000) which set out SPUC's provisional objectives for the forthcoming abortion law review.

ALRANZ slated SPUC for their reliance on the discredited Royal Commission on Contraception, Sterilisation and Abortion from the mid-seventies. It argued that the Royal Commission relied on secondary media resources, did not cite medical, social scientific and psyhological data that challenged the anti-abortion movement, and did not subject anti-abortion sources to critical scrutiny. It questioned why Parliament should accept a restrictive interpretation of abortion law now when it had removed an exceptional circumstances clause from the Crimes Act in 1978, and had not challenged Wall v Livingston, which protects women's medical confidentiality in the context of abortion decisions, for over seventeen years.

It also questioned SPUC's reliance on "post-abortion syndrome."ALRANZ pointed out that anti-abortionist "research" consisted of small samples, short duration cohorts and unrepresentative populations. It questioned the degree of generalisability and independent corroboration of this alleged condition, which no mainstream New Zealand medical practitioner recognises.

SPUC is correct about one thing, however. We will continue to closely monitor their organisation and media in preparation for law reform.

Craig Young Research Officer ALRANZ 2/353 College St Palmerston North wk- 06 3569099 ext 7750

Dr Margaret Sparrow National President ALRANZ Box 28008, Wellington

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Beating Aussies 52-51: Silver Ferns Win Netball World Cup

It's the first time New Zealand has lifted the World Championship trophy in 16 years and marks an impressive turnaround for the Ferns after last year's fourth place finish at the Commonwealth Games. More>>


DOC Alert: Penguins Ignore Police, Return To Sushi Shop

Department of Conservation rangers are on high alert for 'penguin call-outs' after they've been spotted waddling around Wellington. Yesterday the little blue penguins had to be removed from under a sushi store near the Wellington railway station, not once - but twice. More>>

Baldwin St's Steep Decline: Welsh Town Beats Dunedin For Steepest Street

Harlech, a sleepy town set in the hills of North Wales, boasts a beautiful seaside, a 13th century castle and stunning panoramic views. But the town can now add something else to the list - Harlech is officially the home of the world’s steepest street. More>>


Sport: England Wins Cricket World Cup After Super Over

New Zealand have cruelly lost the Cricket World Cup final after a Super Over - a decider more usually associated with the shorter Twenty20 format of the game. More>>




  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland