Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Afghan raid inquiry needed to dispel confusion - lawyer

A lawyer representing Afghan people caught up in a defence force raid in 2010 says persisting confusion about the detail shows an independent inquiry is needed.

Hit and Run Photo: Supplied

The 2017 book Hit and Run alleged six civilians were killed and 15 injured in a raid on two villages in Afghanistan but the New Zealand Defence Force denied the extent of the raids and disagreed on several details.

In a newly public report, the defence force admitted for the first time that photographs in the book do show the raid's location.

However, it said the authors had labelled the areas in the photographs incorrectly.

One of the lawyers helping the Afghans civilians seek a government inquiry here, Deborah Manning, said the defence force was causing more confusion.

The people she represents know the name of their village and what happened there - and that was what counted, she said.

"The public are becoming more and not less confused about what the New Zealand Defence Force is trying to say," she said.

"Serious allegations have been raised and these need to be looked at by an independent body who is able to look at these thorougly and in a clear and impartial manner."

The defence force said the raid took place in Tirgiran Village but Hit and Run says it took place in Naik and Khak Khuday Dad.

Ms Manning says there is no village called Tirgiran - it is the name of a region in the same way Waikato is a region, rather than a town.

"My clients have always been very clear about when the operation happened, where it happened and what happened, which was in their villages called Khak Khuday Dad and Naik ... so I'm confounded as to how the NZDF say our clients don't know the name of their own villages."

The defence force said regardless of the disagreement about details, the operation did not go the way the book alleges.

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Binoy Kampmark: Tom Wolfe The Parajournalist

As New Journalism’s primary advocate, Tom Wolfe headed the field with such experimental forces as Norman Mailer, Truman Capote and Hunter S. Thompson, all dedicated to enriching supposedly factual accounts with excessive flourishes that hurried out the beige in favour of the kaleidoscopic. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Racism And The Windsors

For all the talk about the modernizing effect that Meghan Markle could have on the Royal Family, the suspicion all along has been that the House of Windsor is resistant to change at any level beyond the purely decorative. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Prospects Of US Talks With North Korea

On June 12, the leaders of North Korea and the United States will meet across a table in Singapore, and Kim Jong Un must already be feeling giddy at the thought that this meeting is already being described with the word “summit” formerly reserved for meetings between superpowers of equal stature... Image: Steve Bolton NZ's contribution to the IAEA’s work on North Korea

  • United Nations - UN chief ‘optimistic’ over peace efforts
  • David Swanson - Enough is Enough. The Time Has Come to BDS the US - Peace Comes to Korea: Let’s Understand Why
  • CTBTO - CTBTO on North Korea
  • NZ Govt - NZ welcomes talks between North and South Korea
  • Massey University - Nukes to cyber war – NZ security in focus
  • Jim Miles - The Doomsday Machine - Confessions of a Nuclear War Planner
  • UNHCHR - North Korea detente: UN expert urges human rights opening
  • Binoy Kampmark - Trump, North Korea and Post-Olympic Angst
  • Gordon Campbell: On National’s Latest Attempts At Relevance

    Having ignored the existence of massive problems in health and education for nine years in government, it is no longer politically viable for National to maintain the pretence that such problems really don’t exist, or are somehow unworthy of serious concern by rational men of commerce.... More>>

    Gordon Campbell: On The Need For Immediate Action On WINZ

    So the old saying goes, the main difference between the centre-right and centre-left is that both believe in market solutions, but the centre-left spends a lot more time worrying about the effects, afterwards. More>>

    Gordon Campbell: On Petrol Pricing And The Midwives March

    The public brawl between Energy Minister Megan Woods and BP looks like spinning off – as brawls tend to do – into a whole array of extraneous matters. Evidently, some people find it hard to see the difference between taxes and profits. More>>