Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | News Flashes | Scoop Features | Scoop Video | Strange & Bizarre | Search

 


Stateside: 11 September 1: 27 July Nil

Stateside with Rosalea Barker

11 September 1: 27 July Nil

I cried when I watched Laila Harre's concession speech, and I'm not entirely sure why. I guess it's because she's one of the people I would have given an all-round Minnie Award to for her integrity, her hard work, her quick grasp of the business of legislating, and her potential, based on what I saw of her in action between 1996-99.

Since I moved to the United States at the end of 1999, I haven't really followed Kiwi politics in any detail, so I'll take it on faith that the comment on TV3's website that the cause of the Alliance meltdown was Jim Anderton's insistence they support the Labour government on sending troops to Afghanistan. I guess he got spooked by being the person who was at the helm on September 11 - a chance occurrence he apparently thinks is good reason for him to continue as Deputy PM, despite being one of only two Progressive Coalition MPs.

California is currently 19 hours behind NZDT, so your election coverage began at midnight Friday night here. The last time I remember watching election results live was back in the 70s and I wasn't about to stay up all night watching streaming video not so much stream as ooze through my skinny modem, so I waited till the next morning. When I awoke the Cartoon Fairy had left a drawing on my pillow - it showed a truck dumping a nine-lumped worm cast on the steps of Parliament.

On the New Zealand Herald election page a graphic of the seats in the debating chamber clearly showed who they had expected to win at the time they started making it - all the blues and their likely cohorts were on the right of Mr Speaker, despite the fact that NANZFUF didn't even make it to the halfway mark. I'm not sure who had written the "parties" pages for TVOne's Nzoom online, but the number of list members they chose to show was also instructive: Labour, National, the Greens, ACT, and the Progressive Coalition had 20 names posted; the Alliance had 10; New Zealand First, 5; and there were none at all for United Future.

My favourite posting is Nzoom's clip of Mike Hosking talking to Peter Dunne on election night, where Dunne says it seems a government can't be formed without United Future being part of it. "C'mon Peter, help us out, the nation wants to know..." purrs Hosking at one point in that way he has of charming the most ill-considered remarks out of politicians, who nonetheless think they're outwitting the interviewer. In response to Hosking's comment that Dunne's voting record shows he's more centre right than centre left, Mr Integrity replies: "I think that voting record, frankly, will become irrelevant."

Well, yes, I guess it will, now that Helen Clark has the purple rook square on to the Green pawn, and expedience is the order of the day. Clark is playing an abysmally stupid game, and completely unnecessarily. The Greens won't mitigate their party's stance over GE - they're not the sort to say their voting record is irrelevant. But they are a party for the people, and as such they should be willing to accept the outcome of a national referendum on the issue, held before the moratorium is due to be lifted.

If the nation says that the moratorium should be lifted, then the Greens should not withdraw support for money bills - and can still claim the high moral ground of voting in accordance with the people's wishes; if the nation says the moratorium should NOT be lifted, then Labour shouldn't lift it. How hard is that?

I'm sure the people of New Zealand would rather have a referendum than suffer yet another drawn-out poli-soap opera about who gets to sit in which seat.

lea_barker@hotmail.com
Lea Barker
California
Sunday, 28 July 2002


 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

Public Address link: Dave Haywood from the
Linwood Park Temporary Earthquake Village
- Emma Hart
Photos: EQNZ Remembrance

kiwirail, flat-top wagon, trains, cargo, transport, lemon

Gordon Campbell: On Kiwirail’s Current Problems With Its Chinese-Built Wagons

For many people, Kiwirail’s decision to buy 500 flat top wagons from manufacturers in China instead of building them at Hillside workshops in Dunedin was a classic case of New Zealand chasing short term cost savings from overseas providers at the expense of many local jobs, the development of manufacturing expertise in this country and the related flow-on economic benefits to the wider community.

In recent weeks, the issue of the $49 million rail wagon contract has risen again – this time over news that the Chinese-built wagons are already requiring repairs at a rate significantly higher than normal. More>>

ALSO:

 
 

The Darwin Bombing: The Hidden Story

Binoy Kampmark: On the one hand, the Australian populace had to be convinced that Emperor Hirohito’s armies had the hunger and the ability to march through the wide toasted country of a continent – after all, a suitable defence had to be planned against any onslaught. On the other hand, those oriental savages had to be deemed suitably incompetent and subhuman to be defeated. Surely, they were incapable of such a feat? More >>

Binoy Kampmark: The Farce Of Protection: Humans, Human Rights, And Syria

Humanitarian intervention is often premised on a fetishizing exercise. Protecting civilians has become the time immemorial justification for interventions that rarely achieve that. More>>

ALSO:

Werewolf Satire: The Other People In Your Neighbourhood

With audio! Under a pile of unused plastic spoons I happened to find an old tin of film. There was no clue as to its contents, and it was just made more mysterious by a note scrawled on the label… More>>

Keith Rankin: Asset Sales And Public Ownership

Based on the valuation ... the present government would gain 7.2 billion dollars, and lose two years' worth of dividends ($1.44 billion, assuming annual dividends are 10% of valuation). All future three-year governments would be about $2.2 billion worse off. More>>

Werewolf: Why State Capitalism Is Beating The Free Market

Gordon Campbell: Late last month, the Economist magazine published a debate on state capitalism, in which it proposed that state-led market economies are fast becoming a global rival to the old models of liberal, free market capitalism. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On Syria

So far, the fighting in Syria has largely been limited to its smaller cities – Homs in particular... All the same, Homs is a cautionary example of the dangerous fault lines that run through the entire society. More>>

ALSO:

Werewolf: Undaunted Oakland

It gets really tiring living in Oakland. Practically every television newscast is straight from the police blotter. Murders. Marches. Mayhem. Mayoral recall. (Oops! That last one’s not from the blotter but from the OPD to-do list.) ... More>>

ALSO:

Werewolf: Human Rights, Pinochet And Asset Freezes

Gordon Campbell interviews Baron Collins of Mapesbury, recently retired judge from the British Supreme Court. Politicians are always tempted to take pot shots at judges, who have relatively few friends among the general public. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops
Search Scoop  
 
 
powered by newsagent
NZ independent news