Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | News Flashes | Scoop Features | Scoop Video | Strange & Bizarre | Search

 


Did Justice Order Forced Psych Medication?

Did Justice Order Forced Psych Medication?



The internal recommendation from federal prison psychiatrists on forced
medication for Susan Lindauer.

New Evidence Obtained in Lindauer Case

Hearing in NY Federal Court on Sept. 11, 2001

Michael Collins
"Scoop" Independent News

(Wash. DC) On 9/11 Susan Lindauer will have the second of three hearings to prove her competence to stand trial as an accused "unregistered foreign agent" for Iraq prior to the 2003 U.S. invasion. She was indicted in April 2004 and has consistently requested an open trial to prove her innocence. Lindauer provided "Scoop" Independent News with a copy of a December 23, 2005 "Medication Hearing" report by psychiatrists at the federal prison, Carswell Air Force Base, Ft. Worth, Texas. She was confined there for seven months for evaluation in 2005 and 2006..

At May 2006 hearings before then Judge Michael B. Mukasey (now U.S. Attorney General), assistant U.S. Attorney Ed O'Callaghan requested a court order that would have forced Lindauer to take the psychiatric medications listed below. Lindauer adamantly denied any need for medication, Physical coercion is allowed for those subject to involuntary medication by court order. The drugs that the government wanted to force into her body included: "Antipsychotics, Benzodiazepeines, Antidepressant, Mood Stabilizers"

This is the face page of the "Notice of Medication Hearing." Carswell psychiatrists recommended the use of powerful psychotropic medication for a non specific diagnosis by a prisoner described as consistently "appropriate" to staff and peers.

According to the prosecution, forced medication was necessary in order for Lindauer to stand trial on charges that she acted as an "unregistered foreign agent" for Iraq and attempted to influence a highly placed U.S. government official. Among other things, the "influence" included discouraging the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq due to the damage that it would cause the United States (see letter). The "official" turned out to be Andrew Card, then chief of staff for President Bush and Lindauer's second cousin. Lindauer denies the charges categorically and asserts that she'd been a U.S. intelligence asset for years prior to her arrest. She reports working on the Lockerbie investigation, anti terrorist activities which she says involved Iraqi cooperation, and other efforts.

The Dec. 23 medication report suggested a full spectrum of serious medications for Lindauer. But the report recommended against "involuntary medication." This clearly indicated by a check in the box next to part "4. Findings," section "A." which states, "Involuntary medication is not approved" (see photocopy of report at top article).

Based on the professional opinion of the psychiatrist(s) evaluating her plus the staff and others who contributed to the report, there was no justification for forced medication.

The report, which Lindauer refused to sign, contains a summary of her objections to the diagnosis and the suggested medications:

"Ms. Lindauer reported she was against medication of any kind, including psychotropic medication.

"She denied the possibility of mental illness, since again reporting in detail her belief that the government is having her detained because she represents a threat to the administration due to her differing beliefs about their policies on Iraq. She states she has been a government agent for 9 years working in 'anti terrorism.'

"Ms Lindauer denied any wish to hurt herself or others and denied any history of aggressive behavior." (Recorded in Notice of Medication Report Dec. 23, 2005)

Yet in May 2006, during two hearings before then Federal District Court Judge Michael B. Mukasey, federal prosecutors argued that the medication mentioned above should be provided on an "involuntary" basis. This would have allowed Carswell staff to force these medications into Lindauer's body, orally or intravenously, against her will through methods required to overpower any physical resistance on her part.

Where did the motion for forced medication come from?

The professional consensus and position of Carswell FMC was "Involuntary medication is not approved."

Did something happen between the late December 2005 Carswell report and the May 2006 hearings in federal district court in New York? Federal prosecutor Ed O'Callaghan called Colin Vas, MD, a government psychiatrist form FMC Carswell who had interviewed Lindauer at Carswell and participated in the "Notice" hearing report shown above. Dr. Vas argued for a diagnosis of Psychotic Disorder Not Otherwise Specified and challenged the report he'd helped prepare by supporting forced medication.

At the May 5, 2006 hearing, Sanford B. Talkin, Lindauer's attorney at the time, addressed the two major components of the "psychotic" label, hallucinations and disorganized behavior, in his cross examination of Dr. Vas. Talkin got Vas to admit that nursing reports just prior to the May hearing all showed Lindauer's behavior as "appropriate" and that she had positive interactions with staff and her peers. Vas further confirmed that this was an accurate description of her behavior over the months she was confined at Carswell, with the exception of antipathy toward psychiatrists who labeled her with a mental illness. Vas also agreed that there were "no hallucinations" either reported by Lindauer or indicated by staff observations during her time at the federal prison.

Vas also testified that Lindauer had requested that Carswell staff contact a list of witnesses who would confirm her role as a U.S. intelligence asset. Talkin directed Vas' attention to one psychiatric report on which Lindauer wrote in her own hand, "witness proves it's all true."

On May 9, Dr. Robert L. Goldstein, a psychiatrist called by Lindauer's attorney, testified that Lindauer showed none of the major signs of schizophrenia. This significantly challenged the Psychotic Disorder Not Otherwise Specified diagnosis from Carswell. He argued that Lindauer did have a delusional disorder due to her belief that she was a U.S. intelligence asset. There is no claim or indication that Goldstein contacted any of Lindauer's witnesses that she said would back up her story.

How did the December 2005 Carswell FMC recommendation transform from one opposing forced medication into a prosecution request for an order to force Lindauer to take the medications listed above? Was there some evidence presented to support the change in position. It didn't result from Lindauer's behavior according to the testimony elicited from Carswell psychiatrist, Dr. Colin Vas. The psychiatrist had records showing consistently "appropriate" behavior and no signs of hallucinations.

If the recommendation didn't come from Carswell, where did it originate?

Are U.S. Attorney's now in the business of deciding if defendants should be forced to take psychiatric medication?

After Mukasey refused the prosecution request, Lindauer was released from federal custody on bond. She returned to Maryland where federal court services referred her to a private agency for counseling services. That evaluation showed a diagnosis of post traumatic stress disorder due to her experiences at Carswell and the potential for physical coercion implicit in the process of involuntary medication. There was no diagnosis of a serious mental illness during the extended period of court mandated counseling in the D.C. area either before and after her confinement at Carswell.

To date, it has been nearly four and one half years since Lindauer's indictment. She's just finishing the competency hearing that she'd requested years ago pro se (on her own), a request that her court appointed attorney Talkin argued against successfully. She is currently represented by Brian Shaughnessy, of Shaughnessy, Volzer & Ganger, P.C. An active litigator in private practice, Shaughnessy is a former federal prosecutor who, for a period, was assigned to the D.C. federal court presided over by Judge John Sirica.

There is one more hearing next week which will conclude the competency phase of the case. If Judge Loretta Preska rules as anticipated that Lindauer's is competent to stand trial, the case will move to the trial Lindauer has insisted on since she was indicted prior to the 2004 election.

END

This article may be reproduced in whole or in part with attribution of authorship, a link to this article, and acknowledgment of images.

Previously by Michael Collins on this story:

American Cassandra: Susan Lindauer's Story Oct. 17, 2007
Political Prisoner Gets Her Day in Court June 11, 2008
An Exclusive Interview with Susan Lindauer June 11, 2008
911 Prediction Revealed at Susan Lindauer Competency Hearing June 17, 2008
From the People Who Brought You Judith Miller and George Bush June 24, 2008

*************

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 

Ramzy Baroud: Gaza’s Resistance Will Not Be Crushed

On the 13th day of Israel’s so-called Operation Protective Edge, stories of entire families collectively pulverized, women and children keenly targeted by Israeli soldiers saturate the media. Until now, 430 Palestinians have been killed, mostly women and ... More>>

ALSO:

Ian Anderson: Rearranging The Deck Chairs On The Titanic? The Labour Party And MANA

Early in July this year, Labour Party leader David Cunliffe made headlines by apologising for being a man. Stoked by capitalist media sensation, Prime Minister John Key responded that “not all men” abuse women. More>>

Shobha Shukla: Break The Silos: Drug Use, HIV, HCV, TB, Laws And Funding

Viet Nam is one of the countries in the world that has made remarkable progress over the last decade in not only making harm reduction and HIV services available and accessible for people who use drugs but also reforming laws for supportive health ... More>>

ALSO:

Fiona Gordon: Illegal Wildlife Trading: The Global Response

At the closing session of the inaugural United Nations Environment Assembly (UNEA) in Nairobi last month, United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said, “We need to act decisively to change humanity’s relationship with our planet.” More>>

Faisal Al-Asaad: Gaza: McCully’s Calls For Restraint On Both Sides Is Side-Taking Itself

Since June 12th, the world’s attention has been squarely focused on the events unfolding in the West Bank, Gaza and the occupied territories. The disappearance of three Israeli youths who were later found dead prompted a flurry of condemnations ... More>>

ALSO:

Tania Billingsley: Demand For Accountability On Sexual Assault

Since my assault I feel that people have been assuming that my idea of justice is to have Rizalman found guilty in a New Zealand court. While it is an important part of justice being done, my main reason for wanting this is not for my own sense of ... More>>

Leslie Bravery: Hold The Perpetrator To Account, Not The Victim!

In a 4 July 2014 statement to Scoop Independent News, on the violent deaths of four young people in the Israeli Occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem, New Zealand's Foreign Minister Murray McCully made the following comments: 'The recent killing ... More>>

ALSO:

Santon Tekege: Investigative Report Into Oil Palm In Nabire Regency, Papua

Several companies’ plans to invest in the oil palm sector in Nabire have met with local opposition. People from the Yerisiam and Wate ethnic groups have staged several peaceful actions in Nabire against one of these companies, PT Nabire Baru1. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 
 
TEDxAuckland
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news