News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Private health care inferior and expensive

Private health care inferior and expensive

Private health systems are more expensive and less efficient, and have poorer patient outcomes, says Professor Martin McKee, keynote speaker at the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists 30th anniversary conference.

Professor McKee, of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, is one of the world’s leading researchers on the operation of health care systems in times of economic austerity.

The theme of today’s conference is: Why a public health service is worth fighting for.

The United Kingdom and New Zealand had a shared experience of privatising public services, and it had not gone well.

“You would think that, given our shared experience of failed market reforms, we would have learned something. But in both our countries there are still voices calling for more privatisation in the belief that, if we try often enough, we will eventually get it right,” Professor McKee says.

He likens the continuing advocacy for privatisation to the belief that if communism was implemented properly it would be a success.

While most people think of the United States as having a private health system, the Government pays about half of the total health bill through the Medicare and Medicaid programmes. Professor McKee says this allows the private system to focus on younger, healthier, and more profitable patients.

It’s argued the private system can assist the public system by purchasing private care for public patients, but Professor McKee says that ignores one of the big constraints in health care systems, the availability of trained staff. Deals with the private sector can also expose taxpayers to litigation.

Evidence showed that health outcomes were worse in for-profit hospitals compared with not-for-profit and public hospitals.


© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


DOC Alert: Penguins Ignore Police, Return To Sushi Shop

Department of Conservation rangers are on high alert for 'penguin call-outs' after they've been spotted waddling around Wellington. Yesterday the little blue penguins had to be removed from under a sushi store near the Wellington railway station, not once - but twice. More>>

Baldwin St's Steep Decline: Welsh Town Beats Dunedin For Steepest Street

Harlech, a sleepy town set in the hills of North Wales, boasts a beautiful seaside, a 13th century castle and stunning panoramic views. But the town can now add something else to the list - Harlech is officially the home of the world’s steepest street. More>>


Sport: England Wins Cricket World Cup After Super Over

New Zealand have cruelly lost the Cricket World Cup final after a Super Over - a decider more usually associated with the shorter Twenty20 format of the game. More>>


'High-Level Talks': Lord Of The Rings TV Series To Film In NZ

Amazon needed reassurance after the Christchurch terrorist attacks that New Zealand was still a safe place to film the world's most expensive television series. More>>




  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland