News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Australian Mesh Recommendations Mostly Welcomed

Australian Mesh Recommendations Mostly Welcomed by NZ Doctors

Yesterday’s findings from the 7-month-long Australian Senate Committee Inquiry into transvaginal mesh have been met with widespread support from New Zealand UroGynaecologists …despite concern over one recommendation which would, if adopted here, significantly limit a highly successful surgical option for urinary incontinence.

Senior New Zealand members of the UroGynaecological Society of Australasia(UGSA) say they acknowledge and fully accept many recommendations from the extensive Inquiry report, including the assurance that all women are fully informed and have a good understanding of any potential side-effects from surgical mesh prior to their procedure; that a Centre of Excellence be established in Australia to monitor transvaginal mesh use and complications; and for the introduction of central data collection and on-going audit of all mesh use for women.
However, one recommendation, that the implantation of all transvaginal mesh products should only be undertaken as a last resort, is being met with caution and concern by doctors treating women for urinary incontinence.

While supportive of last year’s Australian TGA decision to remove transvaginal mesh use for women with prolapse due to uncertainty over the risk/benefit balance, many New Zealand urogynaecologists say limiting use of the safest and most effective surgical treatment for urinary incontinence, the mid-urethral sling, would be a backward step for the 1 in 3 New Zealand women who suffer from incontinence, forcing doctors to revert to more traditional, riskier surgical methods.

“It’s very clear and highly regrettable that some women have been harmed by mesh surgery and this is obviously an area where we must focus our efforts in the future” says Christchurch’s Dr John Short, Vice-Chair of the UGSA. “Any surgery has the potential to cause complications and of course non-surgical treatments such as physiotherapy should be considered as first line treatment. However, data clearly shows that the bulk of mesh complications have occurred for vaginal prolapse. The rate of complications with mid urethral sling mesh for incontinence is much, much lower and limiting its use would be a disservice to patients”.

The minimally invasive MUS has been used in Australia and New Zealand since 1998. It’s been extensively studied for almost 2 decades in over 2000 scientific publications and is recommended by the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology as highly effective, with fewer adverse outcomes than other available continence surgeries.

A Middlemore Hospital study following 540 women operated on using MUS trans-vaginal tape between 2010-2016 showed less than 4% suffered post-operative complications. In total, seven women (1.8%) experienced difficulty passing urine while ten (1.85%) experienced sling exposure.

“Both of these complications were readily fixed with minor follow-up procedures” says Middlemore Hospital Urogynaecologist Dr Lynsey Hayward. “

Limiting the use of mid urethral slings would force doctors to rely on more traditional types of surgical repair; using either a patient’s own tissue (known as a fascial repair) or a procedure called a Burch Colposuspension, where permanent stitches were used to lift up the neck of the bladder. However, both are surgically complex, involving a lengthy hospital stay and post-operative recovery, with a greater risk of bleeding, wound infection, difficulty in passing urine and subsequent prolapse.

“Reverting to older, more traditional means of repair would be a backward step, exposing women to risks such as bleeding, thrombosis and infection” says Dr Hayward. “It would turn what’s currently a simple day-stay procedure into a multi-day hospital stay, with six weeks off work to recover. I would probably be unable to treat around one third of the women I treat now, due to factors such as obesity, diabetes, other medical conditions and age, as these women are less able to tolerate lengthy abdominal surgery”.

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Joseph Cederwall Review: NZSO Plays Zappa

The first of the NZSO’s Shed Series concerts at the more informal and intimate space of Wellington's Shed 6 last Friday night featured music composed by, or with a connection to Frank Zappa. Zappa, a psychedelic rock legend, activist and popular culture figure and all round colourful character, was an excellent choice for the concert’s theme of innovation. More>>

Let The Games Begin: PM Sends Best Wishes To Athletes

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has sent her warm wishes to the New Zealand athletes preparing for the opening of the Commonwealth Games on Australia’s Gold Coast... More>>


Scoop Review of Books: Martin Edmonds' The Expatriates

This book is an extension of, and tribute to, the life’s work of James McNeish. Without sacrificing any degree of authorial independence, the result is gracefully written, handsomely produced, and likely to propagate many further works of its kind. More>>

Max Rashbrooke Review: The King's Singers and Voices New Zealand

To be good at one thing is impressive; to be so versatile across a range of genres is truly exceptional. More>>

Joe Cederwall Review: WOMAD 2018 - Harmony of Difference (part 1)

A friend described WOMAD as his “favourite white middle class celebration of diversity.” There is certainly an echo of truth to this as the crowd is still largely white and middle class, but this WOMAD for me represented that a better world is possible ... More>>

Harmony of Difference (part 2)

Top international world music artists seldom make it down to this neck of the woods, so for those of us into this sort of thing WOMAD is certainly a welcome addition to the cultural calendar. Now it is a case of waiting and looking forward to seeing what they manage to conjure up for next year. More>>

Howard Davis Review: A Bigger Splash - Te Papa Celebrates Twenty Years

Considering the available resources, this is a decidedly hit-and-miss affair, mainly due to some highly questionable curatorial decisions. In their overweening wish to "push boundaries," Charlotte Davy and Megan Tamati-Quennell have made a number of serious miscalculations by ignoring a basic rule - keep it simple. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland