News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Care Providers Win Judicial Review against DHBs

8 December 2007

Aged Care Providers Win Judicial Review against DHBs

The High Court in Wellington has agreed with providers of quality aged care
in New Zealand that District Health Boards are acting unlawfully by
inserting collective agreement clauses into service agreements.

Justice McGechan yesterday ruled in favour of aged care providers who took
judicial review proceedings against DHBs for inserting collective agreement
and passing-on clauses in service agreements.

The chief executive of HealthCare Providers NZ, Martin Taylor, said today
that DHBs had been working secretly with unions to orchestrate a rise in the
number of collective agreements. The judgment declared that DHBs acted
unlawfully in deciding to include clauses A4 and A5 in aged care providers'
service contracts.

"A major part of this case was about how and when a Minister can direct
government agencies to do things they don't agree with. The High Court
agrees with HealthCare Providers that the Minister overstepped his
boundaries and acted improperly", Mr Taylor said.

This case was not about whether care providers were passing on funding
targeted for caregivers and cleaners, as unions claimed during the hearings.

The case was about playing fair and meeting consultation obligations. The
court believed DHBs did neither of these two things, he said.

The full judgment can be found at under
'important papers'


© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Howard Davis Review: Reclaiming The N-Word - Spike Lee's BlacKkKlansman

Black resistance to institutional racism in the US has a long, tangled, and traumatic intellectual history. Although we may have assumed much too easily that white supremacists like David Duke had become marginalised as a political force, in reality they never really disappeared ... More>>

Howard Davis Review: The Minstrel in The Gallery - Sam Hunt's Selected Poems

Perhaps the most striking aspect of Sam Hunt's poetry is its quality of urgent authenticity. Encountering this latest compilation, the reader is immediately struck by its easy accessibility, tonal sincerity, and lack of linguistic pretension ... More>>

A Matter Of Fact: Truth In A Post-Truth World

How do we convincingly explain the difference between good information and misinformation? And conversely, how do we challenge our own pre-conceived notions of what we believe to be true? More>>


Scoop Review Of Books: The Road To Unfreedom

Valerie Morse: Yale professor of history Tim Snyder publishes a stunning account of the mechanisms of contemporary Russian power in US and European politics. In telling this story he presents both startling alarms for our own society and some mechanisms of resistance. More>>


Doing Our Bit: An Insider's Account Of New Zealand Political Campaigning

In 2013, Murdoch Stephens began a campaign to double New Zealand’s refugee quota. Over the next five years he built the campaign into a mainstream national movement – one that contributed to the first growth in New Zealand’s refugee quota in thirty years. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland