Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | News Flashes | Scoop Features | Scoop Video | Strange & Bizarre | Search

 


Karl Kuchenbecker Case - The Coroner Got It Wrong


Karl Kuchenbecker Case - The Coroner Got It Wrong

By Roger Brooking

On June 18, the Wellington coroner Garry Evans released his report into the death of Karl Kuchenbecker. According to Mr Evans, the fundamental mistake in the mismanagement of convicted murderer Graeme Burton's parole in 2006 was treating the highly volatile and dangerous offender as a normal parolee. This was a mistake. However, in my view it was not the fundamental mistake.

According to the news media, Graeme Burton had been using drugs since he was 15 years old. He already had 91 convictions including convictions for possession of drugs before he committed his first murder in 1992. After he was arrested, he told police he was ‘out of it’ on a cocktail of six different drugs. He reportedly used drugs most of the time he was in prison, but managed to remain drug-free in the two years before he was released on parole. Soon after he was released on parole, he began using stand over tactics with drug dealers to obtain methamphetamine and anything else he could get his hands on. A few months later he committed his second murder.

Judge John Dalmer was on the panel which twice refused Graeme Burton's application to be released into the community and remembers him as someone who had appeared before them with a 10-year drug habit. When Burton was released and re-offended, the judge was quoted in the media as saying he suspected that Burton's problem was that he had relapsed to drug use.

Judge Dalmer was right. The Corrections Department was aware that drug use was a contributing factor in Burton’s offending. However, it appears that he managed to avoid using drugs in prison in the two years before his release. Apparently this was enough to convince the Department that he had kicked his habit. As a result, they failed to provide an alcohol and drug assessment to the Parole Board.

In a letter to the writer, Minister of Corrections, Phil Goff justified this by saying: “Mr Burton consistently maintained that he was not using drugs or alcohol both before and after his release”. He went on to say that the special investigation by the Department into the management of Mr Burton's parole found “it is unlikely that Burton would have been assessed by a drug and alcohol programme provider as requiring treatment as he stated he was maintaining abstinence and was not admitting to having any issues with drugs or alcohol.”

This explanation provided by Mr Goff is patently ridiculous. The Coroner states that the Police were well aware that Burton was using stand-over tactics with drug dealers in Wellington a full two months before Mr Kuchenbecker was shot. It seems that rather than have Burton assessed by a professional addiction counsellor before (or after) he was released, the Department choose to believe the word of a known psychopath. To think that a drug addict (let alone a psychopath) would tell the truth about his drug use is surely naïve in the extreme.

Even when someone does achieve temporary abstinence in prison, this does not mean they have dealt with the underlying issues that led to their addiction. Many inmates achieve abstinence but still need to do a rehabilitation programme on release. In fact being abstinent is merely the first step in what is generally a five year journey to recovery. The reality is that only a professional alcohol and drug clinician would be qualified to determine whether or not Burton’s drug dependence required further treatment.

Drug addiction was clearly not Burton's only underlying problem. A psychologist assessed him as having a psychopathic personality which pre-disposed him towards violence. Burton had completed a living without violence programme in prison and apparently done motivational work with the psychologist. However, a violent psychopath released into the community with an untreated methamphetamine addiction is nothing short of a disaster waiting to happen.

Inmates are often required to attend and may successfully complete cognitive skills based programmes in prison known as criminogenic programmes. Burton did some criminogenic programmes. But these are ‘education’ programmes, not ‘therapeutic’ programmes which the treatment of substance dependence (drug addiction) requires.

When an offender with an untreated drug addiction is released from prison, they often relapse to their drug of choice within a few days. Once relapse occurs, anything that might have been learnt in a criminogenic programme is forgotten because under the influence of alcohol or ‘P’, the offender no longer has any impulse control. Rapid relapse to alcohol and drug use followed soon after by further re-offending is probably the norm rather than the exception for those released from prison in New Zealand.

Clearly there is no guarantee that Burton would not have re-offended even if he had received treatment for his addiction. But his parole condition should have been that he was placed in a residential alcohol and drug programme for a minimum of 12 months, where he could have monitored on a daily basis. If he relapsed or misbehaved, he could have been recalled to prison immediately. Instead he was placed with his mother – for one month. After that he seems to have been on his own.

Everyone with anything to say on this matter including the Coroner seems to have focused on what the Corrections Department, the Police and the Parole Board did wrong after Burton’s release. Undoubtedly, mistakes were made. However, the fundamental mistake was actually made long before Burton was released. It was made by Corrections staff who don’t understand the nature of addiction and level of treatment required to address it.

Perhaps this is not surprising considering that the Department does not employ alcohol and drug clinicians on its staff and does not even have a budget to have inmates assessed by alcohol and drug clinicians coming up for parole.

If the Department had taken his drug addiction more seriously, and if Burton had been released into a residential treatment programme, none of the subsequent mistakes identified by the Coroner would have occurred.

*******

Roger Brooking is the Clinical Manager at ADAC Ltd that specialises in Alcohol & Drug Assessments & Counselling.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 

Gordon Campbell: On The West’s Existential Crisis About What To Do With Putin, And The Islamic State

Say one thing for Russian President Vladimir Putin. At least he’s given NATO a purpose in life. Right now, that consists of being something that Barack Obama and David Cameron can hide behind, point at Putin, and say : “Go get him, tiger.” Just what NATO is supposed to do about Putin’s armed advance into eastern Ukraine is less than clear. But there is a lot of “steely determination” around in high places. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The US Foreign Policy Somersaults Over Syria And Iran

Amidst the day-to-day reports about the military advances of the Islamic State fighters in Iraq and Syria, one remarkable aspect of this war has barely been mentioned. More>>

ALSO:

Daphne Lawless: The Whale Oil Leaks: Anti-Politics From Above

As we go to press, the election campaign has been turned upside down by a new book by investigative journalist Nicky Hager. Dirty Politics is based mainly on a leak of 2 gigabytes of emails and Facebook messages from “Whale Oil”, the vicious ... More>>

ALSO:

Branko Marcetic: When John Key Was Concerned About Dirty Politics

If Nicky Hager needs some support in the midst of a whirlwind of government criticism for his allegations of “dirty tricks” by the National Party, he may find one unlikely ally – John Key, six years ago. More>>

Jim Miles: Israeli War Crimes In Gaza

Israel reveals its true colours and true aspirations every time it attacks Gaza (or any other self-perceived enemy) as being the ethnic cleansing of Palestine, even to the degree - as the references above indicate - to the act of genocide. More>>

David Swanson: Top 9 Reasons To Stop Bombing Iraq

1. It's not a rescue mission. The U.S. personnel could be evacuated without the 500-pound bombs. The persecuted minorities could be supplied, moved, or their enemy dissuaded, or all three, without the 500-pound bombs or the hundreds of 'advisors' (trained ... More>>

Binoy Kampmark: Comedian’s Death: Robin Williams And The Virtues Of Suicide

The Grim Reaper never runs out of converts. Put another way, death never gets his full due. Comedians do not figure well in this – they are particularly attractive targets in the business of death. More>>

Suzan Mazur: "Oomph" & Origin Of Life At Hydrothermal Vents

The notion that life originated in hydrothermal vents was for a long time a sleepy area of scientific inquiry because the vents first found, known as 'black smokers,' were way too hot and acidic. But in 1989, Michael Russell, a British geochemist who ... More>>

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news