News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Why Do We Need A Republic At All?

Our representative democracy is not working as it should and as sure as night follows day New Zealand will follow Australia and we'll be debating whether to become a republic.

But why do we need a republic at all?

Put simply, people are peeved with a system which does not appear to be working for them.

Our modern-day politicians continually tell us that Parliament is sovereign; that it can do no wrong; that its decisions cannot be challenged. That once they're elected, they have our mandate for the next three years.

The result of this doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty at all costs, is to make citizens more vulnerable than they may think to the arbitrary will of the Government.

As Lord Scarman put it; "So long as English law is unable in any circumstances to challenge a statute, it is, in dangerous and difficult times, at the mercy of the oppressive or discriminatory statute."

But New Zealand remains the last bastion of western Parliamentary supremacy. Other nations have balanced the inequality between the state and the citizen by structural safeguards of various kinds. These include a judicial function of striking down legislation which infringes fundamental rights.

That course was proposed in the White Paper " A Bill of Rights for New Zealand (1985) AJHR A6, but was rejected.

Today, the executive government has captured a disproportionate level of power through the use of conventions, the use of urgency to bring Bills forward and subvert the select committee and public submissions process, their ability to use proxy votes, their voting bloc in caucus and the party whipping system over MP's.

Yet representative democracy has, as a first principle, the informed consent vote or, at the very least, consultation

But MP's can even jump ship to another party without sanction. So much for the "informed consent vote or consultation" with electors.

Moreover, there is simply too much legislation being pushed through Parliament which does not meet the criteria of representative democracy.

In its 1995 Annual Report to Parliament the NZ Law Commission expressed concerns that; " Too much legislation is wrongly focused and fails to address the issue it is meant to; some legislation is unnecessary; much is hastily introduced with fundamental issues still to be addressed when bill's go to select committe's; much is inaccessible or hard to understand; and some is not in accord with constitutional principles."

Most of the important principles for representative democracy are already enshrined. Magna Carta, The Act of Settlement, the Statute of Westminster, the Habeus Corpus Acts, the Petition of Right , the Bill of Rights 1688 are but some instances.

These laws show starkly how far New Zealand has deviated from the fundamentals. If a nation is to be successful and is to enjoy an effective legal system, there must be some agreement as to the basic principles which limits the power of the legislature which has become dangerously illimitable.


© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Howard Davis Review: From Free Press to Fancy Dress - Spielberg's The Post

Stephen Spielberg's The Post is an opportune newsroom drama in which a corrupt Republican president wages war against the "liberal media," as its plucky proprietor risks economic and legal ruin to bring the Pentagon Papers to public light. Its true protagonist is publisher Katharine Graham, a stringently diplomatic businesswoman, reluctantly compelled to take an overtly political stance in the interests of democracy and freedom of the press. More>>

Howard Davis Review: The Black Dog of Empire - Joe Wright's Darkest Hour'

On the eve of England's contorted efforts to negotiate its ignominious retreat from Europe and the chaotic spectacle of the Tory party ratifying its undignified departure from a union originally designed to prevent another World War, there has been a renewed appetite for movies about 1940. More>>

Howard Davis Review: Anger Begets Anger - Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri

For fans of what Ricky Gervais termed "number movies" (Seven Samurai, The Magnificent Seven, Ocean's 11, Se7en), Martin McDonagh's latest offering will be a welcome addition to the roster. The Irish playwright turned screenwriter and director has produced another quirky and darkly comic tragedy that evolves around the futility of anger and grief, retribution and revenge. More>>

Howard Davis: Sexting in George Dawe's Genevieve - Part I

Te Papa's permanent collection includes an enormous oil painting by the English artist George Dawe called Genevieve (from by a poem by S.T. Coleridge entitled 'Love') that was prominently featured in the 2013 exhibition Angels & Aristocrats. Compare the massive immensity of the bard's gorgeously gilded harp with the stubby metallic handle of the Dark Knight's falchion, both suggestively positioned at crotch-level. Dawe's enormous canvas invokes a whole history of blushing that pivots around a direct connection to sexual arousal. More>>


Ethnomusicology: Malian ‘Desert Blues’ Revolutionaries To Storm WOMAD

Malian band Tinariwen (playing WOMAD NZ in March 2018) are a true musical revolutionaries in every sense. Active since 1982, these nomadic Tuareg or ‘Kel Tamashek’ (speakers of Tamashek) electric guitar legends revolutionised a traditional style to give birth to a new genre often called ‘desert blues’. They also have a history rooted deeply in revolution and fighting for the rights of their nomadic Tamashek speaking culture and people. More>>

Gordon Campbell: Best New Music Of 2017

Any ‘best of list’ has to be an exercise in wishful thinking, given the splintering of everyone’s listening habits... But maybe… it could be time for the re-discovery of the lost art of listening to an entire album, all the way through. Just putting that idea out there. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland