Parliament

Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search

 

David Dougherty To Be Compensated

Minister of Justice Phil Goff announced today that the Government has agreed that compensation should be paid to David Dougherty.

“David Dougherty was convicted in 1993 on charges of abduction and sexual violation by rape of a girl then aged 11. He was acquitted on retrial in 1997. The Government has now accepted, following a report by Mr Stuart Grieve, QC, that Mr Dougherty is innocent of these charges and that his eligibility for compensation for wrongful conviction and imprisonment has been established,” Mr Goff said.

“The Government has now asked Mr Grieve to provide further advice as to the appropriate quantum of compensation payable to Mr Dougherty.”

David Dougherty’s conviction was based largely on the complainant’s identification of Mr Dougherty as the offender.

Forensic material was obtained from the complainant’s body and clothing but the amount of DNA material in the samples was insufficient to establish whether or not Mr Dougherty was a possible source, using the techniques which were available at that time.

Subsequent testing using a new DNA technique showed that DNA material from a person other than Mr Dougherty was present on the complainant’s underpants.

In June 1996 the Governor-General referred the matter back to the Court of Appeal under section 406 of the Crimes Act and a retrial was ordered. The retrial took place in April 1997 and Mr Dougherty was acquitted.

In November 1997 the then Government agreed to the adoption of interim criteria for evaluating claims for compensation or ex gratia payments in criminal cases but declined Mr Dougherty’s claim for compensation pending the outcome of further police inquiries.



On 28 November 1998, the Police investigation being effectively at end, the then Minister of Justice referred Mr Dougherty’s claim to Mr Stuart Grieve, QC, for independent assessment of whether it met the Cabinet interim criteria.

“I received Mr Grieve’s initial report at the end of November 2000,” Mr Goff said.

“Mr Grieve has conducted a thorough investigation of the case, including having the relevant DNA samples retested in Australia and interviewing the complainant in the presence of her mother and a Queen’s Counsel appointed to represent her” Mr Goff said.

“While the complainant maintained her identification of Mr Dougherty as the offender, the new DNA testing showed with even greater certainty than the earlier tests that seminal stains on the complainants underpants and certain other samples came from a person other than Mr Dougherty.

“Mr Grieve concluded the most likely explanation was that the complainant was mistaken in her identification.

‘The interim criteria for compensation require among other things that the claimant establish that he or she is innocent on the balance of probabilities. Mr Grieve concluded that Mr Dougherty’s has established his innocence to the required standard.

“While Mr Grieve has yet to make recommendations about the amount of compensation the Government considers it important that Mr Grieve’s findings are released now so that Mr Dougherty’s name can be cleared.

“I have asked Mr Grieve to report further to me with recommendations on quantum. I expect to receive this report by no later than April 2001.

“When a person is wrongfully convicted and suffers the trauma of trial, conviction, and imprisonment, there should be payment to help that individual recover losses and to compensate for the undeserved punishment they have suffered. The Government therefore has committed itself to pay compensation to Mr Dougherty at a level to be determined following Mr Grieve’s second report,” Mr Goff said.


ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Anti-Corbyn Split In British Labour

The resignation of seven UK Labour MPs in protest against the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn is another example of the centre-left’s readiness to sabotage its own cause – such things are always allegedly done on principle – even if the outcome hands the country over to Conservative rule for five more years.

Certainly, a technician hot-miked at the splitters’ press conference was pretty sure this would now be the outcome, and he accidentally informed the nation to that effect. More>>

 
 

Auckland Action Against Poverty: Motels Profit From Housing Crisis

A single motel which charges up to $1,500 per week per room has received over $3 million worth of Government funds to provide emergency assistance, despite never having a Code Compliance Certificate – an offence under the Building Act – and receiving a series of longstanding complaints from occupants... More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Alleged China Relations Crisis

If New Zealand’s relations with China are ‘deteriorating’ then you still need a microscope to detect the signs... More>>

ALSO:

Environment: Government To End Tenure Review

“Tenure review has resulted in parcels of land being added to the conservation estate, but it has also resulted in more intensive farming and subdivision on the 353,000 ha of land which has been freeholded. This contributed to major landscape change and loss of habitat for native plants and animals,” said Eugenie Sage. More>>

ALSO:

Bell Tolls: Big Changes, Grand Mergers Planned For Vocational Training

“At a time when we’re facing critical skill shortages, too many of our polytechnics and institutes of technology are going broke... More>>

ALSO:

Sallies' State Of The Nation: Progress Stalled In Reducing Inequality

The report shows a lack of tangible progress in key areas including record levels of household debt and a growing gap in educational achievement between poorer and more well off communities. More>>

ALSO:

Party Politics In Tax Morale Survey: SSC To Seek Answers From IRD

Minister of State Services Chris Hipkins has today asked the State Services Commissioner Peter Hughes to examine IRD’s reported inappropriate use of a public survey. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels