Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


ACT Lawyer Helps The Government

Sunday 2 Dec 2001

ACT wants to help ensure this week's debate on criminal defamation leaves us with the best law we can get in the circumstances, Justice Spokesman MP Stephen Franks said today.

"I attach a redraft which I think the Greens will support".

"I should not have to be assisting the Government like this. I know, as a careful lawyer, that even with the attention this provision is getting now, unintended bugs will remain. We aren't having the Select Committee submissions designed to pick these things up.

"And I am flabbergasted at how bad the Attorney General is as a lawyer, even with all the officials to help her.

"If I were her I would now be too ashamed ever again to offer law lessons, as she has, several times, to the other lawyers in Parliament. It should be just too embarrassing to have sprung a clause, claiming that it would prevent false claims about election candidates, and wasn't a threat to free speech, when it:

· Didn't touch lies at public meetings, however disgraceful, and however many people heard them;

· Didn't touch lies on radio;

· Didn't touch lies on television;

· Could criminalize innocent journalists with no reason to think they were reporting false statements;

· In many circumstances would let the originating liar off scot free, while the media were liable;

· Arguably allowed prosecutions for statements of opinion.

"If I were a former law professor I wouldn't want to show my face again if - after two weeks of controversy, and time to think about the problems - my patch up replacement clause had a glaring new error and didn't fix the most serious of the old ones. That is what has happened.

"The new error is in using `recklessness'. As well as outlawing radio talkback and other reporting where the reporter can't practically take care to avoid broadcasting callers' false statements, it probably criminalizes internet service providers who don't censor the chat rooms and email traffic of their customers.

"And the old error not fixed is that it still seems to allow prosecution for expressions of opinion. Even a cursory comparison with the clause I promoted should have warned her of that. My clause 199A is confined to false statements of fact.

"I hope my draft SOP will help the Parliament to get where the Attorney General might have wanted to go in the first place.

"It is seriously worrying that our Attorney General may lack the basic legal skills needed for the Crown's Chief Legal Officer and guardian of the Bill of Rights. Proficiency in Political Correctness 1,2 and 3 may get promotion in academia, but it does not help much in drafting or applying real law," Mr Franks said.


ATTACHED: ACT Select Order Paper showing the Attorney General's proposal, with ACT's changes.

Supplementary Order Paper

Electoral Amendment Bill (No. 2)

Proposed Amendments

Stephen Franks, in Committee, to move the following amendments:

Clause 51B New section 199B Defaming candidate at election time

That the proposed section 199B to be inserted in clause 51B by the amendment moved by the Hon Margaret Wilson be further amended as shown below by omitting the words struck through and by adding the words underlined.

"199B Defaming candidate at election time

Every person commits an offence and is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding $5000 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 3 months who, knowing a statement to be false [DEL: in a material particular :DEL] [DEL: or being re :DEL] [DEL: ckless as to whether the statement :DEL] [DEL: is false in a material particular :DEL] publishes or exposes the statement to public view, or causes the statement to be published or exposed to public view, or broadcasts the statement, or causes or permits the statement to be broadcast, at any time in the period commencing on writ day and ending with the close of the poll, if[INS: and to the extent that :INS] the statement is -[INS: :INS]

[INS: (a) of fact; and :INS]

[DEL: (a) :DEL] [INS: (b) :INS] defamatory of any candidate; and

[DEL: (b) :DEL] [INS: (c) :INS] [DEL: calculated :DEL] [INS: intended and :INS] likely to influence the vote of any elector."

Explanatory note

Threats to free speech and robust election coverage are very serious. Parliament should not leave avoidable uncertainty. Among other reasons, test cases are very expensive, and until uncertainties are resolved free speech can be chilled by a simple prudent news media desire to avoid any risk. This amendment deals with two elementary issues, and one technical matter. The first must be fixed. The other two should be fixed.

`Recklessness' as a ground for criminal prosecution must be deleted to protect the reporter or broadcaster who faithfully conveys what is said by public figures. Often there is no reasonable likelihood or means of checking the facts, or the circumstances make it ridiculous to expect the journalist to check. But `recklessness' can mean in legal terms, not taking any precautions. Precautions are often unrealistic. TV1 for example, broadcasting a debate live, would have to try to censor the debate in case one of the candidates said something untrue. For radio talkback this is the constant condition.

The public should be allowed to know what candidates are saying. If they lie, the public can judge character. Free speech is chilled if the journalist is forced by fear of prosecution (or the cautious editor's instructions) to censor anything they think might be questionable.

2. Only statements of fact are actionable in ordinary defamation. It is quite unclear whether the criminal defamation clause is similarly restrained. If prosecutions could be started for wrong opinions the police would never have the resources to deal with all the potential claims in political debate. We must ensure there is no uncertainty on this point, by restricting the claim to statements of fact.

There should be no risk of criminal proceedings over statements of opinion. Whether opinions are right or wrong is the heart of political debate and the police should be nowhere near those issues.

The word `calculated' in common usage means `intended'. A legal meaning is `likely'. Now knowledge is being inserted as a requirement for liability, the purpose of the word `calculated' should be put beyond debate.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Malaysia Exposing Our Dodgy Policies On China

Last week, we all owed a vote of thanks to Malaysian PM Mahathir Mohamad for breaking with protocol during his bilateral meeting in Singapore with New Zealand PM Jacinda Ardern. Reportedly, Mahathir used the photo opportunity phase of the meeting – which usually involves just an exchange of smiles and pleasantries before the media is sent out of the room – to launch into matters of genuine substance.

By doing so, Mahathir usefully exposed how New Zealand is trying to make a virtue out of sitting on the fence over the South China Sea dispute. More>>


Climate Change: Top Academics Call On Government To Take Action

One hundred and fifty academics and researchers from around Aotearoa, including Dame Anne Salmond, Emeriti Professors and several Fellows of the Royal Society, have signed a strongly-worded open letter to the Government demanding bold and urgent action to tackle climate change. More>>


Teacher Qualifications, Class Sizes: Ten Year Plan For Early Learning

“Moving towards 100 percent qualified teachers in early childhood education centres and improving adult:child ratios are among some of the key proposals for change put forward by the sector and experts in the new draft ten year strategic plan for early learning,” Chris Hipkins said. More>>


Teacher Strikes: Meeting, March And Rally In Wellington

Throughout the Wellington region the NZEI rolling strikes entered their final day Friday. Thousands of teachers met in Wellington, Kapiti, Porirua and the Wairarapa. More>>


14/11: Two Years’ Progress Since The Kaikoura Earthquake

Mayor John Leggett said it was a day for reflection, but also a time to recognise the work by many people to support progress towards recovery made across Marlborough since November 2016. More>>


Pike River: Mine Drift Re-Entry Plan To Proceed

“I’ve decided the Te Kāhui Whakamana Rua Tekau Mā Iwa - Pike River Recovery Agency, recommended course of action to enter the drift, using the existing access tunnel, is by far the safest option,” said Andrew Little. More>>


Appointments: New High Commissioner To Australia Announced

“Dame Annette King needs no introduction given her long running career as a parliamentarian where she has previously held a number senior Cabinet portfolios, including Justice, Police and Health. She also was Parliament’s longest serving female MP with 30 years’ service,” said Mr Peters. More>>


Two Years Since Kaikoura: Silvia Cartwright To Lead Inquiry Into EQC

“The inquiry will be the first of its kind under the Public Inquiries Act 2013 and will have all the powers of a Royal Commission, be independent of Government and make its report directly to the Governor-General. More>>





InfoPages News Channels