Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | News Flashes | Scoop Features | Scoop Video | Strange & Bizarre | Search

 


Chc Recovery: Peoples Preferences Always Trump Policy


Christchurch Recovery:
Peoples Preferences Always Trump Policy

Hugh Pavletich
Cantabrians Unite
http://www.cantabriansunite.co.nz/

26 December 2012

Marta Steeman of The Press reports... FORSYTH BARR BUILDING MAY BE REPAIRED...

http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/business/8114724/Forsyth-Barr-building-may-be-repaired

From the date of the first earthquake event 4 September 2010 - over two years ago now – the priority should have been – how can the “new Christchurch” be best developed and governed to better cope with adverse events going forward?

The focus should have been on elementary “risk management”.

Remarkably...this has STILL yet to happen.

It is even more remarkable, when there had been an awareness of the earthquake risks for decades prior to the current series of events – as this television documentary from the mid 1990’s illustrates ...

http://www.youtube.com/watch? v=NkTy6ogLDX8&lc=nTT73t5-ILJS8Mj8jY1kyjc2KZlR0Xb6ZkTdlcvA9gU&feature=inbox
But the risks were in large measure ignored by the Authorities, as Joel Cayford explained with COUNCILS FUDGE CHRISTCHURCH SEISMICITY July 2011 ...

http://joelcayford.blogspot.co.nz/2011/07/councils-fudge-christchurch-seismicity.html

The most destructive 22 February event went on for around 40 seconds.

How will Christchurch cope when the major Alpine Fault “let’s go” (it’s not “if”...its “when”) and the shaking lasts for 3 or 4 minutes?

How much more of Christchurch will liquefy?

Would you like to be in the “restored” Forsyth Barr building when that happens?

At the same time – July last year – I wrote within am Interest Co NZ article CHRISTCHURCH: COUNCIL STALLED RECOVERY...

http://www.interest.co.nz/opinion/53947/opinion-hugh-pavletich-accuses-christchurch-city-council-blindness-blunders-and-chain-

“Reality bites
Unlike the Japanese, who are well prepared and educated about earthquakes and have remarkable risk management procedures in place to deal with them, New Zealand on the urban governance and planning fronts, is nowhere near where it should be.
Indeed – if this becomes a $30 billion event, it would likely have been much less at something below $15 billion, if there had been sound urban governance and planning preceding it. If it works out to be a $20 billion event, it would likely have been below a $10 billion one.
This is without considering the massive and often unnecessary “disruption costs” and the realities of the poorly understood Broken Windows Fallacy (YouTube video). The destruction of the capital stock “costs”. People and businesses rarely come out of an insurance event “making money”.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QG4jhlPLVVs
These major unnecessary poor quality urban governance and planning costs can in large measure be attributed to:
(a) Strangling land supply at the fringes, driving fringe serviced residential section / lots costs up from approximately $30 - $60,000 to $200 - $300,000 and beyond, which in turn ripples through land values within the rest of the urban area...refer Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey ...
http://www.demographia.com/dhi.pdf )
(b) Inappropriately financing infrastructure required for new development, loading the capital costs (with subdivision and builders margins) in to the house purchaser, then forcing them to “gift” this infrastructure to the utility providers.
(c) Poor planning degrading the performance of the residential construction sector, so that construction costs on a per metre basis are currently double what they should be. This “degradation” and the downstream degradation ( e.g. leaky homes, finance companies going to the wall, cowboy construction culture etc) were covered within an earlier article by the writer - Houston, we have a (housing affordability) problem | interest.co.nz.
http://www.interest.co.nz/news/49029/opinion-houston-we-have-housing-affordability-problem
(d) Because of these factors above, the age and quality of the Christchurch housing stock is considerably poorer and less seismically resistant than it should be. Including too the new stock (referred to as “bubble stock”), which has been built well outside conventional Development Ratios (refer the Definition of an Affordable Housing Market at Performance Urban Planning ....
.. http://www.performanceurbanplanning.org/ .
New residential stock, such as that at Rolleston on the good ground coped remarkably well (as did most housing west of Hagley Park and in other areas) – even though it was located at the end of the first event of magnitude 7.1 on 4 September 2010.
(e) Council planning and the idiotic Greater Christchurch Urban Development Strategy ... http://www.greaterchristchurch.org.nz/ (of which current Mayor Bob Parker was the major cheerleader) had effectively “banned” the provision of affordable land on the good ground at the southern, western and northern fringes of Christchurch, severely inflating the price of fringe lots / sections (a – above) and forcing development to the poorer quality swampy ground to the less favoured east. Sound geotechnical and engineering advice was persistently ignored by local politicians and urban planners, who’s only interests were in"birds and bees" issues....refer...QUAKE HIT RESIDENTS MAY SUE COUNCIL...
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/4168338/Quake-hit-residents-may-sue-council
(f) Christchurch urban planning and the regional Greater Christchurch Urban Development Strategy, through inflating land prices and artificially making housing considerably more expensive, forced greater intensification and CBD living. The earthquakes have proven that “density is deadly”. Natural hazards risk management was never considered. Earthquake and liquefaction risks were well understood within the development and engineering communities in particular.
(g) The Christchurch City Council had a long and sorry history of standing in the road of the demolition of much of the old (gerry built) commercial stock, it considered “historic” - that clearly was not. This gross over listing of historic buildings meant that there were not sufficient resources available for the necessary and adequate seismic upgrades of “truly” historic buildings, such as Christchurch Cathedral, the Catholic Cathedral of the Blessed Sacrament and the Arts Centre.
It degenerated pretty much in to a “power game”, with the drummed up active support of some of the “beautiful people” of Fendalton and Merivale, keen for commercial reasons to be seen as politically correct by the Council bureaucrats. This assisted in “smoothing the waters” for other developments requiring consent.”
AUTHORITIES MUST WORK WITH PEOPLE...NOT AGAINST THEM...
To date with the “top down” approach, the recovery process has been glacial.
International evidence is very clear, in that the “bottom u[“ approach is the only way to get robust recoveries underway.
The contrasting experiences of the “bottom up” Joplin, Missouri and the “top down” Tuscaloosa, Alabama tornadoes recovery experiences as reported in the Wall Street Journal April this year illustrate this...JOW JOPLIN IS BEATING TUSCALOOSA ...
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303404704577309220933715082.html
Cantabrians Unite with CHRISTCHURCH THE WAY FORWARD ( http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/AK1206/S00251/christchurch-the-way-forward.htm ) outlines what needs to happen, to allow a robust recovery to get underway, so that Christchurch is clearly seen as a resilient and opportunity City going forward.
CHRISTCHURCH – OUR CITY – OUR FUTURE.
ENDS


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 

Faisal Al-Asaad: Gaza: McCully’s Calls For Restraint On Both Sides Is Side-Taking Itself

Since June 12th, the world’s attention has been squarely focused on the events unfolding in the West Bank, Gaza and the occupied territories. The disappearance of three Israeli youths who were later found dead prompted a flurry of condemnations ... More>>

ALSO:

Tania Billingsley: Demand For Accountability On Sexual Assault

Since my assault I feel that people have been assuming that my idea of justice is to have Rizalman found guilty in a New Zealand court. While it is an important part of justice being done, my main reason for wanting this is not for my own sense of ... More>>

Leslie Bravery: Hold The Perpetrator To Account, Not The Victim!

In a 4 July 2014 statement to Scoop Independent News, on the violent deaths of four young people in the Israeli Occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem, New Zealand's Foreign Minister Murray McCully made the following comments: 'The recent killing ... More>>

ALSO:

Santon Tekege: Investigative Report Into Oil Palm In Nabire Regency, Papua

Several companies’ plans to invest in the oil palm sector in Nabire have met with local opposition. People from the Yerisiam and Wate ethnic groups have staged several peaceful actions in Nabire against one of these companies, PT Nabire Baru1. More>>

ALSO:

Redress Information: Putting The Death Of The Israeli Squatter Teens In Context

The Western media are awash with correspondents’ reports on the grief Israelis are experiencing over the death of three teenagers. The teenagers, the sons of Jewish squatters living on stolen Palestinian land in the occupied West Bank, who disappeared ... More>>

ALSO:

Liran Antebi: United States: Prepared For Military Intervention In Iraq?

Following the seizure of Iraq’s main cities by the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS), there has been much discussion about possible US military intervention in Iraq. Since the ISIS campaign began, a small American force of 275 soldiers has been ... More>>

John Chuckman: Iraq, ISIS, And Intervention: Just What Is Going On?

As so often is the case in foreign affairs, we will never know with precision what is happening in Iraq. The governments involved have reasons to disguise what they are doing, and a number of governments are indeed at work there. More>>

Joel Cosgrove: MANA and Industrial Relations: “Between equal rights, force decides”

Fightback participates in the MANA Movement, whose stated mission is to bring “rangatiratanga to the poor, the powerless and the dispossessed.” Capitalism was imposed in Aotearoa through colonisation, and the fight for indigenous self-determination is intimately ... More>>

Get More From Scoop

 
 
TEDxAuckland
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news