News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search

 

E-cigarettes not safe, and potential public health disaster

E-cigarettes not safe, and a potential public health disaster if not effectively regulated – says Asthma and Respiratory Foundation NZ
In response to the article ‘Vaping better than smoking, Ministry of Health tells MPs’ published on Newshub on 13 December 2017 stating “It is much safer than smoking, and there is emerging evidence it helps people quit, the Ministry of Health said during a briefing at Parliament on Wednesday.”

Letitia O’Dwyer, Chief Executive of the Asthma and Respiratory Foundation NZ (ARFNZ) says, “The efficacy of e-cigarettes as a cessation tool, along with the known risks of these products is too important to not drill down on the evidence, and we believe the statements issued by the Ministry of Health (MOH) do not stipulate what scientific backing or research is behind them. As far as we’re aware, there is no good evidence demonstrating that using e-cigarettes will reduce the incidence of smoking cigarettes. We fear that the Ministry of Health are providing advice based on one side of the story when it comes to e-cigarette use. Whilst they may be safer than smoking cigarettes, that is not a very hard hurdle to jump. We do however know that there is a growing body of evidence demonstrating that these products do damage in the respiratory tract. We urge the MOH to tread very carefully in considering the appropriate regulatory framework for these products.”

Dr Stuart Jones, Medical Director of ARFNZ says, “The rationale for introducing e-cigarettes is to assist smokers who can’t quit via existing means to do so. However, as a policy response, there needs to be strict regulation of these products to avoid a potential public health disaster in the future. There is no evidence that current smokers in New Zealand are finding it harder to quit than in previous years, so we need to make sure that existing smokers are provided with access to quitting support with a proven track record of effectiveness and safety." (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27382047)

Dr Jones says, “We do recognise that for a small number of current smokers, who have tried all other quitting options the use of e-cigarettes may be beneficial, but we need to make sure that we’re targeting that group. The current situation in which e-cigarettes can be marketed including Thomas the Tank shaped vaporisers and fruit loop flavoured liquids is clearly not designed as a marketing strategy for cessation but rather to attract a younger generation of New Zealanders. There is no good reason for children, or indeed non-smokers to use these products as they will cause damage in the lungs. Marketing e-cigarettes as a ‘safer’ alternative to smoking may be interpreted by the general public that they are indeed ‘safe’ and reduce the perceived level of risk taking associated with their use. This is reflected in overseas studies showing an increase in the use of e-cigarettes among adolescents over time.”

If these products are to be made available then we need to weigh up the risks of wide spread access to encourage the small numbers of smokers who can’t quit using existing means against the real harms associated with uptake of these products by children and non-smokers. We also need to consider, that there is significant evidence of smokers using both e-cigarettes and conventional cigarettes and we strongly advise against this dual use.

“We recommend restricting the sale of e-cigarettes to only those people who are smoking and want to use e-cigarettes to give up or reduce harm – this is the only group in our population in which a reduction in harm will occur through the use of e-cigarettes. We also recommend that they are part of a proper smoking cessation programme by the Ministry of Health – a wraparound service involving health professionals at a primary and community care level," says Dr Jones who is also the local branch President of the Thoracic Society.

Being part of a wraparound smoking cessation plan is important, especially if that is in fact the rationale behind their role according to the Ministry of Health, as mentioned in the Newshub article, “vaping could be a tool” in helping to reduce smoking in Māori and Pacific people.

The Newshub article also states, “One of the challenges in developing the law will be allowing vaping products enough visibility to encourage smokers to select them over cigarettes without encouraging young people to take it up.”

We don't want to entice our youth, so to protect them from taking up e-cigarettes or vaping, O’Dywer says “E-cigarettes and vaping products should have the same restricted sale and accessibility placed on them as conventional cigarettes e.g. prohibit sale and supply in public places, not sold to under 18 year olds and no point of sale advertising of e-cigarettes and e-liquids.” This stance is in keeping with the Federation of International Respiratory Societies position paper on e-cigarettes.

O'Dwyer says that several studies are also emerging indicating that e-cigarettes can be a gateway to smoking. A recently published study, ‘Trajectories of E-Cigarette and Conventional Cigarette Use Among Youth’ in the January 2018 edition of Pediatrics (Official Journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics) concludes the following:

E-cigarette use was associated with future cigarette use across 3 longitudinal waves, yet cigarette use was not associated with future e-cigarette use. E-cigarette regulation and prevention programs may help prevent future use of cigarettes among youth.
------------------------------------------------------
Claims about the safety of these products need to be understood in the context of the comparison. Cigarettes are incredibly dangerous so it is not difficult to be safer than cigarettes. The issue is that we do not have enough data about the damage these products cause over long term. Just as the damage from cigarette smoking takes years to manifest, the damage done by e-cigarettes is also likely to be cumulative and take time to develop.

Dr Jones explains, “There is a huge concern around the flavours used in the inhaled products that have had no testing that they are actually safe to inhale. This includes additives of which currently more than 7000 of them are food products. The stomach is very different to the lungs. There are a raft of studies demonstrating many of them are toxic to lung cells especially chocolate and berry. There are also currently no consumer safety requirements for these products.”

The ARFNZ also raises concern that there is significant conflict of interest on the Ministry of Health Electronic Cigarette Technical Expert Advisory Group with three industry representatives (including a buyer for Cosmic retail stores) giving advice on Electronic Cigarette Product Safety.

O'Dwyer says, “It’s greatly concerning that the Ministry of Health does not have a balanced and evidence based Expert Advisory Group. In contrast, many of the people in the group will benefit from the sales of e-cigarettes and vaping products, it doesn’t make sense that these same people are advising us on the safety of these products!”


ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines

 

Howard Davis Review: From Free Press to Fancy Dress - Spielberg's The Post

Stephen Spielberg's The Post is an opportune newsroom drama in which a corrupt Republican president wages war against the "liberal media," as its plucky proprietor risks economic and legal ruin to bring the Pentagon Papers to public light. Its true protagonist is publisher Katharine Graham, a stringently diplomatic businesswoman, reluctantly compelled to take an overtly political stance in the interests of democracy and freedom of the press. More>>



Howard Davis Review: The Black Dog of Empire - Joe Wright's Darkest Hour'

On the eve of England's contorted efforts to negotiate its ignominious retreat from Europe and the chaotic spectacle of the Tory party ratifying its undignified departure from a union originally designed to prevent another World War, there has been a renewed appetite for movies about 1940. More>>



Howard Davis Review: Anger Begets Anger - Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri

For fans of what Ricky Gervais termed "number movies" (Seven Samurai, The Magnificent Seven, Ocean's 11, Se7en), Martin McDonagh's latest offering will be a welcome addition to the roster. The Irish playwright turned screenwriter and director has produced another quirky and darkly comic tragedy that evolves around the futility of anger and grief, retribution and revenge. More>>

Howard Davis: Sexting in George Dawe's Genevieve - Part I

Te Papa's permanent collection includes an enormous oil painting by the English artist George Dawe called Genevieve (from by a poem by S.T. Coleridge entitled 'Love') that was prominently featured in the 2013 exhibition Angels & Aristocrats. Compare the massive immensity of the bard's gorgeously gilded harp with the stubby metallic handle of the Dark Knight's falchion, both suggestively positioned at crotch-level. Dawe's enormous canvas invokes a whole history of blushing that pivots around a direct connection to sexual arousal. More>>

ALSO:

Ethnomusicology: Malian ‘Desert Blues’ Revolutionaries To Storm WOMAD

Malian band Tinariwen (playing WOMAD NZ in March 2018) are a true musical revolutionaries in every sense. Active since 1982, these nomadic Tuareg or ‘Kel Tamashek’ (speakers of Tamashek) electric guitar legends revolutionised a traditional style to give birth to a new genre often called ‘desert blues’. They also have a history rooted deeply in revolution and fighting for the rights of their nomadic Tamashek speaking culture and people. More>>

Gordon Campbell: Best New Music Of 2017

Any ‘best of list’ has to be an exercise in wishful thinking, given the splintering of everyone’s listening habits... But maybe… it could be time for the re-discovery of the lost art of listening to an entire album, all the way through. Just putting that idea out there. More>>

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • CULTURE
  • HEALTH
  • EDUCATION
 
 
  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland