Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Insurance Council figures under fire

10 February 2000

Insurance Council figures under fire

The New Zealand Insurance Council's claim that there has been a more than 40 percent saving in workplace fatalities since the privatisation of workers' compensation was today challenged by Accident Insurance Minister Michael Cullen.

"The statement is based on inadequate and misleading analysis of the evidence, and is opportunistic in the extreme," Dr Cullen said.

The Council's figures cover the five months from July to November last year. During this time, there were 13 deaths from workplace accident. However by the end of December, the total had risen to 16, according to information supplied by the Accident Insurance Regulator.

"This was down on the same period in 1998 but up on 1997 when just 14 fatal workplace injuries were recorded," Dr Cullen said. "In other words, the point of comparison makes a great difference to the story the statistics tell. They are susceptible to manipulation.

"There is a further distortion in the Council's data base as experience shows the fatality rate tends to be much higher in the January to June months than in the second half of the year.

"For example, half of last year's fatalities occurred in the three months between January and March.

"And the Council is claiming credit for accident prevention work which should rightly go to ACC. The accident rate has been declining steadily in the last four years and was almost halved between 1995-96 and 1998-99.

"This reduction was in part due to public education campaigns led by the ACC. It is hard to imagine competing, profit-oriented insurance companies taking over that role from the ACC.

"That is a large part of the explanation for this Government's decision to rebuild ACC," Dr Cullen said. "We are determined to restore the focus on injury prevention and rehabilitation and believe these public interest objectives are best pursued by a publicly-owned organisation."


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


$1m Compensation Paid: First Gun Ban Event In Christchurch

The Police Minister says the first ever firearms collection event in Christchurch over the weekend was a huge success. But Stuart Nash had concerns about whether the participation reflected the number of weapons in the region.

More than 378 people handed in 542 guns and there was a mixed reaction from firearms owners. The total compensation cost amounted to $1,022,599... More>>


The Kids: Youth Parliament 2019 Event Kicks Off

120 Youth MPs and 20 Youth Press Gallery members have gathered in Wellington to attend the two-day Youth Parliament event ... More>>

Friends Like These: Foreign Minister To Visit USA

Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters will travel to Washington D.C. today for talks with senior members of the US Administration, and to attend the Ministerial to Advance Religious Freedom. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The Aussie Banks’ Latest Fee Hike Excuse

When the Reserve Bank sought feedback on its plans to require the country’s major banks to raise their capital reserves then you might have expected the banks to whine and complain. And so they have. More>>


Sitting On Defence: Terms Of Reference For Defence Estate Review

“The 81,000 hectare Defence estate is at a crossroads; much of it is run down, and outdated,” says Ron Mark. “It needs to be improved in order to gain, train and retain our service people, now and into the future." More>>


Meng Foon: Retiring Gisborne Mayor To Be Race Relations Commissioner

Andrew Little: “He has an outstanding record as a relationship builder and walks comfortably in the pākehā world, the Māori world, the Chinese community and other communities making up New Zealand." More>>


NCEA: Students Granted Qualifications After Fees Scrapped

Almost 150,000 current and former students with unpaid NCEA fees have today been formally awarded their NCEA credits or qualifications. More>>

Medical Cannabis: Consultation On Regulations

More widespread access to medicinal cannabis products is a step closer today with the release of proposals for regulations says Minister of Health Dr David Clark. More>>


Surrendered Under Protection Order, Lost: Nine Firearms Held By Police Disappear

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found multiple failings in respect of the disappearance of nine firearms which were held by Police in Auckland from 28 January 2017. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On New Zealand First’s Balancing Act

At this point, New Zealand First needs to more than double its current poll numbers to survive beyond Election Day, 2020… but that’s what Winston Peters is so very good at doing, once an election campaign begins in earnest... More>>

RNZ: Asbestos Court Victory Over ACC After Lung Cancer Death

The family of a woman who died of cancer caused by inhaling asbestos says their victory over ACC in the High Court is bittersweet. More>>





InfoPages News Channels