News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search

 

Health Ministry figures again show fluoridation pointless

Health Ministry figures again show fluoridation pointless

The 2009 school dental statistics have been released by the Ministry of Health. “As in 2008, these show no real benefit from fluoridation, but that socioeconomic (SE) status (decile) is the main factor in tooth decay says Mark Atkin, spokesperson for health activist organisation Fluoride Action Network NZ. Yet remarkably, low decile Counties Manukau shows less decay in the un fluoridated children. “So much for fluoridation helping the poor!” adds Mr Atkin. Once again the Ministry claims total figures, unadjusted for SE status, as showing around 30% benefit for 11-12 years olds. But splitting these between higher and lower SE areas shows no statistically significant difference in DMFT (tooth decay, mainly number of fillings) or percent of children without any decay for the high decile areas. Even in the low decile areas, the claimed benefit (1/5 th of a filling, and 3% extra caries-free children) is within fluctuations since 2000.

“The figures also do not allow for the one year delay in tooth eruption, and therefore decay rates, caused by fluoridation” says Mr Atkin. “They just compare children of the same age, which gives a false impression of reduced, rather than slightly delayed, decay. If we adjusted for this, the fluoridated areas would likely show more decay than the unfluoridated areas.” The only properly conducted study examining the effects of this delay (Komarek, 2005), formerly shown by a 14 year study published in 1961, confirmed the delay, and found no difference in decay rates once comparing teeth at the same time after eruption, rather than the age of the children.

Only 25 out of 69 NZ local authorities add fluoride to their water supplies, in the form of hazardous waste according to the substances’ Safety Data Sheets [1]. Very few countries fluoridate their water.

[1] http://www.fannz.org.nz/pdfs/Prayon%20Manufacturers%20Safety%20Data%20Sheet.pdf;
http://www.fannz.org.nz/pdfs/ORICA%20-%20hydrofluorosilic%20acid.pdf

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines

 
Wellington Rugby Zeroes: Sevens To Move To Hamilton

Wellington Mayor Justin Lester: “The Sevens has been a big part of recent Wellington history but it was time for the event to move on… Wellingtonians have been voting with their feet in the last few years and we’ve seen the result in dwindling crowd numbers and lower ticket sales.” More>>

ALSO:

Matafeo & Dravid: The Billy T And Fred Award Winners For 2017

At the final show of the 2017 NZ International Comedy Festival powered by Flick Electric Co. the Festival came to a close after 115 shows in Auckland and 68 shows in Wellington. More>>

Scoop Review Of Books: What’s Fair? Tax and Fairness

This is an excellent and timely book, since apart from general statements about increasing or mostly reducing tax, there has been very little comment or debate as to whether we should pay tax at all and how much tax should each of us pay. More>>

Ockham Awards: Globally Lauded Novelist Wins NZ’s Biggest Fiction Prize

Internationally renowned Ngāruawāhia resident Catherine Chidgey has won New Zealand’s richest writing award, the $50,000 Acorn Foundation Fiction Prize, for her novel The Wish Child. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • CULTURE
  • HEALTH
  • EDUCATION
 
 
  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland