Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


New legal action taken against 'Hit and Run' inquiry

New legal action taken against 'Hit and Run' inquiry

The lawyer representing the Afghan villagers in the inquiry into Operation Burnham has launched legal proceedings calling for a judicial review in the investigation.

Watch lawyer Deborah Manning speaking to media on the latest developments:

The inquiry was in response to allegations that members of the Defence Force killed six Afghan civilians during a military operation in 2010, then covered it up. The allegations were made in the book Hit & Run, by the journalists Nicky Hager and Jon Stephenson. The Defence Force disputes the claims saying secret drone footage disproves them.

The inquiry is hearing much of the evidence in secret. Chairs Sir Terence Arnold and Sir Geoffrey Palmer said all witnesses' evidence would be taken in closed hearings and much of the evidence would not be made public for safety reasons.

Deborah Manning, a human rights lawyer for some of the Afghan villagers at the centre of the claims, said last year her clients had been calling for the inquiry for a long time and had the right to hear what had happened.

Ms Manning filed legal papers in the High Court in Wellington today.

She said she wanted it to be clear that the inquiry should be fulfilling New Zealand's right to life obligations towards the civilians who died in the operation.

"The right to life investigation should be triggered by the state, it should not be for the victims to be knocking on doors and having doors closed and knocking on new doors over and over again to try and get access to justice. This has been too long and too hard and it should not be allowed to happen again."

She said this was sending a clear message to the state that it had an obligation to conduct a right to life investigation.

"We notified them and asked them to act on it two years ago, they failed. We took them to court, we thought they were going to do it, they've failed again."

Ms Manning compared the case to another in Ireland where a right to life inquiry was held after people allegedly involved with the Irish Republican Army were killed. In those cases, Ms Manning's colleagues have told her no information was withheld in inquiries, she said.

"In that context, there's very clear rulings that the families, the next of kin, have the right to know who was responsible for the deaths of their loved ones, to know their names and to be there to hear what they have to say."

The families of the civilians involved should not be kept on the sidelines awaiting a final report, she said.

"We thought that this was the inquiry we had been seeking in term of the events of Operation Burnham.

"We have been, I think it's fair to say, confused and concerned and now we're at the point where we can't continue to engage in a meaningful way because we're not part of this process, that's how it seems."

The argument for classified information

The Defence Force has been arguing in the inquiry that some information and hearings had to be held in secret due to classified information.

Hager had previously said the decision to run the process largely in secret was hugely disappointing.

"This is an inquiry that was called for by the public, granted by the current government because the public felt so strongly, and now it's been turned into a closed-shop, where the public will only get token briefings on peripheral, irrelevant issues," Hager said.

The lawyer assisting the inquiry, Kristy McDonald QC, said the inquiry submissions showed government agencies involved were worried the process could compromise New Zealand's security and international relations if classified information was made publicly available, and wanted a largely closed process.

Ms Manning said the focus of the inquiry should be to get to truth of what happened and that other important procedural matters would follow, including right to access of information and its disclosure.

"This inquiry has skewed, and the skewing is that - we say that the victims of Operation Burnham are our clients [the villagers].

"However, the way this inquiry has been operating is that the NZDF are the victims - they're the victims of allegations that have been made in the book and that they need to be able to defend themselves and their public reputation against those allegations."

The legal team's experience with classified information was not new, she said, and it should be kept a bare minimum.

Ms Manning said she accepted that there was information that needed protective measures, however, there were proper procedures that could identify which information should be held back and to what extent.

"We're not even adopting those measures, which are actually very controversial measures. Instead, what's happening is that the starting point is a closed process rather than an open process with some closed aspects."

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


There Is A Field: Reimagining Biodiversity In Aotearoa

We are in a moment of existential peril, with interconnected climate and biodiversity crises converging on a global scale to drive most life on Earth to the brink of extinction… These massive challenges can, however, be reframed as a once in a lifetime opportunity to fundamentally change how humanity relates to nature and to each other. Read on The Dig>>


Gordon Campbell: On The Barriers Facing Female Politicians

On the current evidence though, voters are less likely to regard a female politician as ‘likeable’ than a male one, and – even worse – this perception tends to become a barrier that only female candidates in the main, have to face. More>>

The Detail: Britain's Trump Is Now Its Prime Minister

Guardian journalist James Murray says Boris Johnson wears the hat that works, depending on what he’s trying to achieve. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Trump’s Open White Nationalism

By telling those four elected, American born and/or raised women of colour to “go home”, US President Donald Trump’s racist agenda has come out of the shadows. More>>


Mediaversaries: 20 Years Of The Scoop Information Ecosystem

Scoop celebrates its 20th anniversary this month. To celebrate, we are offering 20% off all ScoopPro subscriptions, including the newly launched ScoopPro Citizen service for Citizen readers. More>>