Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | News Flashes | Scoop Features | Scoop Video | Strange & Bizarre | Search

 


Cullen Backdown Unleashes Storm of Retractions

Cullen Backdown Unleashes Storm of Parliamentary Retractions
Oh, wait - actually that's not true at all.


By Lyndon Hood

The recent experience of Dr Michael Cullen seems to have given his colleagues ideas. For years they have struggled with the burden of it being inadvisable - and in some cases expensive - to declare obvious and demonstrable falsehoods. Or at any rate, to do so outside the House of Parliament.

This stricture is of course almost intolerable to a career politician. And the proposed changes to Parliamentary privilege rules address the problem in the same way the Labour's budget provides tax cuts.

But now Cullen has, in a burst of ingenuity, applied the "Withdraw and Apologise" technique - long favoured by those wishing to break the rules inside Parliament - to real life. And given the other other 119 MPs proof that, as long as you disavow it quickly enough, you can say whatever damfool thing you're patronising enough to think your voters want to hear.

The method has been used for a variety of political effects.

Rodney Hide told a press conference that he had heard reports that, during the late 70s, David Benson-Pope had caused the death of millions of innocent civilians and left their bones in piles. He said that he had found these reports "credible".

Shortly afterwards Hide released a clarification, saying that his information in fact related to one Pol Pot.

WInston Peters, addressing the Tauranga bowls club, had this to say: "Have you noticed all the funny-coloured people wandering around in the streets these days? Why is that allowed? Not content to be greasy and smelly, now they want to blow us up! Hold on, I appear to have my notes upside-down. Um... I hold in my hand a list of migrants. One of them must be dodgy."

Greens justice spokesperson Nandor Tanzcos has given the trend a new spin. "We are pleased to help the Government pass Phil Goff's Prisoner's and Victim's Compensation Bill, which we had so violently opposed on human rights grounds," he told reporters. After a moment's pause he pulled away the hand Mr Goff was about to shake and pretended to smooth back his dreadlocks, crying, "Ha ha! Just jokes!"

"Ooo. Burned!" he added.

Popular though the method is becoming, none of the practitioners have quite matched Cullen's technique. Novices still speak with hushed awe of the double-whammy he achieved on his first attempt. Even as he berated entirely the wrong television station, he threw in a perfect retrospective projected flipflop:

"Remember when I said it wasn't appropriate to comment on an ongoing investigation? Well, I've got a few things to tell you about false accusations in a bit. Oh yes."

ENDS

*************

homepages.ihug.co.nz/~lghood
fightingtalk.blogspot.com


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 

Selpius Bobii:Tragic Bloodshed in Waghete, Papua - Suspected Serious Human Rights Violations

Ever since West Papua was annexed into the Republic of Indonesia on 1 May 1963, it has been nothing other than a land smeared with blood and at every moment the blood of Papuans has been shed by the continuous killings. More>>

Leslie Bravery: Simon Schama – Ideology Versus Truth And Reason

In the third part of his BBC history documentary The Story of the Jews Simon Schama announced “I am a Zionist and quite unapologetic about it.” That honest but blunt admission advises us that when the subject of Israel/Palestine is under discussion, ... More>>

Ramzy Baroud: South Vs. North: Yemen Teeters Between Hope And Division

On Oct 12, tens of thousands of Yemenis took to the streets of Eden in the South of the country, mostly demanding secession from the north. The date is significant, for it marks the 1967 independence of South Yemen, ending several decades of British ... More>>

Binoy Kampmark: Ralph Miliband: The Illusion Of Radical Change

Radical conservative critiques often suffer from one crippling flaw: they are mirrors of their revolutionary heritage, apologies for their own deceptions. If you want someone who detests the Left, whom better than someone formerly of the card carrying, ... More>>

Hadyn Green: TPP: This Is A Fight Worth Joining

Trade negotiations are tense affairs. There are always interested parties trying to get your ear, long nights spent arguing small but technical points, and the invisible but ever present political pressure. So it was in Brunei late August where the latest ... More>>

Ramzy Baroud: Giap, Wallace, And The Never-Ending Battle For Freedom

'Nothing is more precious than freedom,” is quoted as being attributed to Vo Nguyen Giap, a Vietnamese General that led his country through two liberation wars. The first was against French colonialists, the second against the Americans. More>>

John Chuckman: The Poor People Of Egypt

How is it that the people of Egypt, after a successful revolution against the repressive 30-year government of President Mubarak, a revolution involving the hopes and fears of millions and a substantial loss of life, have ended up almost precisely where ... More>>

Harvey Wasserman: 14,000 Hiroshimas Still Swing In The Fukushima Air...

Japan’s pro-nuclear Prime Minister has finally asked for global help at Fukushima. It probably hasn’t hurt that more than 100,000 people have signed petitionscalling for a global takeover; more than 8,000 have viewed a new YouTube on it. More>>

Get More From Scoop

 
 
TEDxAuckland
 
 
 
More RSS  RSS News AlertsNews Alerts
 
 
Top Scoops
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news