Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


DHBs seek urgent ERA ruling over union statements

DHBs seek urgent ERA ruling over doctor union's 'inaccurate' statements

Karen Brown, Health Correspondent

District health boards are accusing the junior doctors' union of making statements in public and to its members that are inaccurate and misleading and or deceptive.

strikers holding
placards by the road

Junior doctors have already held three strikes with another one scheduled for next week and a fifth being considered. Photo: RNZ / Brooke Jenner

District health boards say the Resident Doctors' Association (RDA) has breached good-faith bargaining requirements and has written to the Employment Relations Authority asking it to intervene urgently.

However, the union disputes the DHB's claims.

The request to intervene was made by all 20 DHBs last Wednesday. It comes amid ongoing strike action by the doctors, who walked off the wards last week for 48 hours and will do so again on 26 February, with a fifth strike being considered for 12 March.

The latest round of mediation on Friday ended with the RDA saying DHBs were demanding "unilateral power to make changes to RMOs [junior doctors'] terms and conditions of employment and made it clear that this is a non-negotiable position".

In their letter to the ERA, the DHBs said the RDA was "undermining the bargaining by passing inaccurate information about the bargaining to a third party which is publicly criticising the [DHBs'] bargaining position".

DHBs also upset with senior doctors' union

The DHBs wrote that a media release from the senior doctors' union - the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists - stated that an offer by the-then Medical Council chair, Andrew Connolly, to meet the parties involved in the dispute had been raised in mediation but rejected by DHBs.

However, the DHBs said this offer was never raised at all.

This is backed by the mediator Keith Shaw who said in a letter he did not recall it being discussed and could not find any reference at all to the Medical Council in his notes from the day.

DHBs said they asked the senior doctors' union to withdraw the release but it refused, saying it had discussed the issue with the RDA which was adamant it had proposed the Medical Council's offer at mediation.

Ian Powell Photo: Supplied

The DHBs said they were "extremely concerned by the role [senior doctors' union was] taking in this matter".

"Your union is not a party to the RMO bargaining, and as is demonstrated by the current situation, is not necessarily receiving accurate information about what is occurring."

They said the union's media statement was "neither appropriate nor helpful".

The DHBs said the junior doctors' union was required to bargain in good faith, but they say the union has made statements in public and/or to its members "that are inaccurate and/ or which were not provided to the [DHBs] prior to publication".

These statements had contributed to decisions made by the [union's] members to vote in favour of taking industrial action, and it was undermining bargaining, they said.

The DHBs also describe instances of what they said were inaccurate statements made in TV ads and in the media.

The ERA is yet to make a decision on the application.

Union disputes DHB claims

RDA senior advocate David Munro told Morning Report the union disputed the DHB's claims and would be "vigourously defending our position".

"We're confident of what we say, we've been doing this for a long time, we know what the rules are and we take them very seriously."

Mr Munro said it was disappointing the DHB had called in the ERA, and it would have little impact because the claim would not be heard until well after the dispute between the union and the DHBs had been settled.

"What's disappointing about this is they're spending this time tilting at legal windmills when they ought to be getting their ducks in a row and getting some decent position at the table to settle [this] dispute" - David Munro duration 5:49
from Morning Report

Click a link to play audio (or right-click to download) in either
MP3 format or in OGG format.

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


News Deserts: The Death March Of Local Journalism

Joseph Cederwall: The corporate media sector seems unable to do anything to halt the raging dumpster fire of consolidation, layoffs and centralisation of content production. All this means we are increasingly seeing ‘news deserts’ appearing in local communities. Illustration by Paul Sahre. More>>


Joseph Cederwall: Journalism Has A Problem - It’s Called Capitalism!

To the extent that solutions exist, they must be solutions that allow journalism to move outside of the broken system that has caused this situation. For this reason, a resurgence in more engaged and community focused local journalism offers hope for a way out of this situation. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Why Justin Trudeau's Fate Matters To NZ

The scandal now engulfing Justin Trudeau and his Liberal Party is the kind of train wreck that confirms the public's worst feelings about politicians and their back-room dealings. More>>

Joseph Cederwall: Venezuela; Oil, Neoliberalism And White Supremacy

Venezuela has been suffering a slow-burn, yet devastating internal insurgency and economic war since the optimistic beginnings of the ‘Bolivarian’ socialist revolution in 1998. More>>


Ramzy Baroud: What Price Netanyahu’s Victory

It is quite typical for Israeli politicians to carry out confrontational measures against Palestinians shortly before general elections are due. The nature of these measures is determined by the kind of political constituency that Israeli leaders aim to appease. More>>

  • PublicAddress
  • Pundit
  • Kiwiblog