Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


BORA: Courts now allowed to declare inconsistencies

8:35 pm on 26 February 2018

Cabinet has agreed in principle to allow the courts to make a declaration if they believe legislation is inconsistent with the Bill of Rights.

The new Justice Minister Andrew Little says the three strikes law hasn't worked. Photo: RNZ / Rebekah Parsons-King

This would be done by a "declaration of inconsistency", but someone would have to bring a case to court before that could happen.

Once such a declaration was made, Parliament would have to reconsider the legislation with the option of amending it, repealing it, or making no change at all.

Parliament regularly ignores reports from the Attorney-General that legislation is not consistent with the Bill of Rights.

Justice Minister Andrew Little said the declaration would be an extra check and balance on the actions of MPs when passing laws.

"The government supports the senior courts making declarations of inconsistency where there is a legislative power.

"As there is currently no explicit power in the Bill of Rights Act, amending the act will allow for this," he said.

However, Attorney-General David Parker said the courts would not have any ability to change or repeal legislation.

"The courts would not be able to strike down statutory law and Parliament would retain its sovereignty."

Once in place, any law on the statute books could be subject to a declaration, if a case was brought.

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Gordon Campbell: On Politely Fake Political Obituaries (And The Paris Discord)

One unfortunate side effect of “personality politics” is that when prominent politicians die, the niceties we observe at the death of private individuals get automatically extended to them as well... More>>


Unique And Vanishing: NZ Biodiversity Losses Match Global Crisis

One might think that it is buffered from some of the effects of biological erosion, especially since people only arrived less than 800 years ago. But as we show, the impact on wildlife has been catastrophic. More>>

Your Name Here(ish): Sponsor A Section On! has just launched Section Sponsorships - the newest way for you to gain exposure for your brand to Scoop’s high value audience of 500,000 monthly readers. More>>


You Did It! The Scoop 3.0 PledgeMe Closes

Update: The Scoop 3.0 Crowdsale and Crowdfunding Campaign met its target with a total of $36,024 pledged. It looks like it has all been worthwhile. We are nearly there and will ride again in 2019, our 20th year of operations. Moreover the past week has brought a number of inquiries from larger organisations, many of which have till now failed to respond to our messages... More>>


Lyndon Hood: Quiz: Advice For Nats On Collins Leadership, Or Quote From Indiana Jones Fan Fic?

In a recent rest home speech, Judith Collins pitched for the leadership of her party, while at the same time the ghost of Margaret Thatcher struggled to regain control of Collins’ body from the incoherent raging demon that animates Western ethno-nationalist protofascism. More>>