Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | News Flashes | Scoop Features | Scoop Video | Strange & Bizarre | Search

 


RNA World Defenders Take Center Stage at Princeton | Mazur

RNA World Defenders Take Center Stage at Princeton Origin of Life Conference


By Suzan Mazur

LINKS:
VIEW CONFERENCE LIVE
CONFERENCE SCHEDULE

Tuesday, Jan. 22, 2013 (ET)

John Sutherland, the British chemist and winner of the Lonsdale Origin of Life Challenge last year with Matthew Powner, opened day two of the Princeton conference talking about a new holistic approach to the problem, a theme he hinted at several years ago in a lecture at Montpellier, France co-sponsored by ISSOL in which he said the various camps of Origin of Life should come together. He, of course, was talking about metabolism first, genetics first, etc. factions. Sadly, Sutherland's Princeton address was so technical that even scientists in the room who were not chemists had a tough time appreciating it. Plus Sutherland was often barely audible and related more to the screen than to the audience. What progress has been made in his investigations stemming from the Lonsdale prize remains unclear, since Sutherland escaped to the airport canceling my lunchtime interview with him.

But ISSOL president Dave Deamer (who speaks on Thursday [Friday NZT]), also a Lonsdale award winner, told me the following about Sutherland's work in a recent interview:

"Sutherland and Powner published a remarkable paper in 2009 showing how these relatively complex nucleotides, the subunits of RNA, could be synthesized by a chemical process using feedstock. Their proposal was not just about RNA but trying to understand the chemistry of systems of molecules that could give rise to a variety of monomers of which the mononucleotides of RNA are one possible outcome. . . .

I'm not sure how John Sutherland and Matthew Powner would define feedstock, but I assume that they mean relatively reactive simple molecules, simpler, in fact, than mononucleotides. However, one end product of the reaction pathways they are investigating is a mononucleotide, as they showed in their Nature paper. So if that's what they mean by feedstock, then that's not what my work involves because I don't do that kind of chemistry.

Powner and Sutherland are real chemists, organic chemists. They know a lot about how organic chemicals can behave as a feedstock and produce more complex molecules.

What I'm doing is taking the next step and saying given that more complex molecules can be synthesized, what can we do to get them to form polymers? . . . .

I have heard from Harry Lonsdale that Sutherland thinks it might be 50 years [before we get to the bottom of the origin of life]."

Steven Benner of the Foundation for Applied Molecular Evolution successfully resuscitated the audience following Sutherland's talk. Benner so far is the hands-down star of the Princeton powwow. Dressed in an arty teal blue shirt, he thoroughly engaged the crowd, punctuating his informative presentation with perfectly-timed jokes, while working both the power point and chalk board.

Benner told me the day before of his plan to start his talk focusing on my story about the Princeton conference, in which I asked whether it was the "RNA World's Last Hurrah?" He did indeed put the Scoop Media story up on the big screen.

Pier Luigi Luisi was not in the Princeton audience to explain why he considers the RNA World a baseless fantasy, as I reported. So Benner explained for Luisi, saying the reason why is because of the decomposition of ribose, it's unstable.

Loren Williams of Georgia Institute of Technology, who's been a lively questioner at many of the presentations, told Benner the following regarding the RNA World, "Until I see it rain over in a meteor, I'm not going to believe it."

Paul Higgs of Canada's McMaster University opened with a followup story of mine quoting Andrew Pohorille's comment to me that reports of the death of the RNA world are greatly exaggerated. Higgs was an effective communicator, noting that there was indeed progress on the RNA World, citing the work of Dave Deamer et al.

In explaining how life emerges, Higgs pointed to the importance of spacial effects, saying they're "essential" regarding fluctuations. He said it is fluctuations that take you over the unstable point and life emerges.

Laura Landweber, principal organizer of the Princeton conference, emailed me today advising that the presentation of Georgia Institute of Technology's Nicholas Hud (which I missed) had not been streamed and also was not to be reported. Apparently, if the details of certain presentations get out, the science journals won't publish the scientist's paper.

Tomorrow is a spectacular lineup: Andrew Pohorille (origin of protein structures and functions), Wim Hordijk (autocatalytic sets), Nilesh Valdya (spontaneous network formation), Michael Hecht (synthetic biology), Loren Williams (ironing out ancient biochemistry), George Fox (origins and evolution of the ribosome) and much more. .

Earlier Reports in this series:
Conference Preview
Conference Report #1
Conference Report #2


********

Suzan Mazur is the author of The Altenberg 16: An Exposé of the Evolution Industry. Her interest in evolution began with a flight from Nairobi into Olduvai Gorge to interview the late paleoanthropologist Mary Leakey. Because of ideological struggles, the Kenyan-Tanzanian border was closed, and Leakey was the only reason authorities in Dar es Salaam agreed to give landing clearance. The meeting followed discovery by Leakey and her team of the 3.6 million-year-old hominid footprints at Laetoli. Suzan Mazur's reports have since appeared in the Financial Times, The Economist, Forbes, Newsday, Philadelphia Inquirer, Archaeology, Connoisseur, Omni and others, as well as on PBS, CBC and MBC. She has been a guest on McLaughlin, Charlie Rose and various Fox Television News programs. Email: sznmzr@aol.com

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 

Valerie Morse: The Security State: We Should Not Be Surprised, But We Should Be Worried

On the very day that the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security released her report into the actions of people the Prime Minister’s office in leaking classified Security Intelligence Service (NZSIS) documents to right-wing smearmonger Cameron ... More>>

Ramzy Baroud: PFLP Soul-Searching: Rise And Fall Of Palestine’s Socialists

When news reports alleged that the two cousins behind the Jerusalem synagogue attack on 18 November were affiliated with the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a level of confusion reigned. Why the PFLP? Why now? More>>

Valerie Morse: Key And NZ Police At G20: What A Contribution

While 200 New Zealand police officers are helping to repress protests outside of the G20 in Brisbane this week, John Key has been inside pushing the interests of giant multinational corporations to fast track the World Trade Organization (WTO) ... More>>

ALSO:

Gabriela Coutiño: Ayotzinapa Caravan Meets With EZLN In Oventic

In their visit to Zapatista Territory, parents of the 43 students disappeared from Ayotzinapa Guerrero, agreed with the Zapatista National Liberation Army (EZLN), to articulate a national grassroots movement that would question forced disappearances ... More>>

Ramzy Baroud: Talk Of A Third Intifada: Where To From Here, Palestine?

When a journalist tries to do a historian’s job, the outcome can be quite interesting. Using history as a side note in a brief news report or political analysis oftentimes does more harm than good. More>>

ALSO:

David Swanson: Who Says Ferguson Can't End Well

Just as a police officer in a heightened state of panic surrounded by the comfort of impunity will shoot an innocent person, the Governor of Missouri has declared a state of emergency preemptively, thus justifying violence in response to something ... More>>

Melanie Duval-Smith: Homeless Is Where The Heart Is

So, you are not allowed to feed the homeless on the streets of Florida. Last week, a 90 year old man and two Christian ministers were arrested for doing just that. I can hear the cries of the right wingers from here. “Not in our back yard”, ... More>>

John Chuckman: What We Truly Learned From the Great War and the Absurdity of Remembrance Day

No matter what high-blown claims the politicians make each year on Remembrance Day, The Great War was essentially a fight between two branches of a single royal family over the balance of power on the continent of Europe, British foreign policy holding ... More>>

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Top Scoops
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news