News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Health reforms get positive report card

Health reforms get positive report card

The Government's health reforms have received a tentative "thumbs up" in the first report from a major research project analysing the implementation of the new system over three years.

The report, by a consortium of researchers led by Victoria University's Health Services Research Centre, covers the first half of a three-year research period.

Principal Investigator Jackie Cumming said that overall, there was support for the new model but the research has already highlighted key issues that need to be addressed.

"We have received reports of a number of strengths from the model, including the ability to look locally at the needs of the population and the ability to involve the community in decision-making and to be more responsive to local needs and to better plan for them.

"Our interviews with chief executives have found that they see more strengths than weaknesses with the new system and they believe those weaknesses can be managed and will be overcome with time. Even in this early part of the research, we have reports of relationships and processes improving with time.

"Our research has not uncovered a call or need for further major change although this may in part be related to 'change fatigue' and a desire to let the new structure settle in and evolve gradually rather than face further disruption."

The research has highlighted a number of issues relating to how the model is working in practice. For example, many respondents believed there were too many district health boards and that was leading to higher costs and duplication of effort.

"Some DHBs expect amalgamations, although no DHBs are yet 'putting up their hands up' to amalgamate. Concerns were also expressed about the cost of supporting the three statutory committees that each Board is required to have. Some in the sector are also worried that primary health organisations (PHOs) might also add an extra layer of bureaucracy and further increase 'management' costs."

Ms Cumming said the research also highlighted a need to develop strategies to ensure adequate, appropriate and effective Mâori representation on DHBs.

"While the law requires two Mâori to be appointed to each board, there was concern that few Mâori were elected. Although the appointment of Mâori members was seen as a welcome step, increased participation at a local level may still not translate into improved health outcomes for Mâori where a DHB does not actively promote Mâori health and because many of the factors that contribute to poor health lie outside the control of the sector. Pacific peoples also have few representatives, with no elected board members".

Ms Cumming said the respective roles of the Ministry of Health and the DHBs also needed clarification.

"We found a degree of concern from boards about a lack of autonomy for boards and a sense that the Ministry was too involved in their work. There was also a strong perception of reluctance by the Ministry to devolve funding and decision-making and that its performance monitoring was seen as intrusive and demanding."

The research, over three years, is funded by the Health Research Council; and by the Ministry of Health, The Treasury, and the State Services Commission, through a Ministry of Research, Science and Technology Departmental Contestable Research Pool, and examines the reforms through interviews with key individuals in the Government, Ministry, district health boards, national stakeholders and the wider public while five case study DHBs are studied in greater depth.

Interim Report: Now available: (look under publications and then new reports)

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


City Of 100 Lovers: Multi-Million Dollar NZ Theatre Production To Launch

Produced in New Zealand, the $8Million budget, musical comedy, City of 100 Lovers, has been created for locals and tourists alike. More>>

Indycars: Dixon Wins Fifth US Championship

The New Zealand motor racing driver Scott Dixon has won the US Indycar championship for the fifth time. Dixon finished second in the final race of the season in Sonoma in California. More>>


Howard Davis Review: The Outsider Art of Tony Fomison

Among such gifted contemporaries as Bill Hammond, Tony de la Tour, and printmaker Jason Grieg, Fomison distinguished himself as highly idiosyncratic, and could have become wealthy, had not his demons prevented him from investing his income wisely. In his near monochrome oil painting on black hessian, he staked out a territory of morbid originality. More>>

Scoop Review Of Books: Immortal Love

The series has a wild-west tone with a steampunk vibe, so if you’re a fan of Joss Whedon’s Firefly or Joe Abercrombie’s Shattered Sea, then chances are you’ll enjoy this book. More>>

Howard Davis Review: The Trappings of Success - McQueen

This troubling documentary about the extraordinary life and untimely death of British fashion designer Alexander McQueen (1969 - 2010) is a cautionary tale of an extremely gifted, but self-destructive soul caught up in a business that chews up and spits out its creative talent. More>>

Anne Russell: On Nanette, And The Limitations Of Stories

Since many detractors fault Gadsby or other women for talking about their trauma publicly, Gadsby’s most ardent fans mistakenly perceive virtually any criticism of Nanette as misogynist. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland