News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search

 


Driving and Memory loss

Liam Butler interviews Dr John Carmody and Dr Petra Hoggarth about driving and Memory loss.

26 March 2014

Liam Butler

Dr John Carmody is a Senior Staff Specialist Neurologist at Wollongong Hospital, NSW, Australia. He is Head of the Neurology Department, Clinical Theme Leader for Neuroscience and Mental Health at the Illawarra Health and Medical Research Institute, and is a member of the local Human Research Ethics Committee. In terms of clinical research, Dr Carmody is nearing completion of his PhD studies at the University of Wollongong. This work involves the development and testing of a new decision aid booklet which has been designed specifically for drivers with dementia. It is hoped that this booklet will assist people with dementia plan for retirement from driving in Australia and New Zealand. It is anticipated that the booklet will be made available free-of-charge from mid-2014.

John why did you decide to research Driving and Memory Loss?

I found it hard to know what to say to my patients and harder still to know what to say to carers when addressing the issue of memory loss in the hospital setting. The existing guides were not user-friendly.

John many people who have memory loss have no formal diagnosis, how can they stay safe on the roads?

A greater awareness of memory loss and dementia in our community would go a long way in addressing this issue. An important starting point is arranging an appointment to see your GP.

John what is the best way for families or care givers to address a person's driving if they think it is risky?

There are a variety of measures which could be considered. I would favour contacting their GP, local dementia carer group, Alzheimers Australia 1800 100 500 or Alzheimers NZ 0800 004 001 for advice. At times, families are afraid to raise the issue with the driver. It may be best to let the doctor be the ‘bad guy/girl'.

John, what level of memory loss is it ok to drive? And how does someone know if they are safe to drive?

Some people with early/mild dementia are safe to drive. As dementia is gradually progressive, it is very difficult to accurately determine when someone has become unsafe to drive. Early discussion and planning are important strategies. Retirement from driving is easier when planned rather than forced. Review by a GP or specialist every 6 months is wise.

Dr Petra Hoggarth, what is your experience in this field?

I'm a clinical psychologist and did a PhD investigating factors that predict driving ability in healthy older adults and adults with mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer's dementia. I currently work at Psychiatric Service for the Elderly at the Canterbury DHB. I work in a day hospital and the geriatric psychiatric inpatient ward where I do therapy for mental disorder. I have an interest in the diagnosis of dementia and do the odd neuropsychological assessment when a complicated case arises (such as a younger-age person, or when a rarer form of dementia is suspected). I've written two published articles specifically for NZ GPs about how to detect unsafe driving in their older patients with a focus on the detection of cognitive impairment:

http://nzbri.org/research/publications/papers/0722.pdf 2013 paper in the NZ Medical Journal

http://nzbri.org/research/publications/papers/0549.pdf 2011 paper in the Australasian Journal on Ageing

It can be a challenge for a General Practitioner to act to stop a person driving. Yet, it is their responsibility. What advice do you have for them?

In regards to the effect of cognitive impairment on driving, once the necessary steps of diagnosis are completed New Zealand GPs have the option of referring for a specialist on-road driving assessment (which for most of NZ is paid for privately by the patient). If the patient fails this the assessor will generally have the hard task of breaking the news. If the decision is made without a specialist assessment then breaking the news can be a hard task. My advice is to remember that driving is a privilege, not a right, and that failing to discuss the issue leaves the patient at a much higher risk of a crash and resultant injury or death than in a non-cognitively impaired older driver. Then there are passengers and other road users to think of also. GPs only need to advise the NZ Transport Agency of the decision if they are concerned that the patient will continue driving against advice. My second piece of advice is to start talking about driving cessation as soon as a dementia diagnosis is given. All drivers with dementia will need to stop driving at some point, and so being clear about this at the beginning and encouraging the patient to think of alternative methods of transportation when that time comes is important. It would be best to involve family in this discussion also.

Dr John Carmody

The responsibility for issuing and revoking driver licences in Australia lies with the local Driver Licensing Authority (DLA). In the Northern Territory and South Australia, health practitioners are obliged to report all unsafe drivers to their DLA. However, in other states and territories, there is no such obligation. A valuable resource for Australian GPs (and all health professionals) is the Austroads Fitness to Drive Guidelines 2012.

When should I stop Driving ?

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines

 
Scoop Review Of Books: Q&A: Prue Hyman On ‘Hopes Dashed?’

For Scoop Review of Books, Alison McCulloch interviewed Prue Hyman about her new book, part of the BWB Texts series, Hopes Dashed? The Economics of Gender Inequality More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Chuck Berry (And James Comey, And Bill English)

Back when many people were still treating rock’n’roll as a passing fad – was calypso going to be the new thing? – Chuck Berry knew that it had changed popular music forever. What is even more astonishing is that this 30-ish black r&b musician from a middle class family in St Louis could manage to recreate the world of white teenagers, at a time when the very notion of a “teenager” had just been invented. More>>

Howard Davis Review:
The Baroque Fusion Of L'arpeggiata

Named after a toccata by German composer Girolamo Kapsberger, L'Arpeggiata produces its unmistakable sonority mainly from the resonance of plucked strings, creating a tightly-woven acoustic texture that is both idiosyncratic and immediately identifiable. Director Christina Pluhar engenders this distinctive tonality associated with the ensemble she founded in 2000 by inviting musicians and vocalists from around the world to collaborate on specific projects illuminated by her musicological research. More>>

African Masks And Sculpture: Attic Discovery On Display At Expressions Whirinaki

Ranging from masks studded with nails and shards of glass to statues laden with magical metal, the works are from ethnic groups in nine countries ranging from Ivory Coast to the Democratic Republic of the Congo. More>>

Obituary: Andrew Little Remembers Murray Ball

“Murray mined a rich vein of New Zealand popular culture and exported it to the world. Wal and Dog and all the other Kiwi characters he crafted through Footrot Flats were hugely popular here and in Australia, Europe and North America." More>>

ALSO:

Organised Choas: NZ Fringe Festival 2017 Awards

Three more weeks of organised chaos have come to an end with the Wellington NZ Fringe Arts Festival Awards Ceremony as a chance to celebrate all our Fringe artists for their talent, ingenuity, and chutzpah! More>>

ALSO:

Wellington.Scoop: Wellington Writer Wins $US165,000 Literature Prize

Victoria University of Wellington staff member and alumna Ashleigh Young has won a prestigious Windham-Campbell Literature Prize worth USD$165,000 for her book of essays Can You Tolerate This? More>>

ALSO:

Scoop Review Of Books: We’re All Lab Rats

A couple of years ago, there were reports that Silicon Valley executives were sending their children to tech-free schools. It was a story that dripped of irony: geeks in the heart of techno-utopia rejecting their ideology when it came to their own kids. But the story didn’t catch on, and an awkward question lingered. Why were the engineers of the future desperate to part their gadgets from their children? More>>

  • CensusAtSchool - Most kids have no screen-time limits
  • Netsafe - Half of NZ high school students unsupervised online
  • Get More From Scoop

     
     

    LATEST HEADLINES

     
     
     
     
    Health
    Search Scoop  
     
     
    Powered by Vodafone
    NZ independent news