Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Big News: The War Between The Judge & The Cabinet

Big News with Dave Crampton

The War Between The Judge And The Cabinet

The war of words between the country's top judge and Cabinet Ministers still continues over the new Supreme Court. This war has been brewing since Dame Sian Elias handed down the Foreshore and Seabed decision in the Appeal Court. The Government refused to appeal the decision to the Privy Council as it was in the process of trying to ditch the council and form a new Supreme Court, against the will and wishes of most New Zealanders.

The Government instead responded by attempting to change the law - leading to the current Foreshore and Seabed legislation, and the Hikoi. It also changed the law to set up the new court and make Dame Elias head of that court. Now the head of the new court is publically criticising it, both in New Zealand and overseas, and the Government is not impressed. Helen Clark has said here comments were " minor" Michael Cullen, however, has a different perspective - one of "judicial activism".

The latest comments, from Cullen, were a strong reminder that Government sets laws, judges make judgements based on the law.

They follow Prime Minister Helen Clark's criticism of Maori Land Court judge Caren Wickliffe when she ruled that a large Maori East Coast coastal claim could proceed. Miss Clark said that she thought judges would have "rather better things to do with their time" than preside over such cases.

When judgements do not go the way of the Government, do cabinet ministers have a right to criticise judgments if they are based on law set by Government? Additionally, do cabinet ministers have the right to attack comments by judges such as Elias? Particularly when cabinet's office manual does forbid comments that reflect badly on the "impartiality, personal views or ability of any judge".

I would have thought Helen Clark and Michael Cullen have better things to do with their time.

Elias is putting forward her personal views. She is entitled to do so. The staff in Cullen's office have said the minister's comments were not an attack, but a "disagreement about the views she has raised".

But if concerns raised by Cullen are seen to reflect badly on a judge, the resultant comment from Cullen's staff is inexcusable.

Equally inexcusable is the Governments rush to implement a flawed court without the wishes of the majority of the people. Margaret Wilson, Helen Clark and Michael Cullen decided to set up the Supreme Court before any public select committee submissions were considered.

It is also ironic that four of the five judges selected for the new Supreme Court presided over the foreshore and seabed case.

The refusal of the government to appeal the decision from the Appeal Court because it was going to scrap the Privy Council is coming back to bite the Government on the bum - hard.

- Dave Crampton is a Wellinton writer and blogs at

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


27-29 Sept: Social Enterprise World Forum Live Blog

1600+ delegates from more than 45 countries have came together to share wisdom, build networks and discuss how to create a more sustainable future using social enterprise as a vehicle. Attending the Forum were social enterprise practitioners, social entrepreneurs, policy makers, community leaders, investors, activists, academics and more from across the globe... More>>

HiveMind Report: A Universal Basic Income For Aotearoa NZ

Results from this HiveMind suggests that an overwhelming majority of Kiwis believe that due to changing circumstances and inefficiencies in the current system, we need a better system to take care of welfare of struggling members in our society. More>>


Scoop Hivemind: Medical Cannabis - Co-Creating A Policy For Aotearoa

Welcome to the fourth and final HiveMind for Scoop’s Opening the Election campaign for 2017. This HiveMind explores the question: what would a fair, humane and safe Medical Cannabis policy look like for Aotearoa, NZ in 2018? More>>


Lyndon Hood: Notes On National’s Election Campaign, In Poem Form

Nationyl’s bitumen-ing / As they du du / Seed groweth / River floweth / Then ‘dozer drives thru / Highway ensu. More>>