Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Cullen’s Feel-Good Super Scheme A Cruel Hoax

Thursday 9th Mar 2000
Rodney Hide
Media Release -- Social Welfare

Michael Cullen’s super scheme hinted at in yesterday’s Budget Policy Statement is being labelled a ‘cruel hoax’ by ACT Finance Spokesman Rodney Hide who says the money today’s taxpayers pay in for their retirement in good faith will be paid straight out again to today’s elderly.

“New Zealanders have been deceived time and time again by politicians promising to save their taxes to ensure their security and dignity in retirement. It is the cruellest of political hoaxes and Dr Cullen wants to inflict the same deception on not just the baby boomers, but the younger New Zealanders who will pay their taxes into his fund.

“To make it worse Labour’s policy of high taxes penalises New Zealanders who are trying to save for their own retirement.

“Michael Cullen’s scheme is no solution to the country’s pension problems.

“Dr Cullen’s scheme is a Ponzi scheme – named after Charles Ponzi – because the dedicated tax does not stay in the fund but goes straight out again to fund existing pensions. If anyone other than the Government was planning to hawk such a scheme they would go straight to jail for fraud.

“The other problem is one of simple financing. Michael Cullen proposes building up the fund instead of paying off government debt.. This is like a householder saving for their retirement while servicing an expensive mortgage.

“The interest cost on the Government’s debt is 7.5%. It’s hard to see Cullen’s appointed guardians earning such a return on the state-super fund. The result is a net destruction of wealth.

“The best thing Dr Cullen can do with any surplus cash is to pay off existing debt,” said Rodney Hide.


For more information visit ACT online at or contact the ACT Parliamentary Office at

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Politics Of Scaring Voters Back Into Line

Fear has always been a useful mobilising tool in politics… yet in 2017, bogeymen of all shapes and sizes seem to have fallen on hard times. For years, the National party had painted itself as being the only reliable defensive bastion against the terrifying prospect of a centre-left government…

In fact, the polls suggest that the public seems to quite like the new government, its Prime Minister, and its proposed plan of action. Somehow, even though a Labour/Greens/NZ First government is in power, the sun is still rising and setting, on time. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Drinking Water As A Failure Of Political Leadership

It is almost possible to feel sorry for the Health Ministry in their terrible, no good, very bad week... More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Saying ‘Work For The Dole,’ Nicely

As New Zealand First learned the hard way from its two previous periods in government, small parties in MMP coalitions get blamed for the unpopular stuff done by their senior partner in power, but no one remembers the good stuff the junior player brought to the table... More>>


Seismic Blasting: Greenpeace Launches Legal Challenge Against Amazon Warrior

A legal challenge against the world’s largest seismic oil exploration ship was launched at a public rally on Parliament Lawn. More>>


Tertiary: 80,000 People Eligible For Fees Free

The Government has today made good on its 100-day promise of delivering the first year of fees-free post school training and education and industry training from 1 January next year, says Education Minister Chris Hipkins. More>>


PM's Presser: Rebuilding Cathedrals, Felling Trees

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern attended the press conference today with Minister for Greater Christchurch Regeneration Dr Megan Woods to announce urgent legislation this week for the rebuilding of the Christ Church Cathedral. More>>





Featured InfoPages