Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search

 

Scoop Feedback: Apology To Chinese NZers

In This Edition: Pandora's Box - The Treaty - Get Out Of The Kitchen

Pandora's Box

Sir,

I fully support the initiative taken by the government in acknowledging that the years of discrimination against early Chinese settlers in New Zealand was wrong.

However, for the government to be considering providing "money to develop Chinese language and culture and to recognise the immigrants' contribution to society" is not in the best interests of developing New Zealand's identity or nationhood.

Wellington Chinese Association president Esther Fung commented "She wanted more teaching of Chinese history in schools and a commitment to encouraging Chinese language. Without their language, the Chinese here did not have their culture."

Yet in the next breath Ms Fung states "We do regard ourselves as New Zealanders now".

Having adopted the culture and lifestyle of another country in preference to ones origins, you can not later expect to have it both ways.

This applies to all immigrants and it is the responsibility of the "elders" to ensure continuity of their heritage, culture and language, not that of the adopted country.

There is, it seems, a precedent being set here which will open a Pandora's box similar to that of our politically correct dealings with things "Treaty" , the lid of which will be hard to close.

Mirek Marcanik

***

The Treaty

Dear sir,

The treaty of waitangi is an anachronism and has no place as a founding document, a partnership, or a living document. At best it’s a historical document, recording British colonial attempts to quietly gain sovereignty over a new territory, without expending vast sums on enforcing and defending their authority in such a far flung place. “Give the colonials and natives the idea that each is the master of themselves and the other, while milking them for commodities - should keep them quiet for a while, what!”

The treaty was always doomed to fail, because each language version is so different. It was cleverly designed this way to give each party the impression, that what they thought they were getting, was what they wanted - except that the government, as governments always do, gets away with what ever it wants. They ALL were duped, just as we all are being duped nowadays.

The treaty is based on falsehoods and will be forever open to reinterpretation, relitigation and perpetual claims. It is a recipe for racial division, tribalism and will lead to apartheid in this country.

One law for all - not: law for one, and law for one other.

-- Barry Cole Christchurch

***

Get Out Of The Kitchen

Sir,

The Government is pleading with its Australian counterparts to desist interfering in New Zealand's political decisions.

Come on. This is the world of politics.

They, like us (I think), are a democracy entitled to freedoms of speech. Freedoms which allow one to comment where it is perceived the implications of decisions made by one of the partners is detrimental to the common good.

If the Government "can not stand the heat in the kitchen" they should stop cooking their own stews and get out.

Mirek Marcanik

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 

Binoy Kampmark: Meddling For Empire - The CIA Comes Clean

One of the difficulties behind the podium stance of virtue taken by the US political establishment on Russian interference in the country’s electoral process is one of simple hypocrisy. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Gun Debate, Here And In The US

Gun ownership in the US is a mystery to New Zealanders, and so is the constitutional fetish that surrounds it. However, the attitudes involved are not static and unchanging, even if it can feel that way in the wake of each new gun atrocity. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Mueller Probe, And Russia’s Economy

In itself, the indictment of 13 Russian nationals and three Russian companies for interfering in the 2016 US wlll do little to change pre-existing views about the Robert Mueller investigation into Russia’s meddling in US presidential politics... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Nunes Memo

Every now and then the US system erupts and throws up a piece of political magma that can’t be described or explained in any rational fashion... More>>

ALSO:

Ross Webb: Our Union-Powered Past

Labour’s soon-to-implemented workplace relations policy aims to address the imbalances in our economy, but has sparked fears among some that it marks a return to ‘the bad old days’ of the 1970s. But what exactly was happening in the 1970s? And what has caused the ‘imbalances’ that Labour is now trying to fix? More>>

ALSO: