Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search

 

ACC payout 'one benefit' law ruled discriminatory

ACC payout 'one benefit' law ruled discriminatory by Human Rights Tribunal

Phil Pennington, Reporter

A tribunal has backed a woman in a decade-long fight over laws that cut her ACC (Accident Compensation Corporation) payout from $40,000 to just $500.

A Ministry of
Social Development sign

The Ministry of Social Development says it is unable to make any change in practice despite the Tribunal's finding. Photo: RNZ/ Rebekah Parsons-King

The Human Rights Review Tribunal has ruled a section of Social Security law is discriminatory.

Maree Hennessy, a mother-of-two originally from Waikato, had her ACC payout in 2010 cut to almost nothing because all her welfare benefits were deducted from it, under the government's "one benefit" principle.

The new ruling does not get her any more money, even though the Ministry of Social Development agrees with it, and wanted this declaration to avoid the need for more litigation.

"For those of our clients who are receiving income support from us and compensation from ACC, we are unable to make any change in practice despite the Tribunal's finding," the ministry said in a statement, adding it must implement the law as it is.



Ms Hennessy was too ill to talk to RNZ.

Lawyer Greg Robins, speaking on her behalf, said she regarded it as worth fighting for anyway.

"It's always going to be a landmark declaration of this sort ... it's clear and it's unequivocal and it places the issue squarely on the agenda," Mr Robins said.

About 600 other people currently get both income support and ACC so might be hit by the law, which has been in place for decades.

"It is disappointing Maree won't receive a backdated payment," said Mr Robins, from the Office of Human Rights Proceedings.

"But she was aware of that and so were we. This was the best outcome we could have hoped for."

The big sum she misses out on would have gone a long way to alleviating her situation, he said.

"She has fallen on hard financial times and despite those hard financial times and her injuries, she has kept on battling for this case and for that we are really appreciative."

Ms Hennessy was injured in 2002, and first fought ACC for coverage.

When she got the eroded payout in 2010, she then argued and lost at both the district court and Social Security Appeal Authority that her circumstances had been wrongly assessed under the law.

This Human Rights Review Tribunal ruling has now found the law itself discriminates on the prohibited grounds of "employment status".

The government has until later this month to appeal the ruling, or until June to respond to it.

Minister of Social Development Carmel Sepuloni tabled a two-page report on the problem in Parliament in December.

She told RNZ she had raised the problem of ACC and benefits with the Welfare Expert Advisory Group.

The independent group is due to report back at the end of this month, which could lead to law changes.

However, the Social Security Act was already altered just last year, and this discriminatory feature remained in place.

"The intention of the 2018 change was to simplify the law not to make any fundamental policy changes. Changes of this nature would have been significant ones," MSD said in a statement.

"The intention was always to look at more significant policy changes on a longer time frame."


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Top Scoops Headlines

 

Gordon Campbell: On America’s ‘Green New Deal’

‘Socialism’ is more of a political scare word than an objective condition. Even in the US, as Nate Silver’s 538 website pointed out this week there is polling evidence that modern Americans are inclined to treat socialism as meaning ‘equality’ rather than the ‘government ownership or control’ that Americans understood the term to mean back in the 1940s... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Nelson Fire And Climate Change

The Nelson fire has been a useful warning of things to come, given how climate change will (a) increase the likelihood of reduced rainfall and drought-like conditions in many parts of New Zealand, which – obviously – will raise (b) the fire danger and (c) the cost of providing the communities at risk with the enhanced firefighting capabilities that they’re going to need. More>>

ALSO:


Gordon Campbell: On Listening To Ocasio-Cortez About Tax

In its attitudes to tax, New Zealand has been the last colonial outpost of Thatcherism. Change, however, may be in the air. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The US Exit From Afghanistan

To state the bleedingly obvious, US military forces have done a good deal of harm over the past 50 years from Central America to Asia to Africa. That history is now tending to obscure the harm that’s being done by the polar opposite impulse: American isolationism... More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Brexit Vote Aftermath

So, what happens next? Normally when a major policy like this gets so crushingly rejected – by 230 votes, when Theresa May had reportedly been hoping for a defeat by “only” 70- 100 votes – the PM would resign and/or a fresh election called. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Our History Of Selling Out The Kurds

For the past 100 years, the West has sold out the Kurds over and over again. So much so that it came as a surprise yesterday when US National Security advisor John Bolton appeared to walk back the latest act of betrayal... More>>

ALSO: